Tuesday, April 7, 2015

We Owe Our Children a More Technologically Advanced Society, Not 'Preserved' Nature

Environmentalists often defend their anti-industrial causes by invoking the good of “future generations.” That tactic was employed by Regina Barna, an outspoken opponent of the proposed PennEast natural gas pipeline, which will run partly though New Jersey.


In a letter titled Shale gas is a bad idea, Barna wrote, in part:


Shale gas development is a bad idea, not just for New Jersey, but for the planet.


On Sept. 21, the People’s Climate March of 400,000 protestors in New York City and the subsequent United Nations’ Conference on Climate Change, are highlighting the dangers that countries all over the world are already experiencing because of man-made climate change issues.


When considering whether you care about a pipeline, do not ask whether you personally want a 30- to 42-inch pipeline running through your backyard. The pipeline and its infrastructure will bring with it noxious compressor stations, noisy power plants and metering stations, risks of leaks and explosions. I doubt if any of us want that. Rather, ask the following larger questions: How important are clean air, water and soil to the earth? Is a healthy environment worthy of preserving for our children? If you have suffered from or know of anyone affected by Superstorm Sandy, ask: Can we avoid these ever more severe natural disasters? Do the benefits of extraction outweigh the costs? Are we not at a tipping point where we should be focusing on alternate sources of renewable energy? By extracting fossil fuels, we are contributing to the degradation, not only of beautiful state that we live in, but to the very earth we live on.


At least Barna is will to pose the question, “Do the benefits . . . outweigh the costs?” Most anti-fossil fuel activists don’t even acknowledge that there are benefits.


I left these comments:


“If you have suffered from or know of anyone affected by Superstorm Sandy, ask: Can we avoid  
these ever more severe natural disasters?”


If you ever doubted that climate change environmentalism (CCE) is a religion, not a science, this statement is it. Just as religionists credit God with all the good in the world, and blame man for all the bad, so CCE blames every bad weather event on human-caused climate change, yet don’t credit human-caused climate change for good weather. What if I cited climate change as the cause of this spring-summer’s ideal weather that led to record crop yields across the U.S, and, on that basis, called for dramatically increasing our use of fossil fuels—even to the point of
stopping new “alternative energy” installations and showering fossil fuel companies with $billions in taxpayer subsidies?


Rediculous? Yes—and that’s how we should look at Barna’s exploitation of Sandy for her political purposes. The fact is, natural disasters are not getting “ever more severe.” Before there was Sandy, there was the Great Atlantic Storm. Before that, the Blizzard of 1888. Before that, “The Grate Hurrycano of 1780, which was actually three hurricanes in one week in October.” In fact, New Jersey has always been vulnerable to savage storms. “Great Storms of the Jersey Shore ” by Larry Savadove and Margaret Thomas Buchholz documents the history going back 2-1/2 centuries, to the time before fossil fuels, spanning the time from the “little Ice Age” to today’s mild warming.


Natural disasters have not changed noticeably, except in climate computer model predictions. But even if weather extremes are getting a bit more extreme, so what? The difference today is that, thanks to energy produced mostly from fossil fuels, humans can now cope with these disasters. No longer are we at the utter mercy of weather extremes like heat and cold waves, droughts, floods, and storms of every variety. And when a mega-disaster like Sandy happens, we are in a much better position to recover quickly. What sane person would want to roll back that progress? To paraphrase Barna, “Fossil fuel development is a great idea, not just for New Jersey, but for the planet.”


Landowners directly in the path of the PennEast and other pipelines certainly have a right to have their legitimate concerns addressed, and have the right not to have the pipeline cross their property. But the CCE ideologues coming out of woodwork to oppose the pipeline have nothing more than faith-based nonsense to peddle. Cleaner air, water, and soil are powered by fossil fuels. “Risks of leaks and explosions?” Modern pipelines use state-of-the-art technologies, and are the safest yet—much safer than some of the 305,000 miles of existing nat-gas pipelines. Or did she mean free of all possible risks? A risk-free environment is the riskiest possible environment for human beings. By Barna’s logic, fire would never have been harnessed, and man would still be struck in caves, with a 15-year life expectancy.


“Is a healthy environment worthy of preserving for our children?” Not if it means stopping life-enhancing energy production. There was a time when a “healthy environment”—meaning an environment unaltered by human productive labor and technology—was preserved for “our children,” and their children, and their children. It is called the Dark Ages.


Thankfully, there were no environmentalists around before the Industrial Revolution to "preserve the environment." If there had been, the few of us that would be around today would still be existing in short, miserable lives—ever at the mercy of "healthy" nature—rather than enjoying the advanced technological industrialization bequeathed to us. We should celebrate the fact that the environment wasn't preserved for our alleged benefit; and then build on the progress we inherited to make our lives still better and happier. Fossil fuels have contributed, and continue to contribute, mightily to that progress.


Progress begets progress, and fossil fuels are vital to building on the progress we inherited from the productive heros past, including the pipeline builders. This will result in the passing on to the next generation of an even more technologically advanced society, and thus better environment.


That is what we owe our children.


Related Reading:





Climate Change Alarmists Ignore Life-Giving Fossil fuel Contributions

Human Life would be Impossible Without Accepting Dangers that ‘Could’ Happen

Related Viewing:

The magic washing machine—Hans Rosling

Saturday, April 4, 2015

'Religious Freedom Restoration' Laws and Tim Cook's Misunderstanding of America's Founding Principles

Indiana’s controversial new Religious Freedom Restoration Act is another bad fix for a problem created by bad law to begin with. 

The impetus for religious freedom restoration laws (RFRLs) is the increasing, and proper, nationwide legal recognition of the individual rights of gay people, especially the legalization of gay marriage. This trend clashed with many biblical dogmas that consider homosexuality to be a sin. The result has been increasing instances of private businesses running afoul of anti-discrimination laws by refusing to serve gay couples because of the business owners’ religious beliefs.


Proponents claim the Indiana law protects religious liberty, not give private businesses the right to discriminate against gays for religious reasons. But there’s no getting around it. RFRLs intend one thing; to carve out exemptions from anti-discrimination laws for religious people as such laws relate to gays. The issue is clear-cut: Either a businessman can refuse to serve gays in conformance with his religious teaching, or he can’t. Supporters of RFRLs won’t acknowledge the obvious, and the stench of hypocrisy hangs over them. Religions never objected to anti-discrimination laws intended to outlaw discrimination based on race, national origin, gender, or religious affiliation. Only when gays were added to the list of “protected groups” did RFRLs arise.


Proponents’ disingenuousness sidesteps the basic problem: Anti-discrimination laws targeting the private sector violate the right to freedom of association, which encompasses the right to discriminate in one’s private associations. If not for anti-discrimination laws, RFRLs would not be “necessary,” because private business owners would not be forced to contract with gays against their religious convictions. Repeal of anti-discrimination laws, not enactment of dishonest RFRLs, should be their focus.


But opponents of RFRLs also get it wrong. In response to Indiana’s law, Apple CEO Tim Cook declared in a Washington Post op-ed that Pro-discrimination ‘religious freedom’ laws are dangerous. He writes:


There’s something very dangerous happening in states across the country.


A wave of legislation, introduced in more than two dozen states, would allow people to discriminate against their neighbors. Some, such as the bill enacted in Indiana last week that drew a national outcry and one passed in Arkansas, say individuals can cite their personal religious beliefs to refuse service to a customer or resist a state nondiscrimination law.


Others are more transparent in their effort to discriminate. Legislation being considered in Texas would strip the salaries and pensions of clerks who issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples — even if the Supreme Court strikes down Texas’ marriage ban later this year. In total, there are nearly 100 bills designed to enshrine discrimination in state law.


Cook views anti-discrimination laws and anti-gay marriage laws as moral opposites. In fact, they are two sides of the same rights-violating coin. Cook goes on:


These bills rationalize injustice by pretending to defend something many of us hold dear. They go against the very principles our nation was founded on, and they have the potential to undo decades of progress toward greater equality.


Men and women have fought and died fighting to protect our country’s founding principles of freedom and equality. We owe it to them, to each other and to our future to continue to fight with our words and our actions to make sure we protect those ideals. The days of segregation and discrimination marked by “Whites Only” signs on shop doors, water fountains and restrooms must remain deep in our past.


But Cook has a fundamental misunderstanding of American ideals. Yes, we should continue the fight to protect the ideals of freedom and equality. But first, we must learn what freedom and equality actually mean.


America is a nation Founded on the principle of individual rights. Rights protect freedom of action in the social context, so long as one’s actions don’t violate the rights of others; i.e., involve the initiation of physical force against another. Critically, rights do not guarantee anyone's conception of moral action, just action. A “right” to act only in ways the government approves of is not a right, but a special privilege. A government with the power to dictate personal morals, and to recognize rights only of select groups, is not a legitimate government. It is a dictatorship.


That said, the purpose of rights should not be construed primarily as protecting immoral actions. Some may indeed exercise their rights irrationally and/or immorally, but such instances are side effects of rights’ primary purpose. The individual right to act free from the coercive interference of others is a necessary social condition of human life and flourishing, because life requires action in support of one’s life. The purpose of rights is to protect constructive, life-enhancing action, despite the fact that some actions may be destructive.


As I wrote in response to the Liberty Ridge Farms case in New York, “Every individual has a right to live by his own moral standards, even irrational ones, so long as his actions don’t violate the rights of others. But this issue is not primarily about freedom of religion and conscience; rather, it is about freedom of association and contract.” Freedom of Association resolves both the marriage equality and religious freedom issues. Gay people have a right to marry. Private businesses have a right to do business with whom they please. Both are forms of contract, and freedom of contract is a  fundamental extension of freedom of association. Freedom of contract does not include the right to coerce others into any contract.


Importantly, “equality” under American principles means equal protection of individual rights—including rights of association—under the law. Equality then forbids legally enforced segregation (E.G, Jim Crow and Separate but Equal doctrines). But equal protection under law also forbids legally-enforced integration. Equality and freedom in American terms means equal protection all private individuals’ right to freely associate, or not, in his private dealings with other people. This includes Christian businessmen’s right not to serve gay couples (and to accept the consequences, such as public scorn and loss of sales and profits due to boycotts by disapproving potential customers). If the equality that Cook upholds as a Founding American ideal means anything, it means that it is just as wrong for Tim Cook to impose his values on Christian businesses by legally forcing them to serve gays against their conscience as it is for the government to impose Christians’ standards on gays by legally banning gay marriage. If the freedom that Cook upholds as a Founding American ideal means anything, it means the freedom not to associate with whom one prefers not to associate with.


Personally, I oppose religious freedom restoration laws because such laws carve out a special exemption to anti-discrimination laws only for religious people, and because in any event freedom of religion is not the fundamental issue. Freedom of association is the fundamental issue, and under that principle anti-private discrimination laws are the problem. Fully and consistently upholding individual rights, and specifically the right to freedom of association, resolves the conflict without violating either the rights of the religious or the rights of gay people.


Anti-gay bigotry, as with all bigotry is disgusting and ignorant. But laws banning private discrimination is no more the American way than prior laws enforcing segregation were. The proper way to overcome irrational discrimination is not through law (i.e. force) but through reason and persuasion. Private action under First Amendment principles, such as speaking, writing, boycotting, public protests, and making an example by your own actions—as Cook is doing with Apple’s strong anti-discrimination business policies and culture (which Cook explains at length in his article)—is an intellectual power that no coercive power of law can match. Indeed, anti-discrimination laws would not have been possible without first defeating bigotry and prejudice in the broader culture. The 1964 Civil Rights Act was a consequence, not the start, of the Civil Rights Movement, which was winning the moral battle against anti-black bigotry on the battleground of ideas. The spontaneous national outcry against the Indiana law—and the rush by Indiana (and Arkansas) lawmakers to amend their religious freedom laws in response—proves the point. In the absence of anti-discrimination laws, bigotry could never gain a foothold in today’s culture. Public outcry would tamp it down wherever it arose. Discriminating businesses, while free to operate, would be marginalized into insignificance and even bankruptcy under withering public condemnation and economic competition.


Cook is wrong on his key point. “[T]he very principles our nation was founded on” do not include turning the government into a morality dictator. Rights protect freedom, because freedom is a fundamental requirement of human nature. But there is a bright moral line between something being legal and something being moral. Legality signifies implementation of an underlying political principle, not a moral sanction of all particular actions that may be taken under that principle. Freedom of association does not mean “pro-discrimination,” even though some may use that right to irrationally discriminate, any more than freedom of speech means “pro-Nazi,” even though some may use that right to advocate evil ideas. Freedom of association simply means freedom of association, just as freedom of speech simply means freedom of speech. We shouldn’t allow our revulsion against bigotry to water down and undermine our sacred rights. Bigotry should never be granted that kind of status.


I sympathize with Cook’s moral outrage with laws that masquerade as protections for religious freedom, but effectually sanction discrimination against gays. But I also understand religionists who believe their freedom to practice their religion in a non-rights-violating manner, however irrational and immoral that practice, is under attack. The resolution of this conflict requires upholding everyone’s individual rights equally, including the right to freedom of association.


Related Reading:








Is RFRA Unconstitutional?—Sasha Volokh, Washington Post



Gay Marriage: The Right to Voluntary Contract, Not to Coercive “Contract”

Thursday, April 2, 2015

Bloated Food Stamp Program Neglects Americans' Right to Their Moral Choices

A 3/28/15 New Jersey Star-Ledger letter lamented that Congress’ Food Stamp Cuts Neglect Poor Americans. The cuts referred to are part of a Federal budget blueprint passed by the House of Representatives, which would cut 18% from the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP (formerly called Food Stamps). (Farm Aid would also be cut by 16%.)

The letter, submitted by Susan Joseph Rack of Martinsville, NJ, committed a grave moral error; focussing solely on a desired end while ignoring consideration of the means of achieving that end. She wrote, “When it comes to reducing hunger and poverty, our investments in SNAP are working. Congress should not mess with such a highly effective program.” I left these comments, drawing on quotes from Rack’s letter:

SNAP has ballooned to nearly $80 billion a year with 46 million recipients, up dramatically from the $15 billion and 17 million recipients in 2001. Despite that expansion, the proposed House budget cuts will amount to only 13.7 $billion a year, which still leaves a gargantuan 65 $billion program.

Yet, proponents of SNAP still complain. No matter how much of taxpayer money is seized and spent, proponents won’t consider cuts—not even “cuts” in the growth of such programs—to be open to rational discussion. No amount of spending is ever enough for the welfare statists. And this highlights the malignant nature of the SNAP program, and redistributionist welfare state programs generally. They are cancerous by nature. The GOP doesn’t even want to end SNAP. It’s reductions leave most of its recent growth in place. And still Republicans are criticized.

Despite those huge numbers, the biggest problem with SNAP is not monetary, but moral. Ms. Rack states that “. . . the primary beneficiaries of SNAP are children, the elderly, veterans and the disabled.” So?

The moral problem is this: SNAP deprives American taxpayers of their right to make moral judgements on how they spend their money. How am I to know whether the recipients of food stamps are deserving of my “help?” Where is the parents’ responsibility to feed their own children? Why didn’t the elderly recipients save for their old age when they were working—if they even worked? How hard is that veteran looking for a job, or a better-paying job? Is that “disabled” person really disabled? I’ve known people on disability who do all manner of physical and mental activities. I’ve known people who didn’t think it necessary to save for rough times or old age, because “the government will take care of me.”

Undoubtedly, some food stamp recipients fall on hard times through no fault of their own, and collect the SNAP benefits only until they can get back on their feet economically. But that’s the point: SNAP deprives American taxpayers of the right to distinguish between responsible and irresponsible people in deciding how the taxpayer spends his own charitable dollars, or whether to spend his dollars on charity at all. For example, I don’t believe that being “poor” is itself adequate reason for giving someone a handout, because being poor can very easily be the person’s own fault—i.e., being the result of bad choices rather than unforeseen  circumstances beyond the person’s control. To the extent my tax dollars go toward the SNAP program, is the extent to which my rights are violated, and that’s the fundamental immorality of the SNAP program.

Rack’s statement that “. . . if SNAP were a corporate program, Congress would be holding it up as a model of effectiveness and efficiency.” Maybe or maybe not—and utterly beside the point. Ms. Rack neglects the fundamental moral difference between government force and voluntary private association.

There’s nothing wrong with food assistance. But there is a black-and-white moral difference between a coercive government program and a private voluntary charitable effort, corporate or otherwise. Defenders of SNAP always ignore the means, and focus only on the ends. In so doing, they commit a grave moral sin. But the ends don’t automatically justify the means. Otherwise, we’d live in a predatory jungle (we’re partly there already). If the means are immoral, the ends cannot be justified, no matter how convincingly anyone asserts that “our investments in SNAP are working.” And the means—forcibly redistributing wealth from those who earned it to those who didn’t—is immoral. It is legalized plunder.

Whether or not helping some needy person get food is a desirable end is rightfully and morally a personal choice. If it is desirable, we should choose the moral means to that end. We should recognize people's right to decide if, who, when, and in what capacity to help others. We should recognize each person’s right to judge what works and what doesn’t, and direct his charitable dollars accordingly. We should recognize every individual’s right to make moral judgements as to the worthiness of recipients of his charitable dollars. Ending SNAP would be a good moral step in this direction.

Unfortunately, the debate in Washington is only about the size of SNAP, when we should be debating how best to least disruptively phase out the program. That said, it’s laudable that the GOP is offering these cuts. Every dollar cut from the gargantuan federal budget is another dollar left in the hands of the people who earned it. Cutting spending wherever politically feasable is the right thing to do.

Related Reading:



Rights vs. Need: Who Determines How Much Food Aid is "Enough"?

Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Privilege, Servitude, and the GOP Budget

Both houses of Congress passed budget blueprints designed to balance the federal budget in 10 years. The budget calls for a reduction in projected spending of 5.5 $trillion. Needless to say—and leaving aside the details of the budget—the Left is not happy with the budget, and offers the usual smear tactics, lies, and false generalities in rebuttal.

For example, the New Jersey Star-Ledger titles their rebuttal The GOP has spoken: The wealthy and powerful could use more help. What “help” they do not say. Nor can they, because the alleged “help” is really a modest reduction in the amount of money seized from the “wealthy” and redistributed to those who did not earn it. The Star-Ledger drivels:

The GOP-dominated House and Senate passed their budget resolutions last week, and in the process proved beyond reasonable doubt that the majority party is less interested in governing than in sending symbolic valentines to the wealthy.

As usual, this will lead to the same ideological war that consumes our politics, but this budget also represents a war against cognitive function, because only in the fantasies of ideologues can one expect to make $5 trillion in cuts over the next 10 years without raising any taxes.

Unless, of course, you do it by advancing a budget that promotes the existence of a privileged class and a servile class. [emphasis added]

The S-L goes on to bemoan proposed cuts in Food Stamps (more on that in my next post), Pell Grants, and Medicaid; repeal of ObamaCare “because anything that improves the lives of 16.4 million working people cannot possibly be a good thing”; “guts” Dodd-Frank (reduces regulation); and “doesn't create jobs, address infrastructure, raise the minimum wage, reduce college debt, promote scientific research, or deal with income inequality”: In other words, the GOP budget doesn’t do enough to advance the Left’s statist agenda. (For perspective, the GOP would actually increase annual spending from $3.8 trillion to $5.1 trillion, for a 10-year total of $43.2 trillion—a reduction of about 11% from current projections. Note also that, other than ObamaCare, no welfare programs are slated to be eliminated.)

I left these comments:

We already have “a privileged class and a servile class”: It’s called the regulatory welfare state.

The privileged are the political class, which has garnered enormous power to regulate and redistribute the wealth of the servile class—the self-reliant and the productive. The privileged class feeds off of the “needy and the poor,” an ever-expanding class of dependents feeding off of the loot collected from the ever-shrinking, ever-more-regulated servile class.

The sinister nature of the welfare state is not just that it rewards moochers, however. It’s not that simple. It’s that it drives decent people into dependency. The welfare state drives up the cost of goods and services, setting up a dynamic that makes government handouts “necessary.” The soaring cost of college, driven up by subsidies, grants, and easy-money loans, is a clear-cut example of this. Worse, the welfare state turns millions of self-reliant people into a hybrid monstrosity—a combination slave and parasite. E.G. Social Security, which taxes you all of your working life to support other people, and then leaving you with living off of the earnings of others as the only means of collecting your promised “earned benefits,” because your SS taxes were not invested in your name but spent. Welfare statists are not content to “help” the poor. If they actually did care, they’d be unrepentant free market capitalist “ideologues.” They’re not, because they love the poor. It’s the source of their power and their very reason for being. That’s why their actual goal is to relentlessly expand the ranks of the poor, until the vast, once self-reliant middle class is turned into a vast, dependent welfare class. It is a dependency society, not a self-reliant society, that is the ultimate goal of the power-lusting privileged class.

The regulatory welfare state is immoral at its core, because it is built on legalized looting and rights-violating regulations and fostered by envy and hatred of economic flourishing masquerading as “economic justice” and the phony problem of “income inequality.” The fact that there are beneficiaries such as the 16.4 million ObamaCare “insured” doesn’t mitigate this fact. Every tyranny has beneficiaries, including Soviet Russia, Nazi Germany, and socialist Venezuela. The ends don’t justify the means.

Unfortunately, the debate in Washington is only about the size of the welfare state, when we should be debating how best to least disruptively phase it out. That said, it’s laudable that the GOP is offering these cuts, even though their goal is to save and perpetuate the welfare state. Every dollar cut from the gargantuan federal budget is another dollar left in the hands of the people who earned it. Cutting spending wherever politically feasable is the right thing to do, albeit being only a small first step in the right direction.  

Related Reading:



The Evil Genius of the Welfare State

Sunday, March 29, 2015

Free Speech, not Self-Censorship, is the Answer to 'Offensive' Free Speech

The Charlie Hebdo assault has exposed hidden danger; the danger of self-censorship. The New Jersey Star-Ledger’s Paul Mulshine discusses the dangerous consequences for civilization. In The Charlie Hebdo case: Killers’ apologists owe us an apology, Mulshine recalled the Iranian Ayatollah Khomeini’s 1980s fatwa (death sentence) against Salman Rushdie for “insulting Islam with the publication of ‘The Satanic Verses.’” Mulshine noted that “no sooner was the fatwa issued than various deep thinkers arose to denounce Rushdie for provoking death threats he could not possibly have anticipated.” Mulshine goes on:


Perhaps the worst example came from Bill Donohue of the Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights. In a press release titled “Muslims Are Right to Be Angry,” Donohue wrote the boilerplate “I don’t condone violence, but …” passage before going on to say this:


“Stephane Charbonnier, the paper’s publisher, was killed today in the slaughter, It is too bad that he didn’t understand the role he played in his tragic death. In 2012, when asked why he insults Muslims, he said, ‘Muhammad isn’t sacred to me.’ Had he not been so narcissistic, he may still be alive.”


Many apologists make a slippery-slope argument to the effect that chaos would ensue if society permitted people to utter inflammatory thoughts on topics like religion and race.


There’s a slippery slope here, all right, but it’s a slope on which our right of free expression slides away.


I left these comments:


“There’s a slippery slope here, all right, but it’s a slope on which our right of free expression slides away.”


And it’s a really scary slope.


What Donohue and his ilk are essentially advocating is something arguably worse than overt government censorship—self-censorship. If people must filter their judgement about what to express through a strainer labeled “offensive,” it will be the end of rational discourse and, consequently, a civil society. Virtually any idea—whether “reasonably” presented or not—can offend somebody. A free society requires the free flow of ideas. It’s the only way to filter out the bad ones and advance the good ones peaceably.


Donohue’s call for self-censorship is a cowards way out. The only moral way to counter ideas one doesn’t approve of is to use one’s own freedom of speech in rebuttal.


----


Mulshine added in reply to my comments: “Also, it's extremely naive to pretend that the Muslims had a right to ‘peaceful’ protest since leveling the charge of blasphemy carries a threat of execution.” Returning to the article, Mulshine observed:


Donohue’s statement has much competition, especially in the comments I’ve read on the internet. None of the commenters seem to realize their attitude sets a standard by which they themselves could be slaughtered by anyone who took umbrage at their inanities.


Exactly. People have all sorts of deeply held beliefs, and not all of these beliefs are limited to religion. As an Objectivist—Objectivism being the philosophy of Ayn Rand—I have to put up with all sorts of ignorant insults of me, my philosophy, and especially of Ayn Rand. I’m not talking about rational disagreement—even hard-hitting disagreement. I’m talking about uniformed insults and smears; inanity. I admire Ayn Rand and agree with her philosophy. In a sense, her ideas are sacred to me. Why is offending me by smearing her, whom I admire, any different than offending a Muslim by smearing Muhammad, who Muslims admire?


According to the principle espoused by the Hebdo terrorists apologists, Objectivists need only threaten harm or execution to justify others’ responsibility to “voluntarily” keep quite (or at least tone down their remarks, which in principle is the same thing). Of course, Objectivists would never demand such a thing, because a rational person understands that the best weapon against “offensive” speech is using one’s own free speech rights in rebuttal.


And here is the fundamental point: When you demand censorship—legal or “voluntarily” self-imposed—you’re own free speech, and ultimately everyone’s free speech, goes out with it. And it’s naive to find solace in an imagined distinction between legal censorship and “voluntary” self-censorship in fear of physical harm. Once the idea of voluntary self-censorship is accepted as legitimate in a culture, it’s only a matter of time before legal censorship follows: Politics always follows cultural trends. Freedom of expression is fundamental and indispensable to Western Civilization and any kind of free society. What we must recognize is that there is no “right” not to be offended, and so need for protection against offensive speech, so long as freedom of speech—properly understood—is absolute.


Related Reading:






Related Listening:

NEW EPISODE OF THE YARON BROOK SHOW: CHARLIE HEBDO AND THE THREAT TO FREE SPEECH

Friday, March 27, 2015

Minimum Wage Amendments Violate Rights and Subvert Proper Constitutions

Most states legally mandate minimum wages. But Colorado, Florida, and New Jersey have actually amended their constitutions to impose minimum wages.

Any government action to impose mandatory minimum wage rates is not only economically destructive but fundamentally immoral, because such measures violate employers’ and job-seekers’ moral rights to freely contract.

But as if Minimum wage laws are not bad enough, using the constitution to impose minimum wages, on whatever governmental level, compounds the evil. Such political tactics subvert the very crucial role of constitutions in protecting our liberties from governmental encroachment.

As philosopher Ayn Rand explains:

There are two potential violators of man’s rights: the criminals and the government. The great achievement of the United States was to draw a distinction between these two—by forbidding to the second the legalized version of the activities of the first.

The government was set to protect man from criminals—and the Constitution was written to protect man from the government.

These principles necessarily apply to government at any level. Otherwise, if the federal constitution protects rights, but the state constitutions can violate rights with impunity, then the federal constitution is in essence a hollow document. It is not. Though our constitution was approved on a state-by-state basis, it was instituted by “We the People,” not “We the States.”

Under minimum wage amendments and like “economic” constitutional provisions, man’s protection from the government vanishes. Rather than limiting the government to protecting individual rights, such provisions invert the constitution, turning it into a rights-violating tool of economic aggression at the behest of any victorious voting bloc.

As stated in the Declaration of Independence, the philosophic blueprint for the constitution, “. . . to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men.” If liberty is to be preserved and fully restored, Americans must rediscover the vision of the Founding Fathers as regards the proper role of government and purpose of a constitution.

Related Reading:




Minimum Wage Issue is Not "about what it’s like to live on $7.25 an hour"