Showing posts with label Individual Rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Individual Rights. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

A Moral Rot is Infecting America

The recent election signaled a lot of bad signs for our future. One leading signal involves a moral rot infecting the United States of America, and it is eroding the fundamental principle of America, individual rights. It’s not new. But it has exploded into a nationwide movement. The sudden massive, destructive assault against data centers, the vital infrastructure of the AI revolution, is a manifestation of that rot—a manifestation not just in its irrationality, misplaced blame, and NIMBYism, but in its assault on basic principles of Americanism. 


America is fundamentally a nation built on the Enlightenment ideal of Natural Rights theory. That theory, which deeply informed America’s Founding generation, translates into the protection and securing of equal and unalienable individual rights to life, liberty, property, and the pursuit of happiness. Rights protect every individual’s liberty of action according to his will, unobstructed by other humans, within limits drawn around him by the equal rights of others. These rights secure our intellectual, political, and economic freedom. Crucially, these rights command the government to protect us not only from domestic criminals and foreign enemies, but, critically, also against home-grown collectives—society, the state, the nation, the community, the NIMBYs, the anti-tech mobs, and, especially, voting majorities. No matter how many people disagree, they can’t obstruct you because you are an individual and your rights are secured. Individual rights protect the smallest minority—the individual.


These freedom principles are the reason America has succeeded and flourished. If you have an idea, America offers the unobstructed freedom to put it into action—to innovate and create, to build it, and offer it on a free market, and if someone wants to buy it, you can sell it. If you own property, you can use it as you please, so long as your use of the property doesn’t demonstrably, objectively harm someone else's property, violating their equal property rights. This applies to all properties from residential to giant industrial tracts, and to individuals and associations of individuals from small businesses to giant corporations alike.


Yet, that liberty is eroding. Too many people—apparently, most people—have lost, forgotten, or abandoned their commitment to the fundamental ideals and principles of Americanism. What is going on with, but not limited to, data centers is indicative. Mobs self-identifying as “the community” are blocking or attempting to block—through government force—the building of data centers, violating the rights of people to work, produce, trade, and develop their properties. This collectivistic subordinating of the individual to the group is entirely opposite of America’s individualist creed. It is communism (small “c”), not Americanism. This moral rot is undermining our economic freedoms, and thus America’s entrepreneurial dynamism, our future prosperity, and ultimately what makes America America. The quintessentially American mantra “You can’t stop progress” is being replaced with “Progress stops here”—by people who have benefited enormously from 200 years of such progress.


The rot didn’t start with data centers, but it is accelerating it and threatening to stop not just a local project here and there but an entire industry—an industry that is indicative of America’s perpetual renewal and youth, both for its young generation and as a nation. Remember when we rant against AI and data centers, we’re not just speaking abstractly. We’re speaking of real businesses, real people, real careers, real futures—those whose pursuits of happiness are now threatened or obstructed. We’re speaking of real benefits and real progress, for real consumers—very likely you and me. And it’s not just immoral, but unnecessary. Those who oppose data centers and/or AI can refuse to buy the products of the companies that depend on that infrastructure. That is their freedom, and their right. That is how respectful people exercise their rights.


But the moral rot is longer and runs deeper and broader. The issue of data centers only shines a spotlight on it. Every right carries a corollary duty to respect the same rights of others. There is no “right” to cross that boundary that defines the rights of others, and rob individuals who have violated no one’s rights of their freedom to work and trade, to exercize their property rights, and to engage in commerce. A nation of just laws doesn’t allow “communities” and populist will to commandeer the legal power of the state—through zoning boards, legislation, the ballot box, or any other authority—to do so. A nation that does is not a nation committed to the principles of liberty. It is a nation descending into gang rule. 


Related Reading:


My Facebook Activism:


August 21, 2026


My comment


Data Centers -- Some Thoughts


Zoning Justice -- The Institute for Justice’s Zoning Justice Project 


Stealing land in data center fight—What happened to property rights?


Private Property Rights versus ‘the Power to Govern Land Use’


How Property Rights Solve Problems by David R. Henderson


The Unholy Alliance of the NIMBYs and the Anti-Pipeline Jihadists


Development is Not ‘Inverse Condemnation’


Solberg Airport: Who Shapes "Community Character"? 


Property Rights and Title 2


Thursday, October 22, 2026

Native Americans and this Land

This post appeared on Quora. The poster, Hudson Flores, claims to have “Expertise in elections, policy, and diplomacy.” It came with the caption “This guy KNOWS EXACTLY what’s going on!”


I usually ignore this kind of nonsense. But the last point triggered me.


I posted this comment:


This guy is apparently too clueless (to put it mildly) to realize it, but the shirt he is wearing is addressed to himself.


A race can’t own a continent to the exclusion of all other people of the Earth. Anyone who believes this land belongs to the Indians for all time by the simple historical accident that their ancestors arrived here first is a blazing racist. The Europeans who later came to this continent to set up residence had as much right to emigrate here as the Indians. The same goes subsequently for Chinese, Africans, Hispanics, et al. Everyone born here is as much a native American as the people of Native American descent. 


To the glory of mankind, Enlightened Europeans ultimately established this great country, the United States of America—the first nation in history Founded on the principle of equal, unalienable, universal Individual Rights so that all people of all backgrounds can live in peaceful, respectful, prosperous coexistence. The USA, because of its Founding principles—albeit not consistently practiced—is the first moral nation in human history.


For more on this subject, see the links below.


Related Reading:


Did Ayn Rand Support the ‘Native American Genocide’?


Genocide, Stolen Land, and Other Lies about America by Dr. Jason Hill


QUORA: 'Why aren't Native Americans taking back their country, The United States of America?'


Is America Based on a "Land Grab From the Native American People?"


Was America 'made possible by stealing Indian land and the labor of slaves?'


Saturday, October 17, 2026

To Understand the Democratic Party’s Ultimate Goal, Listen to its Most Radical Wing

If one wants evidence of where the Democratic Party wants to lead the United States of America, don’t listen to the vague, hollow, meaningless, evasive, insulting generalities uttered by their electoral candidates. Listen, instead, to the Party’s most radical, most consistent, most philosophical wing—the far Left, “progressive” wing—the soul and beating heart of the Democratic Party, the party’s surging Democratic Socialists of America (DSA). That’s where the gloves come off. 

It is in this vein that I present the leading spokespersons of the DSA. 


I have said that Socialism is not the welfare state. As I’ve observed, the government’s so-called social safety net, while it is socialistic in that it is tax-funded government supplied goods, is layered on a Capitalist-oriented fundamental premise, the rights of the individual. Socialism, however—in any of its manifestations—is the counter-revolution, and the best evidence of that proposition is in the words of one of America’s Socialist leaders.


Romer didn’t actually say “Our Goal is to Destroy Americans’ Liberty”. But she set up a straw man that means precisely that. 


Let’s examine her gimmick. Speaking at the Democratic Socialists of America’s (DSA) 2025 national convention, Romer said: 


Power only cedes itself to a greater degree of power. We will win by making conditions so intolerable to the ruling class that they would rather give in to our demands than live with the disturbance we cause until we are able to fully seize power ourselves.


On the face of it, this Marxist gibberish makes no kind of sense at all. After all, the United States of America has no ruling class, neither economic nor political, by design of its Founding principles. America’s first organic law, the Declaration of Independence, The Conscience of the Constitution, declares . . .


that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness; That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.*


For the first time in recorded history, ordinary people were set free from any ruling class or elite. Bucking the tide of history, they created a Constitution to enforce those principles. America has no all-powerful king, religious cleric, military dictator, oligarchy, majority, or slave master. For the first time, the common individual was liberated from rulers. The new nation’s people instead created a government to serve them. Instead of being a subject of an authoritarian of any kind, the people got what they naturally always had— individual self-rule, which the Founding generation called self-governance. Each person is in charge of his own life, setting his own goals, choosing his own values, pursuing his own happiness, by exercising liberty limited only by the equal rights of others—by unalienable right.  The government’s sole responsibility was to secure these rights, holding only those powers justly required to carry out that responsibility. The unique American system was grounded in Natural Rights theory, which held that all persons were born free and equal and have inherent rights to life, liberty, and property that no government or ruler can take away.


So, again, what does Romer mean by “ruling class?” Let’s consider Romer’s use of the term “power.” Seth McLaughlin, writing for The Washington Times, observes:


For Ms. Romer, 43, the movement is about seizing power from corporate and political elites she calls “bosses.” 


“We don’t think that’s extreme,”  [Co-chair Ashik] Siddique said on C-SPAN this week. “We want to transfer power from the 1% to the working class, and to replace capitalism with socialism.” [my emphasis]


But here’s the gimmick: corporate—i.e. economic—power is not the same as political power. Economic power is the power of production and trade, which are voluntary activities freely engaged in by the people exercising their unalienable individual rights. Under the American system of Capitalism, economic power belongs to and is granted by free people. The economic power of the business corporation is derived solely by the consumer’s willingness to buy and use the good it is selling. 


Political power is the power of law—that is, of coercion, of the gun—and belongs strictly to the government, and only the government. When that power is strictly limited and reined in by a legitimate Constitution, like the American Constitution, it is a vital and benign power designed strictly for securing the individual’s rights to self-governance, including economic self-governance—which means rights to property and free trade, career choice, freedom of speech, press, conscience, association, reproductive freedom, and the like.


The difference between corporate and political power is the difference between a producer and a gunman, with the producer free to produce and the gunman, in a free society, strictly limited to the role of protecting that freedom.

Thus, the DSA’s explicit intention is to replace the economic and political freedom and Constitutionally limited rights-securing government of America (Capitalism) with totalitarian government (Socialism)., a power which the DSA’s members intend to “fully seize for ourselves.”


Note that the Democratic Socialists of America intend not to replace a ruling class but to create a ruling class. If the Democratic Socialists didn’t intend that outcome, why do they seek political power to begin with? There is nothing in America’s free society that prevents them from practicing their socialist values privately and voluntarily, and respecting others’ rights to live by their values. Why do they want to eliminate the Senate and make the Presidency and Supreme Court subservient to a single branch, the House of Representatives? To eliminate the checks and balances that the Founders instituted to constrain the power of the government and protect individual rights. Why? To transform our Constitutionally limited republic with a government of unlimited democratic power—a Democracy. Hence, the Democratic Socialists of America.


Never mind the “transfer [of] power from the 1% to the working class”: Both have economic power under the American system, but no power to dominate the other. The power of the “1%”—the business class—is to offer a product, service, or job, and the power of the “working class,” is in the choice people make to buy the offered product or service or accept the job. If the 1% is code for corporate power, then remember that corporate power derives from consumers’ willingness to voluntarily buy their products. When you “replace capitalism with socialism,” you eliminate every bit of voluntary economic power from the private sector, which includes the “working class,” and replace it with coercive centralized political control by the state. 


Note the sinister gimmick: First they set up a straw man—some mythical “ruling class”—then blank out the distinction between economic and political power, with the purpose of draining the economic power of voluntarism from the American people and vastly expanding the political power of the government for the purpose of enslaving us all under totalitarian Socialism. The U.S Constitution deprives the Socialists of the power they seek, so they seek to neuter  or, if possible, repeal the Constitution. The American citizen—the common person—will no longer be sovereign, and will once again become subordinate to some collective goal embodied by the state. 


If Socialism replaces Capitalism, it will be the end of rightful liberty in America—a complete counter-Revolution. The DSA seeks to replace America’s individualistic freedom with collectivistic tyranny. That is why I quoted DSA Co-Chair Megan Romer as saying “Our Goal is to Destroy Americans’ Liberty.” That is actually what she intends. Don’t be duped by the altruistic slogans Democratic Socialist “Progressives” hide behind. The goal behind every far Left candidate is what Romer expressed. They mean it.


And that leads me back to my opening proposition. Why have the Democratic Socialists found a home in the Democratic Party? Why have Democratic Party leaders not denounced them? Why, instead, do we so often hear statements of acceptance, such as “we are a big tent party, open to all ideas?” Because totalitarian Socialism is the ultimate end to which their policies are aimed. To vote Democrat is to vote for the most honest wing of the Democratic Party—the strongly anti-individual rights, pro-Socialist Progressive wing, the currently ascendant Democratic Socialists of America.


250 years ago, the Founding of the United States of America set out to free the ordinary person to self-govern his own life. Despite contradictions inherited from history, the basic social compact remains largely intact. That freedom of self-rule is threatened by The Democratic Socialists of America—and by logical extension, the Democratic Party. 


* [“Created Equal” has long been logically interpreted to mean born morally free and equal—equally free to self-govern; “men” to be generic for all individuals regardless of race, gender, economic condition, et al; and property to be among the “unalienable Rights.” These interpretations are both logical and correct, as they derive from Enlightenment philosophy. See 


Related Reading:


Why I Will Never Vote for a Democrat


Socialism's Totalitarian Nature Cannot Be Obscured by 'Democratic Socialism' 


Socialism vs. Welfare Statism: Why These Terms Matter


Criminal Socialism vs. a Free Society


The Dollar and the Gun by Harry Binswanger


The Conscience of the Constitution


On This Constitution Day, Remember the Declaration of Independence


QUORA *: ‘Why do people find communism so terrifying as an idea?’


Tuesday, September 8, 2026

What the Democrats’ Reactionary Views on Voting Actually Mean

The Democrats appear poised to win control of one or both houses of Congress. So it’s a good time to revisit the Democrats' reactionary designs on our electoral process, especially now that their party is increasingly captured by the radically counter-Enlightenment, Marxist-oriented anti-American Democratic Socialists of America, whose agenda includes totalitarian Democracy fundamentalism. 


In a leadup to Martin Luther King Jr. day, 2022, President Joe Biden gave a rousing speech in Georgia pushing his party’s so-called Freedom to Vote: John R. Lewis Act,* which combines the Freedom to Vote Act and the John R. Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act. But this was no mere campaign-style speech. Biden dove right into the thick of political philosophy, reaching straight back to the Founding of America. In doing so, Biden clearly and explicitly exposed the reactionary premises of the Democratic Party.


After falsely claiming voting rights across America as under threat from laws like Georgia’s new voting law as, Biden’s philosophic treason comes into full view:


The filibuster has been weaponized and abused.


Today I’m making it clear: To protect our democracy, I support changing the Senate rules, whichever way they need to be changed — (applause) — to prevent a minority of senators from blocking action on voting rights.  (Applause.)  


When it comes to protecting majority rule in America, the majority should rule in the United States Senate.  


I make this announcement with careful deliberation, recognizing the fundamental right to vote is the right from which all other rights flow. [My emphasis]


This is nothing short of a repudiation of America and its Enlightenment roots. The Declaration of Independence states clearly, in these “magnificent words” as per Doctor Martin Luther King Jr., 


We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed . . . [my emphasis]


This is not mere rhetorical flourish. America has never been about majority rule. The idea of unalienable Rights and the government’s sole purpose to “to secure these rights” is deeply rooted in Enlightenment philosophy, led by John Locke, embraced by America’s Founding Fathers, and ultimately, clarified and solidified by 20th Century philosopher Ayn Rand. The principle of individual rights is derived from man’s individual nature as a rational being, and precedes government. The truth is the exact opposite of Biden’s reactionary formulation: Man’s  fundamental inalienable rights to Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness are the rights from which all other rights—including the right to vote—flow.


After railing against Trump and his supporters for attempting to commandeer “the kind of power you see in totalitarian states, not in democracies,” Biden announces that rights are privileges granted by government, a foundational power of totalitarian states. This is not a power of constitutional republics such as, in its Founding ideals—the very same ideals drawn on by King in support of his Civil Rights Movement—the United States of America!


So what does it mean, in practice, when “the fundamental right to vote is the right from which all other rights flow?” It means majority rule. Mob rule. When rights flow from the right to vote, then all rights flow from the government—and the flow goes both ways.


  • It means the “rights” of majorities to vote minorities into slavery, which was a plank of the antebellum Democratic Party. 

  • It means the “rights” of majorities, or the majority’s elected representatives, to force unwilling citizens to fund political campaigns. 

  • It means the power to vote in governments to grant “rights” to material benefits, such as healthcare or education, that take away the rights of the citizens who are forced to provide and/or fund them—selectively, as in the regulatory welfare state, or across the board, as in a fully socialist country

  • It means the “right” of voters to install sharia law, violating the right to freedom of religion.

  • It means that Jim Crow laws were legitimate, democratically legitimate. Those laws were established by elected representatives--and, for a time upheld by the courts.

  • It means endorsing the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization overturning Roe v. Wade because it made a women’s right to abortion a matter of democratic vote rather than inalienable. 


That’s exactly the evil that the Founders abolished. When the British government began systematically to take away the colonists’ “rights of Englishmen,” the Founders realized that there must be a firmer foundation for rights than the benevolent whims (or lack of) of a King or other ruling authority, including the rule of elected legislatures. They found that firm foundation for the preservation of their rights in the theory of natural rights, a product of The Enlightenment; the theory that man by his very nature, and his relationship to broader nature, requires the freedom to take the actions necessary for the furtherance of his life, secured by, in the words of John Locke, inalienable individual rights.  


The Democratic Party, along with the Confederate intellectuals, rejected those principles by radically reinterpreting the Founding of America as a Democracy, not a constitutional republic. The Democrats haven’t changed their stripes. They claimed rights were grants of state authority, derived from the vote, rather than from the laws of nature, and their elected governments deprived blacks their rights—The fundamental right to vote is the right from which all other rights flow--or not flow, as elected representatives deemed to declare. Today, on Democratic Party reactionary premises, an entire country can be voted into socialist slavery. The Democratic Party has Democratic Socialists embedded within. Venezuela elected and re-elected socialist leaders Chavez and Madura, and rights were systematically stripped away--voted away--turning Venezuela into an unfree, impoverished basket case. 


That’s what you get when you declare that rights come from the state--that the fundamental right to vote is the right from which all other rights flow. As we can clearly see in theory and in practice, a government from which rights flow is also a government from which rights can recede. Biden has it backwards. In fact, in a Democracy as conceived by Biden, the right to vote is the “right” that puts all other rights at risk.


Then came the final outrage of Biden’s philosophic treason. Biden framed the debate over his Freedom to Vote: John R. Lewis Act in apocalyptic demagoguery—as a choice of democracy over autocracy, light over shadows, justice over injustice; as a choice for or against voter suppression, election subversion, and democracy. With a straight face, Biden dropped the hammer on opponents:


So, I ask every elected official in America: How do you want to be remembered? 


At consequential moments in history, they present a choice: Do you want to be the si- — on the side of Dr. King or George Wallace?  Do you want to be on the side of John Lewis or Bull Connor?  Do you want to be on the side of Abraham Lincoln or Jefferson Davis?


It was the Confederate intelligentsia that repudiated the ideal of inalienable individual rights, or natural rights theory, and reconceived America as a Democracy under which all rights flow from government—to protect their slavocracy. Who, then, is siding with the president of the slaveholding Confederacy, Jefferson Davis? Biden’s belief that “the fundamental right to vote is the right from which all other rights flow,” a principle upon which his Justice Department is basing its lawsuit against the state of Georgia over that state’s new election law, dovetails seamlessly with the philosophy of the Slave Power centered in Confederate States of America and its Democratic Party allies. 


To Joe Biden and the Democratic Party, election to political office in America is not an honorable job that entails doing the legal work of securing the fundamental rights to life, liberty, property, and the pursuit of happiness of its citizens. To today’s democratic socialist Democrats, like the antebellum Democrats and the Jim Crow Democrats and the welfare state Democrats, getting elected to political office is a license for totalitarian power—to the extent they can get away with it—to do the work of deciding what rights are, who gets them, who doesn’t, and to enforce those “rights” through legal coercion. While pretending to be on the side of mid-twentieth century civil rights crusaders, Biden is actually on the opposite side philosophically. Whereas Martin Luther King Jr., for all of his mixed and inconsistent politics, was squarely on the side of the Founding principles. Joe Biden has chosen the opposite side. 


In case you think this is hyperbole, consider that Biden’s view is precisely affirmed by his own Justice Department under Attorney General Merrick Garland, and by his Vice President, Kamala Harris, during her presidential candidacy. Since philosophy is the primary engine of history, who, then, is the real Protégé of Jefferson Davis? Add to this the fact that, as political scholar Michael Barone reminds us, “George Wallace, Bull Connor, and Jefferson Davis were all partisan Democrats.” 


There is plenty more that is bad about the Democrats’ attempt to enact their election reforms. I covered the bad elements in my post HR-1 is An Assault on Free Speech, Property Rights, Freedom of Conscience, and Privacy. Some version of the Democrats’ “Voting Rights” bill has been kicking around Congress for years. For now, it remains stalled. Let’s hope it never becomes law, and fight to kill it.


* (This bill remains stalled in Congress.)


Related Reading:


HR-1 is An Assault on Free Speech, Property Rights, Freedom of Conscience, and Privacy


The Democrats’ Anti-Free Speech Bill HR-1—the ‘For the People Act’—is Still a Threat


The Dangerous Totalitarian Premise Underpinning the Justice Department’s Suit Against Georgia’s New Election Law


Harris's Unchanged anti-American Values


Voting Rights are Not the ‘Most Fundamental Right’—or Even a Fundamental Right. 


The Conscience of the Constitution: The Declaration of Independence and the Right to Liberty—Timothy Sandefur


America; Democracy or Republic or Both--Why it Matters


Understanding the Role of the Senate Filibuster


Jesse Jackson’s Big Lie: ‘American Democracy is Under Siege’


A New Textbook of Americanism: The Politics of Ayn Rand edited by Jonathan Hoenig


Sunday, August 23, 2026

On Socialism and Democracy

This Post appeared on the Facebook page of The Federalist Papers:


DSA [Democratic Socialists of America] Co-Chair Megan Romer did Americans a favor by saying the quiet part out loud.


“We will win by making conditions so intolerable to the ruling class that they would rather give in to our demands than live with the disturbance we cause until we are able to fully seize power ourselves.” [Confirmed]


Read those words again.


This is not a call to persuade voters, win honest debates, or pass legislation through the normal democratic process. It is a declaration that socialists intend to deliberately make life intolerable until people surrender to their demands.


That is what socialists do.


They create disruption, resentment, fear, and economic pain, then present themselves as the solution to the misery they helped produce. The objective is not peaceful coexistence. The objective is power.


Americans should take this threat seriously.


When political activists block roads, occupy buildings, intimidate workers, interfere with law enforcement, destroy property, or attempt to shut down ordinary life, government officials cannot continue treating it as harmless protest. Peaceful protest is a constitutional right. Coercion, vandalism, threats, and organized lawlessness are not.


Anyone who crosses that line should face arrest, prosecution, jail, civil liability, and every other lawful consequence available.


There can be no special exemption because the people causing the disruption claim to be pursuing “social justice.” A crime committed for socialism is still a crime.


The most revealing portion of Romer’s statement is the desire to “fully seize power.” That phrase should destroy the comforting fiction that the DSA is merely seeking a slightly larger welfare state. [My emphasis]


America was founded on limited government, private property, individual liberty, religious freedom, and the right of citizens to live without being ruled by an all-powerful political class.


Socialism attacks every one of those principles.


You cannot claim to love America while working to eliminate the freedoms that make America worth loving. You cannot praise democracy while planning to make life intolerable until your opponents submit.


Believe them when they tell us what they intend to do.


What consequences should people face when political disruption crosses the line into intimidation, destruction, or organized lawlessness?


Source: Commentary magazine, “The Misery Strategy”


The Federalist Papers followed this up in the comments with;


The people calling themselves the enemies of the “ruling class” rarely intend to surrender power once they obtain it. 


This is true. Although the “Democratic” in Democratic Socialism refers to totalitarian democracy—the hideous idea that the right to vote is the most fundamental right that confers on elected politicians unlimited power to do as they please without restraint because they are elected—that same democracy that got Socialism elected can work in reverse, throwing the Socialists out of office. So while the Democratic Socialists (or any dictatorship) will claim their despotic policies are legitimate because instituted democratically, they’ll never submit their rule to voters for continuing validation. After HAMAS won election in Gaza under President Bush’s “Forward Strategy of Freedom,” it immediately canceled all future elections. 


That is why, once in power, the DSA will never allow free and fair elections. They will never allow themselves to be voted out of power. They will either abandon elections altogether or allow only rigged elections (Their advocacy for public funding of elections is a step in that direction). This has been true of Socialism from Vladimir Lenin to Nicolas Maduro. Why? Because elections require certain individual rights—rights to free speech and press, private campaign financing, dissent and opposing ideas, honest debate, association, one-man-one-vote, and so on. For Socialists, it’s not only about power. It’s about principle. They are collectivists. As the 20th Century Socialist Robert L. Heilbroner acknowledged, individual rights fundamentally conflict with Socialism’s collective moral goal—central planning—and thus cannot be allowed. 


Heilbroner, a leading Socialist intellectual and best-selling socialist writer of the 20th century, had no illusions about what Socialism requires. In a Dissent magazine essay titled What is Socialism, Heilbroner wrote:


The rights of individuals to their Millian liberties [are] directly opposed to the basic social commitment to a deliberately embraced collective moral goal… Under socialism, every dissenting voice raises a threat similar to that raised under a democracy by those who preach antidemocracy.


In  The Nature and Logic of Capitalism by Heilbroner wrote; 


Political freedom in modern times has only appeared in capitalist states. Democratic liberties have not yet appeared in any nation that [is] fundamentally anti-capitalist, which is to say within the self-styled Marxist ambit. The . . . separation of realms [politics and economics] creates the essential conditions for political freedom because the state cannot enforce its will though economic sanctions, such as denying work to political dissidents.


Heilbroner also noted that “democratic liberties have not yet appeared, except fleetingly, in any nation that has declared itself to be fundamentally anticapitalist.”


Bolshevik  Communist Vladimir Lenin, the first head of the Soviet Union, banned all other parties and oppositions, internal Communist Party factions, an independent press, and free, fair, and open elections, on the principle that open dissent acted as a counter-revolutionary danger. Socialists use the liberties of free, Capitalist-oriented nations to come to power, then ban those liberties. Socialists can exploit capitalism’s “tolerance of dissent” to gain power, Heilbroner explains in What Is Socialism?, but then must not allow dissent to undermine their power. Once in power, socialists must understand that


Dissents, disagreements, and departures from norms then assume a far more threatening aspect than under bourgeois society, for they hold out the possibility of destroying the very commitment to a moral consensus by which socialist society differs from capitalist.


Nor can we wriggle off this hook by asserting that, among its moral commitments, socialism will choose to include the rights of individuals to their Millian liberties. For that celebration of individualism is directly opposed to the basic socialist commitment to a deliberately embraced collective moral goal.


We can also dispel the delusion that Socialist rule can be anything but total. I quote Heilbroner from What Is Socialism? Page 344:


Socialists have always railed against the invidious striving of the market that forces individuals to subordinate their full personalities to narrow economic roles. Moreover, it is not only the motivations of capitalists that are at stake. . . The issue is the motivation of working people. For the market mechanism is not merely a means to profit. It is also a means to individual betterment by the maximization of one's income. Without this drive, the mechanism will not work. 


But is the drive for private gain compatible with the goal of socialism? I do not see how it can be. The market system, in order to function, requires attitudes of self-seeking that are in direct conflict with the goal of an "other-oriented" society. If socialism seeks to avoid both the anarchy and alienation of capitalism, it must seek to break the hold of the market, not merely over the economy but over the mind.' [Emphasis added.]


Get that? “. . . over the mind,” not only of capitalists but of working people. This is what Socialists mean when they express concern for the “working class”—to break their minds, and spirits, so as to make them “other-oriented” rather than strivers for self-betterment.


This dispels the notion that Socialism is for “working people.” This dispels the notion that Socialism is “only about economics.” Note, again, Romer’s choice of words—”until we are able to fully seize power ourselves.” fully seize power. Clearly, she’s not referring to elective power, which in America is limited. She’s referring to the day after the Democratic Socialists win electoral control of the presidency and Congress—at which point, Hitler style, they end the Constitutional checks on government power, abandon the Declaration of Independence, and establish—seize—full despotism, thus ending rightful liberty in America. That’s why there has never been—not in Soviet Russia; not in Red China; not in Castro’s Cuba; not in North Korea; not in modern Venezuela; not anywhere full Socialism has been established—anything but one-party totalitarianism under Socialism—and philosophically and logically never can be.



RELATED:


QUORA: ‘Would socialism be constitutional in the U. S.?’


Socialism's Totalitarian Nature Cannot Be Obscured by 'Democratic Socialism'


QUORA: ‘Is capitalism voluntary?’


Ralph Peters: “Mesmerized by Elections, We Forgot Freedom”, my essay for The Objective Standard


Mesmerized by Elections, the NJ Star-Ledger Forgot that Tyranny is Tyranny


Democratic Socialism: The Left Escalates America’s Journey to Totalitarianism


Socialism vs. Welfare Statism: Why These Terms Matter