Wednesday, March 25, 2015

Selflessness vs. Egoism: Or, ‘Real Education’ vs. Real Education

Last October, the New Jersey Star-Ledger ran an editorial titled From Kentucky State U., a lesson in real education. The first sentence:


Nancy Astor, the complex American socialite who became the first woman ever to sit in the British House of Commons, once described “real education” as something that “should educate us out of self into something far finer; into a selflessness which links us to all humanity.”


I left these comments:


“Real education should educate us out of self into something far finer; into a selflessness which links us to all humanity.”


Translation: Everybody is important, as long as it’s not you. You are nobody. If this principle applies equally to everybody, then all of your self-renunciation is for a bunch of nobodies.


But this begs the question: For every act of selflessness, there is someone profiting from your selflessness. Basic logic. “Humanity”, after all, is made up of individuals. Just who is “humanity”? It turns out to be every moocher who thinks the world owes him a living. Who are the people who get stuck selflessly serving “humanity”? Anyone who takes this rubbish seriously, makes something of themselves, and finds—as his “reward”—a hoard of parasites waiting to drain him of his dreams, efforts, and wealth. The “educational” lesson: To the extent you succeed and produce, you are a slave; to the extent you fail, you get the unearned. From each according to his ability, to each according to his need. The “educational” lesson: Why bother trying? Other people owe me. The ultimate triumph of vice over virtue.


The biggest winners of all: power-lusters who claim the title of “public servants”—the politicians who get the job of distributing the largess of the selfless serfs who play it straight according to the ethics of selflessness. Convince a person he doesn’t own his life, and you’ve got him. Convince everyone of the morality of selflessness, or altruism, and everyone ends up living for the state.


Collectivism is the ultimate fraud: It crusades under the banner of benevolence and good will, to clear the way for the reign of parasites and power-lusters.


After the horrors of 20th Century collectivism, it is shocking to see these ideas once again openly espoused. Reject it, and embrace rational self-interest and self-reliance; not in the conventional mean-spirited, lone wolf sense—which is a straw man—but as a means to peaceful coexistence and mutual benefit.


The real purpose of education should be to prepare children for an independent, self-reliant adulthood so they can take care of themselves. They should be taught not to be a slave to “humanity” nor wait greedily for “humanity” to give them something they didn’t earn. They should be taught how to rationally choose their values and goals, work to achieve them, and be proud of what they do achieve—not for lesser achievers, or for “humanity”, or for “something far finer” than self—but precisely for self. One’s own life—the only life any of us will ever have—should be one’s highest value. Live for yourself and your own long-term happiness and rise by your own thought and effort. The Declaration of Independence, not the Communist Manifesto. That will breed self-respect and its corollary; respect for others and their achievements—and, by the way, genuine generosity toward people one cares about, rather than guilt-ridden handouts.


That is the ideal education.


Astor’s quote has nothing to do with a CEO taking a salary cut to give out a few raises. The issue is much more fundamental: Does your life belong to you, or not? “Do not hide behind such superficialities as whether you should or should not give a dime to a beggar. That is not the issue. The issue is whether you do or do not have the right to exist without giving him that dime.” The question is not linkage, but the basis of that linkage. The choice has always been either-or; selflessness and mutual predation, or self-reliance and mutual respect. Live for others and demand others live for you, or live for yourself, and respect others right to live for themselves. Deal with others as slave and master, giver and taker; or as equals exchanging value for value, neither self-sacrificing for others nor demanding others self-sacrifice for you. Lose-win, or win-win. Mutual profiteering on sacrifice, or self-reliance. Chains or freedom. Altruism or egoism. Run from anyone who preaches the former, for they are not lovers of humanity. They are either moochers or power-lusters—the collectors and/or distributors of your sacrifices.


Selflessness in education has political appeal for power-lusters. The purpose of an education based on selflessness is to create adults who will readily submit to authoritarian rule, because they are not morally equipped to selfishly defend their values and their rights to life, liberty, and property.


Related Reading:






The Comprachicos—Ayn Rand

Individualism vs. Collectivism: Our Future, Our Choice—Craig Biddle

Teaching Johnny to Think—Leonard Peikoff

Monday, March 23, 2015

On Religion, The First Amendment Works Both Ways

A letter published in the Hunterdon County Democrat screamed, “Tragedy Looms!” Robert A. Loss writes:


Hearing some of the preliminary talk regarding the 2016 presidential election, I sense a true tragedy in the making, [the election of] another liberal, un-American president” who doesn’t understand that “the Constitution is the ‘supreme law of the land.’”


Apparently, Loss doesn’t understand the constitution, either. His very next paragraph reads:


The First Amendment of our Constitution states we have the right to free exercise of religion, so why does any court entertain any lawsuit pertaining to the display of a nativity scene or any other Christian celebration? Any religion has the Constitutional right to exercise their religious beliefs and there is nothing in the Constitution that says anything about “the separation of church and state” - whatever that means.


In the comments, David Ivester did a pretty good job of explaining to Loss exactly what “separation of church and state” means:


I’m happy to answer Mr. Loss’s question.It is important to distinguish between "individual" and "government" speech about religion.The constitutional principle of separation of church and state does not purge religion from the public square--far from it. Indeed, the First Amendment's "free exercise" clause assures that each individual is free to exercise and express his or her religious views--publicly as well as privately. The Amendment constrains only the government not to promote or otherwise take steps toward establishment of religion.While figuring out whether someone is speaking for the government in any particular circumstance may sometimes be difficult, making the distinction is critical. [sic]


I left this reply to Ivester, under my screen name “Zemack”:


I would add that freedom of religion extends beyond religion to all personal belief systems. The Founding Fathers used freedom of religion and liberty of conscience interchangeably. They intended that government be neutral, promoting (establishing) neither religious nor non-religious beliefs, and protecting the free exercise and expression of all personal belief systems.


I would also add that the Constitution cannot be understood outside of the context of the Declaration of Independence, the philosophic blueprint for the Constitution. The meaning of “unalienable rights” is that the exercise of one man’s rights cannot infringe on another’s. “Unalienable” establishes the parameters within which one may exercise his rights, and beyond which his exercise cannot go, and best summed up by the saying, “Your right to swing your arms ends where my nose begins.” This means no one may force others to pay for their “free exercise of religion,” which is exactly what happens when religionists want to use tax-funded government property such as courthouses to display their religious symbols. Loss wonders “why does any court entertain any lawsuit pertaining to the display of a nativity scene or any other Christian celebration?” But this issue only pertains to government buildings such as courthouses and schools. If such displays are allowed, it implies government sanction or establishment. No one has ever suggested that private individuals be forbidden to express their beliefs on private property, or privately on public property. On the other hand, if an employee of the government, such as a public school teacher, uses his position as a government employee to express his religious beliefs, that cannot be tolerated under the First Amendment.


Loss apparently forgot the rest of the First Amendment, such as the part that states “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion,” which precedes the part about free exercise he references. Perhaps if he read the whole thing, he’d understand what separation of church and state actually means. Legally walling off religion and political power is the only way to protect freedom of religion and conscience, and foster peaceful coexistence among people of all beliefs.


As I wrote in Freedom Of Religion Demands Freedom From Religion for The Objective Standard:


In a political context, freedom means the absence of initiatory physical force or coercion. Those who promote the idea that there is no freedom from religion undermine the First Amendment, reject the separation of church and state, and seek to impose their religious beliefs through government force.


If freedom of conscience is to continue in America—which means: if America is to continue being even semi-free—Americans must understand and embrace the principle that freedom of conscience entails and requires freedom from religion.


Related Reading:





America Was Not Founded as a Christian Nation

Saturday, March 21, 2015

How Business Productivity Makes Us Wealthier and Safer

This is a followup on Gary Faraci’s letter titled Economic status quo must change, which was published in the Asbury Park Press and also appeared in the print edition of the New Jersey Star-Ledger.


Gary Faraci posted this rebuttal to my comments, discussed in my last post on 3/19/15, “Only Free Markets Can Fairly Determine Economic Success”:


Contrary to what you say, in today's system big business investors don't risk their capital - they use our tax dollars in the form of grants, subsidies, tax abatements & deferments. The billions the oil companies get from us, and the billions in breaks we give them are good examples. And big business investors are guaranteed a return - just look at the TARP bailout of the financial industry. Increased productivity also means less labor needed, thus less not more earning power for many. And climate change indicates business has NOT led to a safer, healthier human environment. The only thing we agree on is the first responsibility of a CEO is to maximize shareholder value. But that is not in any way a MORAL responsibility, as the other stakeholders are not considered. And that is immoral.


My Reply:


Today’s system is seriously corrupt in many ways, and I agree the TARP bailouts are terrible. But mixed economy corruption aside, investment, production, and trade drive progress.


I also agree that any actual subsidies—direct payments from taxpayers to companies—should end. That includes the massive, decades-long subsidies to so-called “renewable” energy companies. But tax breaks are not subsidies. They are companies keeping more of what they have earned. And oil companies earn their profits by producing the indispensable values—energy and myriad petroleum-based products—that we voluntarily buy.


“And climate change indicates business has NOT led to a safer, healthier human environment.”


This is the most fantastic statement imaginable. Where would we be without central heating and a/c; water purification and delivery systems; sturdy structures; advanced sanitary waste disposal; advanced medicine; electrification; modern transportation; modern agriculture; modern communications; stores stocked with products to meet every imaginable need and desire. The list goes on and on. We are saturated in the wonders of business, big and small. In the midst of plenty, you see only “climate change,” ignoring the monumental benefits. This is irrational prejudice. Well, climate danger, not climate change, is and always has been the real threat. And we’re better protected from climate danger than ever before. Before the capitalist era of business prominence, life for all but the very wealthiest ruling elites was a brutal day-to-day, hand-to-mouth struggle to stay one step ahead of the next drought-induced famine or storm or infectious disease or cold wave. If what we have today is not a safer, healthier human environment compared to what existed back then, then how exactly do you define safer and healthier?


--


Now let’s explore in more depth Faraci’s statement that “Increased productivity also means less labor needed, thus less not more earning power for many.”


Increased productivity does cost jobs in the short term, and these workers who lose their jobs can face hardship if they don’t find an alternative livelihood.


But productivity works both ways. The workers who remain are more productive, and thus, over time, earn higher wages. Furthermore, lower costs lead to lower prices, resulting in increased sales that tend to mitigate the shrinkage of the more productive company’s workforce. And as existing industry gets more productive and sheds workers, the way is paved for the birth of new technologies and new industries—including those that produce the new, labor saving technologies. This process leads to more goods at more affordable prices, and more jobs.


Steady economic progress has been the history of capitalism. Before free market capitalism gave birth to the industrial revolution, almost everyone worked on the basic necessities of life—food and clothing. That was all most people had time for. As recently as 1870, at least 70% of the U.S. population worked in agriculture. Today, only 2%. Add in the productivity-led shrinkage of jobs in the textile industry to 2% of the labor force, and—according to Faraci’s logic that productivity is regressive—we should have 90% unemployment today. Not only is that obviously not so, we are all immensely wealthier than in pre-industrial times. We have indoor plumbing, electrification, autos and planes, central air conditioning and heating, amazing healthcare, cell phones, television, the internet, plentiful food, much better protection from the natural elements, and whatever else one cares to add to this list. And we live almost twice as long, with a wealth of job opportunities unimaginable 250 years ago.


Faraci doesn’t explain specifically what he means when he says that a CEO’s duty to maximize shareholder value “is not in any way a MORAL responsibility, as the other stakeholders—the community, the employees and the environment—are not considered.” But we can surmise. Apparently, Faraci believes businessmen’s interests are to be subordinated to the “community”—i.e., anyone other than the owners and operators of the business; and that the world owes “employees” a living, which it is business’s moral duty to provide for, whether or not the employee is any longer needed and regardless of his level of competence. As to the environment, Faraci apparently believes that the natural environment is safe, and businessmen have made it less safe—the exact opposite of the truth. Does Faraci prefer a pre-industrial existence over today’s comparatively thriving industrial, technological civilization? Or is Faraci demanding that  business somehow produce what we need without affecting the natural world? Your guess is as good as mine.


Of course, capitalism balances and harmonizes everyone’s interests, through the mechanism of trade, so that no one’s interests are sacrificed to anyone else’s. This is so because, under capitalism, individual rights are protected equally and at all times, under a government constitutionally limited to that purpose. Capitalism is the system of self-reliance and respect for the rights of others. It is the system that liberates producers to transform the natural world, with all of its inherent dangers, into a safer, livable human life-centered environment. Parasites, power-lusters, and “Mother Earth”—worshipping primitives have no place in a capitalist society, and that’s what makes capitalism the only moral social system.


Related Reading:





Businessmen—Ayn Rand

Thursday, March 19, 2015

Only Free Markets Can Fairly Determine Economic Success

A recent letter titled Economic status quo must change was published in the Asbury Park Press. (It also appeared in the print edition of the New Jersey Star-Ledger.) It is an interesting letter in that it exposes the soul and the ignorance of the anti-capitalist. The writer is Gary Faraci.


Faraci calls for a “cultural change” away from “the mantra that success is measured solely by maximizing stockholder value.” Instead, he says, “Economic success must be measured by maximizing all ‘stakeholders’ values. Stakeholders include the community, the employees, and the environment. Not just stockholders.” Faraci goes on:


Maximizing stockholder value by the continually driving costs out of the system allows companies to have workers living below the poverty line, which then results in the workers relying on the government for food stamps and health benefits. And this narrow pursuit of profits also allows businesses to neglect and ignore the detrimental effects they have on the community systems and infrastructure, and the environment. Unless the welfare of the community, the employees and the environment are balanced with the interests of the investors, any economic success will be short-lived. And only for those at the top. Long term economic survival depends upon liveable wages, disposable income, sound infrastructure, and a safe environment. Not just higher stock prices.


I left these comments:


Business creates the products our lives and flourishing depend on at a price people can afford, the remunerative jobs that enable us to buy the products we need and desire, and by extension the tax revenue that supports our schools and infrastructure. All of this starts with the entrepreneurs and investors who risk their capital rather than keep it “safe” in bank accounts or bonds. Investors (shareholders) are not guaranteed a return. For the company and thus the investors to profit, their business must attract and keep customers. To attract customers, the business must create ever-increasing value at ever-decreasing costs, which is achieved by investing in technologies that increase the productivity—and thus the earning power—of labor. To create that value, businesses must pay and treat employees in a way that attracts and holds a dedicated, motivated workforce. This is what it means to “maximize shareholder value”—the first moral responsibility of the CEO.  


As to the environment, human beings survive and thrive by turning the Earth’s raw materials into life-enhancing material goods, thus transforming a hostile, pristine natural environment into a safer, healthier human environment. By far the leader in this virtuous transformation of the environment is business. For that, we owe business a huge expression of thanks, not a demand for them to sacrifice their best interests.


This virtuous cycle requires a social system that harmonizes the interests of “all stakeholders.” That system is the “unknown ideal,” free market capitalism—the system of voluntary, peaceful coexistence through trade, backed up by limited, individual rights-protecting government. Any means of “harmonizing interests” other than voluntary cooperation is the means of a thug. Today we don’t have capitalism. We have a mixed economy—un-free markets bogged down with government controls. That’s what “the culture” needs to learn.


--


Faraci raises the question of how economic success is measured:


Businesses need to stop pursuing, governments need to stop legislating to, and educators need to stop teaching the mantra that success is measured solely by maximizing stockholder value. Economic success must be measured by maximizing all “stakeholders” values. Stakeholders include the community, the employees, and the environment. Not just stockholders.


Faraci implies that “economic success” is an arbitrary construct that can be redefined on a whim. But, in fact, economic success has an objective basis; the market. As Ayn Rand has observed, “The economic value of a man’s work is determined, on a free market, by a single principle: by the voluntary consent of those who are willing to trade him their work or products in return.” It’s not enough to invest, work hard, and so on. On any level, from the janitor to the CEO, one’s economic success is measured by what others are willing to pay you.


But while an employee has only one consideration—the level of his compensation—the businessman has two concerns. Not only must he have people willing to pay him for his product; they must be willing to pay him more than it costs him to produce it. Faraci sees “Maximizing stockholder value by the continually driving costs out of the system . . .” as a vice. In fact, it is the greatest virtue of successful businesses. The “continually driving costs out of the system” is what creates mass markets of goods that not just the rich but the average person can afford. It is what lifts the general standard of living. The average person never had it as good as under businesses liberated by capitalism.


Faraci’s reference to “sound infrastructure” is puzzling. Business is the mainstay of the economy, and as such, generates—directly and indirectly—most of the taxes that fund the building and maintenance of our infrastructure. It’s true that our government-owned infrastructure is crumbling. But we all use it, not just business. I guess, given his anti-business bigotry, Faraci can’t help pinning the blame for every conceivable problem on business.


I’m not done with this letter. I’ll finish up with Faraci in my next post.


Related Reading:







To Whom Does the American Worker Owe His Prowess?

Tuesday, March 17, 2015

I Agree: Pipelines Should Be ‘Evaluated On Their Individual Merits.’ Why Don’t We?

The following comment was left regarding New Jersey Star-Ledger columnist Paul Mulshine’s Chris Christie should address the oily logic of pipeline opponents. Mulshine highlighted the hypocrisy of NJ’s NIMBY (not -in-my-back-yard) opponents of the proposed Pilgrim Pipeline, which would carry liquid petroleum products across Northern NJ.


In response to my comments, Kevin posted, in part:


There are many energy choices, some difficult, and they should be evaluated on their individual merits. The Pilgrim Pipeline is a bad idea.  If it isn't built, fossil fuels won't disappear.


I also think it's unfair to characterize the opposition as extreme environmentalists.  They're simply not.  Nor are they all affluent.  All along the route of the pipeline, people of every economic and political stripe are opposed to it.


I'd encourage you to take a look at the pipeline route as it goes through Fanwood, Scotch Plains, Edison and Woodbridge, more densely populated communities.  Look at it in satellite view.  See how close the pipeline gets to the swing sets and sandboxes.  Kids play mere feet from the pipeline.


My reply:


“There are many energy choices, some difficult, and they should be evaluated on their individual merits.”


Really? When do you ever hear fossil fuels evaluated on their merits. When do you hear people talking about the benefits? Of the risks of not using fossil fuels? Rarely.  


Industrial civilization is full of potential hazards. Schools have natural gas piping and/or oil piping for their furnaces. Most streets have high-pressure natgas lines below, including in residential neighborhoods, where kids live and play. Roads have tanker trucks carrying liquid explosives. Every car is a potential bomb. Electrification can cause catastrophic fires. Planes fly overhead, any one of which could crash. And yes, pipelines involve risks, as well. What doesn’t? You say the pipeline is a bad idea. But you give no reason why.


No, not every pipeline opponent is an “extreme environmentalist.” It’s true that many local opponents are only concerned with “their” pipeline. But the same is true of other pipelines—the PennEast natural gas pipeline through my home county of Hunterdon; the South Jersey Gas pipeline through the Pinelands; Keystone. Meanwhile, they enable the extreme environmentalists. “If it isn't built, fossil fuels won't disappear.” Not right away. But it’s a step in that direction.


Related Reading:





NJ's "St. Ambrose" LNG Port and Liz Roberts's One-Sided Disaster Mongering

Monday, March 16, 2015

To Demand an 'Impregnable Pipeline' is to End Pipelines

The following comment was left regarding New Jersey Star-Ledger columnist Paul Mulshine’s Chris Christie should address the oily logic of pipeline opponents. Mulshine highlighted the hypocrisy of NJ’s NIMBY (not -in-my-back-yard) opponents of the proposed Pilgrim Pipeline, which would carry liquid petroleum products across Northern NJ.

Mr.Splunge posted:

“At some point, it will be economically unfeasible to construct an impregnable pipeline.”

My reply:

No industrial project can be truly “impregnable”; i.e., achieve perfect safety and zero risk. If perfection is the standard, we’d have no energy to run water purification and delivery systems.

There are currently about 185,000 miles of liquid petroleum pipelines, 320,000 miles of gas transmission pipelines, and two million miles of gas distribution pipelines in operation in America. Yet, there is no clean water problem in America.

Clearly, pipelines and clean water can and do coexist. More to the point, these pipelines deliver the vital energy that powers our water purification and delivery systems. Without this energy, our “water supplies” would remain just so much inaccessible ground water rather than turned into the clean water conveniently available at the twist of a knob in our homes.

While many older pipelines are vulnerable to breakdowns, new pipelines represent state-of-the-art technologies, making them safer than ever. But if it’s 100% safety guarantees you’re demanding, you’re demanding omniscience and infallibility, two attributes impossible to man. On that premise, man’s first advance from the cave—the harnessing of fire—would never have happened.

Related Reading:




Reject the Green Agenda in 2015

Sunday, March 15, 2015

The Unholy Alliance of the NIMBYs and the Anti-Pipeline Jihadists

In a recent New Jersey Star-Ledger op-ed, Chris Christie should address the oily logic of pipeline opponents, columnist Paul Mulshine highlighted the hypocrisy of NJ’s NIMBY (not -in-my-back-yard) opponents of the proposed Pilgrim Pipeline, which would carry liquid petroleum products across Northern NJ. Mulshine wrote:


This opposition is nonsensical, whether it comes from the Democrats opposing Keystone or Republicans opposing Pilgrim, such as Senate [Republican] Minority Leader Tom Kean Jr.


Consider Kean’s statement against Pilgrim:


“Several of our towns have reached out to me personally about the potential impact of this pipeline, about the effect on densely populated areas and on legally-protected natural preserves,” Kean (R-Union) said.


Note the illogic: We can’t run the pipeline through populated areas because people live there. But we can’t run the pipeline through unpopulated areas either; we’ve passed laws saying people can’t live there.


And as to the safety question, Mulshine noted that pipelines are demonstrably safer than other forms of petroleum transport. That fact mean nothing to the Pilgrim NIMBY’s, because:


Given that those trains and barges tend to run through the back yards of people who live in places a lot less ritzy than Chatham, that sounds like classic NIMBYism.


I left these comments:


And notice the almost breathtaking hypocrisy of Pilgrim’s opponents. There are currently about 185,000 miles of liquid petroleum pipelines, 320,000 miles of gas transmission pipelines, and two million miles of gas distribution pipelines in operation in America. Anyone who relies on food and other products transported to the shelves of their local stores, electricity, clean running water, sanitary waste disposal, gasoline for their cars, fuel for heat, etc., etc., etc., relies in large part on these pipelines that pass through other people’s backyards. Pilgrim’s opponents surely do. If every local community thought like Pilgrim’s opponents, and had the power to stop commerce, America would still be an impoverished third-world backwater. These NIMBY’s prove the wisdom of the Founding Fathers: The original purpose of the Commerce Clause was precisely to prevent narrow-minded local tribes from shutting down interstate commerce.


And Brendan Keating is disingenuous to assert that “the Chatham people [and other opponents] are not part of” the radical “jihad on pipelines.” Their hypocrisy is an enabler of the much more dangerous environmentalist crusade against fossil fuels. Environmentalism holds “pristine” nature, rather than human life, as its standard of value. Environmentalism is an evil ideology because human beings survive and thrive precisely by transforming “pristine” nature into a livable, industrial environment. And the industry of industries is energy. Fossil fuels are far and away the most viable option for providing the massive amounts of reliable, economical, scalable energy required to sustain and grow an industrial economy capable of supporting Earth’s 7 billion people. Nuclear and hydro are a distant second and third. So-called “renewables” like wind and solar aren’t even on the reliability scale. That’s why, worldwide, fossil provides 86% of the world’s energy. Fossil is the people’s choice, for good reason. It is the moral and practical choice, because it improves human lives.


Environmentalism stands opposed to every reliable energy source—not only fossil but nuclear and hydro as well—and thus to human life. If environmentalism ever succeeded in its stated goal of shutting down the fossil fuel industry in the absence of any proven viable replacement—which as of now does not exist—the scale of human devastation would dwarf the combined horrors of communism, fascism, and theocracy. This is not hyperbole. Agriculture would shut down. Medical care would be shackled. Modern transportation would grind to a halt. Most communication would go silent. The ability to protect ourselves from climate dangers—from heat to cold to droughts to floods to storms—would be thwarted. Production and commerce would grind to a halt, and billions would literally die. Pilgrim’s opponents should consider who they are in bed with—and then take an objective look at this pipeline.


I’ll post my replies to a couple of comments in the next two days.


[NOTE: After Brendan Keating contacted me by e-mail protesting my characterization of his position, I left this “Retraction and correction”;


I said “And Brendan Keating is disingenuous to assert that ‘the Chatham people [and other opponents] are not part of’ the radical ‘jihad on pipelines.’” This was a poor use of the word “disingenuous” that amounts to an unintended smear of Keating. What I actually had in mind to say is that Keating and other opponents of the pipeline are unwittingly advancing the cause of the “environmentalist crusade against fossil fuels.” My poor choice of the word “disingenuous” inadvertently implies that Keating supports what Mulshine calls a “jihad against pipelines.” But Keating clearly disassociates himself from that cause.


[Mulshine had cited “radical environmentalists” who have “declared a jihad on pipelines on the theory that if you choke off delivery you can eventually choke off production” of fossil fuels. My apologies to Brendan Keating.]


Related Reading:





Reject the Green Agenda in 2015