Showing posts with label Freedom of Speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedom of Speech. Show all posts

Friday, January 31, 2025

NJ Should Pass on the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s Definition of Anti-Semitism

 New Jersey Spotlight News reports that there is Strong support in Assembly for adopting IHRA definition of antisemitism, but adds that “Aspects of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition are controversial.” Indeed. NJSN reports:

The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition underlines widely accepted aspects of antisemitism, including statements that the Holocaust was a lie or exaggerated, or claiming that Jewish people control the media. What has proved controversial is the part of the definition that specifies certain criticisms of Israel — that Israel is a racist state, and that Israelis should be held to a different standard than other democracies — as antisemitic.


“This has nothing to do with Jews. This is about protecting Israel,” said Raz Segal, an associate professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Stockton University. “It silences Palestinians who, for example, will say that Israel is a racist state, which is a very legitimate critique against any other state in the world, including the United States.”


The International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition includes this example:


"Denying the Jewish people their right to self-determination, e.g., by claiming that the existence of a State of Israel is a racist endeavor."


Of course, identifying "the Jewish People" as a collective is racist, by definition. A group of Jews has no right to a state that legally prioritizes Jews over non-Jews. A legitimate state recognizes individual rights equally for all. If the above IHRA example is taken literally, then the state of Israel is a racist endeavor. All individuals have a right to their own personal self-determination, whether acting individually or in voluntary agreement with others as a group. But none should be favored or disfavored under the law.


So, is the State of Israel designed to guarantee only the Jewish people their collective right to self-determination?] If so, Israel is racist. But Israel's Declaration of Independence states: 


THE STATE OF ISRAEL will be the Jewish people their right to self-determination and for the Ingathering of the Exiles; it will foster the development of the country for the benefit of all its inhabitants; it will be based on freedom, justice and peace as envisaged by the prophets of Israel; it will ensure complete equality of social and political rights to all its inhabitants irrespective of religion, race or sex; it will guarantee freedom of religion, conscience, language, education and culture; it will safeguard the Holy Places of all religions; and it will be faithful to the principles of the Charter of the United Nations.


Despite the opening nod to  "the Jewish people [and] their right to self-determination," that paragraph doesn't sound racist to me. In fact, Israel, while majority Jewish, includes 20% Palestinian, ranging from Arab descent to Christian orientation, as well as Muslim. There are atheists and the non-Jews also, all of whom live in equality under the law. But the point is that accusing Israel of being a racist state, or of having racist policies or laws, does not necessarily make that person anti-Semitic. The IHRA definition of antisemitism seems to shield racists who happen to be Jewish from criticism. But a racist who happens to be Jewish is still racist, and people should be free to call that person out without being accused of being an anti-Semite. 


The IHRA definition of antisemitism includes some uncontroversial manifestations. For example:


Accusing Jews as a people of being responsible for real or imagined wrongdoing committed by a single Jewish person or group, or even for acts committed by non-Jews.


Yes, this is anti-Semitic. But such views are racist across the board. Substitute “Jews” with black and “Jewish” with black (or any other ethnic group), and you still get racism. Racism is the idea that a person's beliefs, character, choices, and moral standing are inherited through body chemistry—such as skin color, genes, or blood—and thus should be judged by the actions of ancestors of his ethnic group. That definition already describes anti-Semitism. It doesn’t need a special exception. 


The IHRA’s definition of antisemitism is a bad, biased definition. It seems more designed to shield Jews from criticism than to present an objective definition of anti-Semitism.


I should clarify that NJ’s adoption of the IHRA’s definition of antisemitism would not have legal teeth, as there are no hate speech laws in the state, which would be anti-free speech and unConstitutional under the First Amendment. NJSN reports:


A bill that would have New Jersey adopt the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance’s definition of antisemitism has overwhelming support in the state Assembly, with three primary sponsors and 56 co-sponsors out of 80 possible representatives.


Supporters say a clear definition of antisemitism would protect Jewish people and make hate speech easier to spot and stamp out.


But it is clearly a step toward censorship, especially given the prevalence of DEI initiatives in NJ. The government should never be in the business of “stamping out” any speech, either explicitly through laws or implicitly through biased legal language.


Related Reading:


Racism—Ayn Rand


Fighting Racism With Collectivism is No Way to Exterminate Racism


Facebook Backtracks on Free Speech Policy; Political Extortion?


Individualism vs. Collectivism: Our Future, Our Choice—Craig Biddle


Monday, January 13, 2025

Axios’s Slam of Meta’s Elimination of Fact-Checking System Exhibits Shocking Political Ignorance—Or Worse?

Meta just walked away from fact-checking, and AXIOS didn’t like it one bit. In More Speech and Fewer Mistakes, Meta’s Chief Global Affairs Officer, Joel Kaplan, explained:


In recent years we’ve developed increasingly complex systems to manage content across our platforms, partly in response to societal and political pressure to moderate content. This approach has gone too far. As well-intentioned as many of these efforts have been, they have expanded over time to the point where we are making too many mistakes, frustrating our users and too often getting in the way of the free expression we set out to enable. Too much harmless content gets censored, too many people find themselves wrongly locked up in “Facebook jail,” and we are often too slow to respond when they do. 


We want to fix that and return to that fundamental commitment to free expression. Today, we’re making some changes to stay true to that ideal.


The changes? “Ending Third Party Fact Checking Program, Moving to Community Notes.” These “Independent Experts,” Kaplan explained, are “like everyone else.” [They] have their own biases and perspectives. This showed up in the choices some made about what to fact check and how. 


Great!


But in Behind the Curtain: The new gatekeepers, Axios responded:


The truth is, it is an almost impossible task for companies to police speech without bias or unfairness. That leaves two other options — the government or individuals. Both X and Meta are choosing people, with an imperfect ‘community notes’ mechanism to correct misinformation in real time.


That opens most of social media up as a Wild West of expression, where high-quality, trustworthy information will commingle with garbage and misinformation. That's what free speech absolutists have long fought for.


There isn't a tyrant past or present who wouldn't cheer Axios. What does Axios think the government is? It's people. Individuals. The only difference is that the government people are armed. Axios apparently believes that individuals, acting privately, are incapable of distinguishing between high-quality, trustworthy information and garbage and misinformation, but individuals backed by the power of legalized force—the law—are somehow capable of creating that perfect mechanism by successfully making that distinction! This, from a private media company!


Axios acts like "government or [private] individuals" is a balanced choice. Nothing can be further from the truth. Government has a legal monopoly on the use of force and violence. A government edict is imposed on all media, leaving both media owners and consumers no choice—and with the power to levy fines and jail terms for saying the “wrong” thing. A private individual (or company) has no such legal power of coercion of any kind. A Mark Zuckerberg speech regulation, or lack thereof, only affects his own company, which is subject to competition, leaving the field open to other platforms with different content moderation standards—and consumers free to switch and choose. 


But, in Axios’s view, we end up with some "Wild West of expression," which implies lawlessness. WRONG! Speech cannot be legally used to violate others' rights. That's why we have laws against inciting violence, making terroristic threats, or endangering public safety. We have libel and slander laws to give victims a chance to recover damages inflicted by others’ lies. Our real danger is a Wild West of arbitrary government speech regulation.


The choice "government or individuals" is a choice of despotism or individual freedom—nothing more and nothing less. The very fact that the choice is even posed as legitimate and balanced shows shocking ignorance of basic political philosophy, of America's very Founding ideals, and of history more broadly—or, worse, an understanding of the stakes involved with Axios deliberately opening the door to despotism, with Axios becoming one of the government’s gatekeepers. As Megan McArdle presciently puts it,


If you see someone advocating for more suppression of dangerous speech — be it heresy, hate speech or “misinformation” — you can be sure they expect their side to have exclusive use of the ban-hammer.


I’ll give Axios the benefit of the doubt and assume ignorance. But what does that say about the state of knowledge in our culture that a widely read social media outlet like Axios can spread such political misinformation with apparent impunity? 


Private platforms, of course, have a right to moderate content posted on their platforms by their customers. And they may find that some form of content moderation or suggestive bylines are necessary. Still, kudos to Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg for championing the powerful idea of intellectual freedom through  global information platforms governed by free speech — and the people — not by the platforms themselves.


The very idea of centralized fact-checking, whether by a private media company,  which is legitimate but can be problematic, or by the government, which is downright dangerous, ignores a crucial fact. What’s lost in all of the hand wringing over social media misinformation is the fact that it’s never been easier for the average person to do his own fact-checking.  Remember that consumers can easily reference professional fact-checkers on their own. All we need to do is get off of our lazy mental asses and do a bit of intellectual labor. 


Related Reading:


The Nature of Government, by Ayn Rand, From Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal


The First Amendment Restricts Government, Not Private Citizens


Here’s the truth: Meta ending fact-checking is a win against censorship by Megan McArdle for WAPO.


The fact that merely letting people talk to each other feels like a dangerous concession to the right tells you just how much power progressives had amassed. Ironically, it reminds me of a quote cited often when conservatives complained about progressives throttling their opinions: “When you’re accustomed to privilege, equality feels like oppression.”


Meta's Content Moderation Turnabout by Roger Pielke Jur. for The Honest Broker


A Lesson From 1930s Germany: Beware State Control of Social Media By Heidi Tworek for The Atlantic


The Intimidation Game: How the Left Is Silencing Free Speech--by Kimberley Strassel, especially Chapter 2, “Publius & Co.”


HATE: Why We Should Resist it With Free Speech, Not Censorship by Nadine Strossen 


Meta Makes Major Moves to Advance Free Expression on Its Platforms By David Inserra

Tuesday, October 31, 2023

‘Banned Books Week’ vs. Real Book Banning

Did you know we just had “Banned Books Week?” Yes, there is such a thing. In America, of all places—as absurd as that sounds. It ran from October 1 - 7.


This silliness is a reaction, of course, to the controversies surrounding the appropriateness of certain books being carried in school libraries. A Washington Post article by Alyssa Rosenberg and Greg Sargent, It’s Banned Books Week. Here’s how to fight for libraries, covered the issue from the perspective of the side opposing the so-called book banners—i.e., the parents who object to their children being exposed to certain material they believe is inappropriate for their children. 


I will not wade into the controversy here. I’ve already done that here and here. My aim here is to push back against what I consider to be a gross misuse of wording and thus a gross misrepresentation of the issue. I posted this comment:


Can anyone cite one single instance of someone being fined, jailed, hung, burned at the stake, or forced into exile for owning any book in America? I ask because those outrages have been what has been inflicted throughout history on those who dared to violate ACTUAL book bans—books banned by government edict or laws. If you’ve ever read Jacob Mchangama’s excellent “Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media,” you’ll see what ACTUAL book banning looks like. 


Today, no books are banned in America. The powerful First Amendment won’t allow it. In classic Orwellian style, the Left has mischaracterized the controversy over what books are appropriate for school libraries as a battle over book banning. In fact, the issue is educational and involves age appropriateness of material available to children. There are no books that can’t be legally published and purchased by adults in America. Unfortunately, a tiny cabal of activists has managed to highlack the debate for it’s own narrow political ends, abetted by an uncritically compliant media. So-called “Banned Books Week'' is a fraud, and only serves to white-wash the legitimate competing issues and concerns surrounding school libraries and education, and demonize one side of the debate.


Related Reading:


NJ Proposed ‘Book Ban’ Law Seeks to Silence Parents, Debate and Dissent.


Free Speech: A History from Socrates to Social Media by Jacob Mchangama 


Book-Banning vs. Age-Appropriate Educational Material


Real vs. Pseudo-Censorship


What the Parents’ Rights Movement is Really Really About


Tuesday, July 18, 2023

The Gay Wedding Website Case—The “Right” to Enslave is Rolled Back

Can the state force a custom website designer to design a website for customers even if the merchant does not want to? In 303 Creative v. Elenis, the Supreme Court said no. 


This is a good rights-affirming ruling. The case was brought by Lorie Smith, the owner of 303 Creative, who, because of her Christian beliefs, didn’t want to design a wedding website for a same-sex couple. The case was decided on First Amendment grounds based on “compelled speech” doctrine. Compelled speech doctrine holds that the First Amendment prohibits anyone from being forced to say anything that she does not want to say. Megan McArdle explains in The Washington Post:


On the legal merits, the decision is correct; it would be hard to square a different ruling with previous high court jurisprudence that has affirmed broad rights of individual expression, including protections against compelled speech. (See, for example, National Institute of Family and Life Advocates v. Becerra, in which the court ruled that California could not force crisis pregnancy centers to provide information about how to obtain abortions.) Government attempts to compel speech need an overwhelming rationale, and the court ruled that Colorado’s law doesn’t provide a sufficient one.


But there are other reasons to applaud the Supreme Court’s ruling. Article I, Section 10, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution protects the sanctity of contracts. A contract is a mutually voluntary agreement. That’s what sanctifies contracts. A contract isn’t legitimate unless both sides agree. Lorie Smith has every right not to enter a contract. The rights of the same-sex couple seeking to contract with Smith are not violated any more than the rights of Christians who oppose same-sex marriage are violated by legalization of same-sex marriage. There is no “”right” to force a contract on others. A forced contract is a contradiction in terms. Freedom of contract is in fact a derivative of the right to freedom of association, which is one of the First Amendment’s five key individual rights.


The other reason stems from the 13th Amendment to the Constitution, which prohibits both slavery and involuntary servitude. Clearly, forcing Smith to design a website against her will is involuntary servitude. Please don’t remind me that designing a website is nothing like the brutality faced by slaves on Southern slave plantations. No, it’s not. But the principle still applies. The 13th Amendment makes no distinctions regarding degree. It states simply, “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States.” This means that involuntary servitude in any degree or on any level, other than the exception noted,* is outlawed. Note that there is no exception regarding anti-discrimination law.


At this point, let me state unequivocally that I find the web designer’s refusal to serve the gay couple abhorrent. But this is about individual rights. It’s not about some alleged “right” to force Smith to do the work. It’s about her right not to. Her refusal does not in any way, shape, or form “roll back LBGTQ+ rights”—as the Left frames it—since no one has the “right” to force Smith, even by law. This is not a gay rights case. This is an equal individual rights case. In this case, on multiple levels, individual rights were upheld against a tyrannical state.


* [The exception is a point of contention because of the possibility of abuse.]


Related Reading:


Contra the NY Times, a SCOTUS Case Does Not ‘Pit Gay Rights Against Religion’


Gay Marriage: The Right to Voluntary Contract, Not to Coercive “Contract”


Does rescinding laws banning private discrimination make a moral statement in support of bigotry?


The False Alternative of Religious Rights vs. Gay Rights—Michael J. Hurd


Kim Davis vs. Liberty Ridge Farm


Court Violates Cake Baker’s Right Not to Serve Gay Weddings—Ari Armstrong for The Objective Standard


‘Bigotry Motivated by Religion is Still Bigotry’—True, but Still an Individual Right


Fine Against Christian Baker Who refused to Serve a Pro-Gay Marriage Cake Exposes Hypocrisy on Both Sides




Others’ Opinions:


CON: I’m not a lawyer. But I see what the same-sex wedding website case will mean.


PRO:  In the court’s ruling on gay wedding websites, free speech won

Monday, June 5, 2023

QUORA: “What would the founding fathers have thought of the ruling that 'corporations are people'?”

 QUORA: “What would the founding fathers have thought of the ruling that 'corporations are people'?”


I posted this answer:


No one ever said that corporations are actual people. But there is a legal doctrine called corporate personhood, to which the question probably refers, and which the U.S. Supreme Court has recognized. As  the Court noted in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby Stores, Inc., the purpose of the doctrine of corporate personhood is to “to provide protection for human beings” organized under a corporation. “When rights . . . are extended to corporations, the purpose is to protect the rights of these people.” (See my essay Corporate Personhood” Clarified.) 


As the Supreme Court noted in Citizens United, corporations are associations of individuals. "The First Amendment,” the Court held, “prohibits Congress from fining or jailing citizens, or associations of citizens, for simply engaging in political speech." Corporations are obviously associations of individuals. Therefore, the government cannot “ban political speech because the speaker is an association with a corporate form.” If it could, “Its censorship [would be] vast in its reach, suppressing the speech of both for-profit and nonprofit, both small and large, corporations.” Significantly, the Court noted that media corporations could be targeted if people couldn’t speak under the corporate form. [my emphasis]


The doctrine of “corporate personhood” is an expression of the individual right of freedom of association. Freedom of association is recognized by the First Amendment, which states that “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging . . . the right of the people peaceably to assemble.” This means that a number of individuals may voluntarily assemble as a means of collectively exercising their inalienable rights, including rights to property and free speech. The “personhood” of a corporation is merely an extension of the rights of the people who comprise the corporation for a limited purpose, such as to manage productive activity or to speak as one voice. Corporations are therefore not “people” apart from or superior to the individuals that comprise it, but an extension of the members’ individual rights. Individuals that voluntarily join groups like corporations neither lose nor gain rights. 


The Founding Fathers, as creators of a country based upon individual rights, would approve of the doctrine “corporate personhood,” in my view. Corporate personhood is merely a legal fiction that stands for actual individual human beings. After all, they crafted the First Amendment to unite freedom of speech and assembly. This was no accident. How could they not agree with the doctrine of corporate personhood?


Related Reading:


“Corporate Personhood” Clarified


QUORA: ‘Since corporations are not actual people, how does John Roberts justify legally defining them as such?’


"Corporatists" Are Individuals, Too


If Citizens United is Overturned, Michael Moore’s Film Would be Banned. But Does the Left Care?


Citizens United and the Battle for Free Speech in America by Steve Simpson for The Objective Standard

Thursday, June 1, 2023

NJ Proposed ‘Book Ban’ Law Seeks to Silence Parents, Debate and Dissent.

Under the Orwellian title New Zwicker Bill Seeks To Protect NJ Libraries, School From Book Bans, Sarah Salvadore reports for Patch that two NJ state legislators have taken a page from Florida Governor Ron DeSantos’s book: They want to get the state involved in dictating local public school educational policy.


Ok, Salvadore doesn’t actually mention DeSantos. But she might as well. Salvadore reports


South Brunswick resident and Senator from NJ-16, Andrew Zwicker, introduced legislation that seeks to protect public libraries and schools from book bans.


The legislation was introduced along with Senate Majority Leader M. Teresa Ruiz.


The bill, S-3907, would authorize the State Librarian to direct State Treasury officials to withhold funding from any public school or library that fails to comply, and would deter school boards from banning or restricting access to books or other resource materials in their libraries.


Couched in propaganda terms like “book ban” and “censorship,” the bill would essentially circumvent the current debates over age-appropriate material for school age children in public schools. Censorship and book bans are political terms that apply to governments. No one is advocating the legal banning of books or of government censorship. 


At least, not until S-3907.


This bill would essentially get the state in the position of dictating education policy. Let’s examine.


[The bill] would deter school boards from banning or restricting access to books or other resource materials in their libraries.


The word “deter” is vague. It means libraries and school boards will not have a clear idea of what is permissible, and what is not. The result--fear. As we will see, the language of the bill supports this conclusion.


The bill aims to prevent censorship of any book for “partisan or doctrinal” reasons . . .


Who defines “partisan” and “doctrinal?” This puts the state squarely in the business of deciding what viewpoints are acceptable and which aren’t. This, in a bill that purports to be against censorship!


“This is about preventing censorship and keeping intolerance and hatred from being infused into public libraries in New Jersey,” Zwicker said in a statement.


This bill has intolerance at its core. If anyone challenges material that she believes children are not cognitively or experientially equipped to handle, they are opposing the material for doctrinal reasons. After all, education is guided by philosophical doctrine. Any parent or school board that advocates elimination of any book or material from the curriculum would by definition be violating the law, if this bill passes.


And hate? What can be more subjective than that. The word is very often hurled around mindlessly to demonize others for differing opinions. Imagine the power of censorship the stature would wield if it can silence people based on “hate.”


Furthermore, the bill is targeted not just at “banning” but at “restricting access to books or other resource materials” as well. This is an attack on flexibility. One compromise regarding sexually explicit material that some have proposed is to allow the books in school libraries, but to require parental consent for children below a certain grade level to take out the book. Such a reasonable compromise would obviously be a “restriction,” and thus banned by this bill. And then the Swicker/Luiz bill purports to be against intolerance! Give me a break. Tellingly, a Republican-sponsored bill to require parental approval for sexually explicit, child pornagraphic material in school libraries was rejected by the Democrat majority on a state senate committee. Yet, the Swicker/Ruiz bill purports to ban “partisan reasons” in the school battles! Give me another break.


“The fact that we are in 2023 and debating whether or not we should be banning books and ideas is just outrageous. Ideas and information are meant to be discussed and debated in a society that respects the right of free expression and values the pursuit of knowledge.”


This is also very telling. The local government public school battles over educational materials happening at school board meetings is all about free expression and values in pursuit of knowledge. Yet this bill would ban and restrict certain viewpoint expressions and values to only those the state approves of. 


I oppose government-run or -administered schools. They are inherently political. All schools should be privatized, with education tax dollars following the student, at the very least. But as long as we have them, the state should stay out of curriculum decision-making. Public schools are local and heavily restricted, by definition and design. Generally, only those children living in the district are eligible to attend the district school. These local monopolies are bad enough. But leaving education decision-making at the local level will at least mitigate the damage. Parents can directly confront school boards and other parents to debate, inform, and, yes, argue continuously over books and other educational issues. 


To take that power away from local residents and shift that authority to the rigid dictates of the far-away state government—or worse, the federal government—would be to further entrench partisan and doctrinal viewpoints and factions. Parental rights to control the course of their children’s education, already violated by the government school near-monopoly, would be further violated by increasing state involvement. It would effectively silence parents, and stifle dissent and debate. In the current system and environment, the most civil, equitable, tolerant, and moral course of action to take is to abandon this bill and others like it, and leave the debates and authority to local school districts, residents, and school boards to sort out.


And stop using the term “book banning.” This controversy is about something common to all libraries—content curation. Librarians do that all the time. It’s especially important in school libraries, given their very limited space. According to the loose and irresponsible way that “book ban” is thrown around, any book not carried or subject to restricted access due to age in a school library is to be considered banned. By that definition, every school librarian is guilty of book banning on a massive scale.


Related Reading:


Book-Banning vs. Age-Appropriate Educational Material


What the Parents’ Rights Movement is Really Really About