Showing posts with label Altruism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Altruism. Show all posts

Sunday, December 4, 2022

Reply Responses to QUORA *: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’ - 4

I received numerous comments on my QUORA answer to Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism? The following comment inspired a (partial) response from me:


William Delouvrely commented:


To me, and I could be wrong, there is a basic problem with Ayn Rand. Let me assure you that “I have not always been wrong.” (Churchill quote).


Ayn Rand and her followers have the habit to see everything in a purely ‘yes or no’, ‘black or white’, or ‘extremely correct or totally wrong’ frame of mind. The great majority of humans do not live and do not want to live within such a ‘permanent logic or bust’ standard. This is not a ‘wobbly mealy-mouthed argument’. If you can imagine it, in Ayn Rand’s world there is no room for feelings, kindness, for music, poetry, art and theater, because don’t all these distract from the ‘purely rational 100% productivity only, no jokes, no laughter, no good times allowed’ systemic standard that must be applied to all people of all ages, or else my philosophy is wrong, and we can’t have that as I always must be right, at all costs, no matter the human costs, no matter the consequences.


Do I still make sense, as I am trying to climb down into the rabbit hole of Randian logic?

In one way, to put a lighter spin on it, Ayn Rand is the philosophical personification of Jerry Seinfeld’s ‘Soup Nazi’. Wham, bamm, no soup for you!

In another way, the harshness that is shown by devoted, harsh, zealous, uncompromising followers of such political fashions as Nazism, Capitalism, Communism, as well as by militant & irrational proponents of any and all world religions & cults, all that points to the paranoid and super-logical world view espoused by Ayn Rand.


Do you want to live in a world like that, where a three year old might be expected to already be a productive member of society, and a seventy-five year old is expected to work until she croaks while at work? Well, me neither.


I remember that old Greek riddle: “What animal is this? It walks on four legs in the morning, on two legs at noon, and on three legs at nightfall?” The answer is of course, the human being, as it crawls on all four as a toddler, in the morning of life, on two legs at noon in the productive time of life, and on three legs (two legs and a cane) near the end of life. Ayn Rand would not have guessed it. Or would she?


Which gets me back to the beginning, where I said something like ‘well, I haven’t always been wrong’.


I’ll say that a civilized society cannot exist without a certain degree of altruism, which of course has to be counter-balanced [sic] with a degree of reason and willingness to assert oneself. Just taking without giving is as unsustainable as only giving without taking. 

There, now I am going to shut up.


My emphasis.


I do not know where this Mr. Spock depiction of “Ayn Rand and her followers” comes from. His is just another complete strawman, which I will not waste my time responding to. Just the fact that he equates Nazism and Communism with Capitalism shows that Delouvrely does not know what he is talking about. But Delouvrely does close with a point that requires a response for the benefit of serious readers of this site. Here is my reply:


“Just taking without giving is as unsustainable as only giving without taking.” 


Rand most emphatically rejected that premise as a false choice. In fact, she convincingly argued that that “choice” is really two sides of the same coin. I made this point clear in my answer above. 


The alternative to that false choice that Rand posited is the trader principle—the win-win relationship.


Relationships need not be win-lose or lose-win, necessarily  involving both an exploiter and a victim. People can get better together, with each neither taking without giving or giving without taking. The values exchanged can be material or spiritual, or a combination of both. But the ideal human relationship Rand promoted would leave each side better off.


Related Reading:


Reply Responses to QUORA *: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’


Reply Responses to QUORA: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’ — 2


Reply Responses to My Answer regarding QUORA: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’ - 3


This Quora Answer Shows Why Ayn Rand Was Right About Altruism


QUORA: Is Ayn Rand's 'Selfishness' 'the middle between altruism and selfism?'


Books to Aid in Understanding Ayn Rand's Rational Selfishness


QUORA: ‘Did Ayn Rand support the idea of giving to charity or donating your own money to help other people?’


QUORA: What does Ayn Rand think about vitrues [sic] such as charity, selflessness, and friendship?


QUORA: ‘What do people misunderstand about Ayn Rand's ideas?’


Auguste Comte on altruism


The word "altruism" (French: altruisme, from autrui, 'other people', derived from Latin alter 'other') was coined by Auguste Comte, the French founder of positivism, in order to describe the ethical doctrine he supported. He believed that individuals had a moral obligation to renounce self-interest and live for others. Comte says, in his Catéchisme Positiviste,[2] that:


[The] social point of view cannot tolerate the notion of rights, for such notion rests on individualism. We are born under a load of obligations of every kind, to our predecessors, to our successors, to our contemporaries. After our birth these obligations increase or accumulate, for it is some time before we can return any service.... This ["to live for others"], the definitive formula of human morality, gives a direct sanction exclusively to our instincts of benevolence, the common source of happiness and duty. [Man must serve] Humanity, whose we are entirely."


Monday, August 1, 2022

Reply Responses to My Answer regarding QUORA: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’ - 3

I received several comments on my QUORA answer to Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism? The following comment inspired a response from me:

 

From K Lauretti · 15h

I just was learning about echoism which is the opposite of narcissism. I believe having a purpose that helps us make up for the atoms that we are created from and our need to consume during life helps balance us and carry our spirit and makeup into the next generation. So it’s both filling our own needs now and then in the future. And ensuring that our community will be healthy for the next generation. So it’s healthy when you have a healthy amount of altruism just like it’s healthy when you have a healthy amount of narcissism. You have to care about yourself and others in order to have a safe society to live in and a healthy life for yourself.

 

My response, posted as a reply to Lauretti:


There is a common theme running through recent comments to the effect that the definition of altruism that Rand relies upon is “extreme” and therefore has no practical relevance to people’s lives. It’s true that, as I observed in my answer, people’s conception of altruism is mixed and contradictory. The so-called “middle” ground actually entails two opposites, non-sacrificial vs. self-sacrificial concern for others’ interest. This is logically untenable. To conceive of both forms of concern for others’ interest in a single concept—altruism—is to violate two of the three basic laws of logic, the Law of Non-Contradiction and the Law of Excluded Middle. The issue at hand involves two distinct and logically opposing concepts, rational self-interest vs. altruism, each having their own objective—that is, “extreme”—definitions, and thus opposite practical effects. 


An “extreme” definition is an actual, proper definition. Any proper definition, by definition, is “extreme”, in the sense of being non-contradictory, unambiguous, and fact based, or it’s not a proper definition. A “non-extreme” definition never works logically, because a “non-extreme” definition is an attempt at obfuscation by approximation, vagueness, and inexactness. A “non-extreme” definition is no definition at all. Nothing is more destructive to human reason and communication than the approximate, the vague, the imprecise, the ambiguous, the non-objective, or the non-exact. Those who evade “extreme” definitions are condemned to logical and moral incoherence.


I maintain that the “extreme”—that is, accurate—definition of altruism has damaging real life practical consequences, not only in the more detached world of politics but also on a direct personal level. 


Which brings me to K Lauretti’s point about echoism. The practical value of Rand’s “extreme”—i.e., precise—understanding of altruism becomes plain in this comment.


The precise definition of altruism holds that the standard of moral action is self-sacrificial concern for others.* This is the definition generally accepted implicitly, even as some mistakenly conflate non-sacrificial acts of concern (including charity or helping out) for others’ interests with the self-sacrificial acts that altruism demands. Lauretti’s reference to echoism in fact proves Rand’s point, in the form of highlighting the inherently corrupting influence of altruism on the human soul. To see why, one must unpack the mushy, mixed understanding of “altruism” into its mutually exclusive opposites.


Echoism is a personality trait only recently identified by psychologists. Craig Malkin Ph.D., writing for Psychology Today, observes


Echoism is a trait that my colleagues and I have begun measuring, and like all traits, it exists to a greater or lesser degree in everyone. People who score well above average in echoism qualify as echoists, and their defining characteristic is a fear of seeming narcissistic in any way. 


[my emphasis]

 

Narcissism, strictly speaking, is of course not a virtue. But here I take Lauretti’s use of the word narcissism to be a blanket reference to self-interest generally. A “fear of seeming narcissistic” amounts to, “I don’t want to be seen as thinking of myself.” If echoism “exists to a greater or lesser degree in everyone,” then it is safe to say that my claim that Rand’s “impractical” understanding of altruism is in fact very practical is correct.


I hold that underlying this irrational “fear of seeming narcissistic” is altruism, precisely and properly (extremely) defined. 


This fear highlights how altruism, properly understood, has real-life consequences on the personal level. Since altruism ascribes a negative moral significance to prioritizing one’s self-interest, even though one cannot live without being substantially selfish, altruism's corrupting effect manifests in unearned guilt. If echoism “exists to a greater or lesser degree in everyone”, we can readily see altruism’s widespread effects—the widespread infection of unearned guilt. The fear of seeming narcissistic is actually unearned guilt. Unearned guilt can have very damaging consequences for the individual, leading to damaged self-esteem and moral confidence.


As I said, the mushy, contradictory ways that altruism is used today violates the basic laws of logic—specifically, the law of non-contradiction and the law of excluded middle. Altruism cannot mean both sacrifice and non-sacrifice. It is either/or. People can hold mixed premises. But in any real life issue involving others, it’s either/or. It’s either a self-sacrifice to others, or rationally self-interested; altruism, or benevolence; unhealthy, or healthy. Altruism is what it is -- self-sacrificial service to others by moral duty, and nothing else. Altruism is not charitable; it is not benevolent; it is not respectful. 


I agree with Lauretti that “You have to care about yourself and others in order to have a safe society to live in and a healthy life for yourself.” But caring for yourself does not preclude caring for others. Certainly, charity and/or helping others can and often is consistent with promoting your own rationally selfish value hierarchy. And that concern for others, including strangers, needn’t, and shouldn’t, be self-sacrificial. Indeed, no respectful person would ever expect or demand of others self-sacrifice for their sake. A culture full of people demanding and expecting sacrifices from others for their own benefit is not a healthy culture. A healthy culture is a respectful culture, where people co-exist and interact by mutually beneficial relationships, neither sacrificing themselves to others nor expecting sacrifices from others. Concern for others can certainly be healthy. But there is no “healthy amount of altruism.”


Finally, observe how “selfish” is regularly used as a stand-alone criticism or accusation. “You’re selfish” is almost universally accepted as a pejorative, as if being selfish in and of itself is a vice. It’s intended to put the target on the defensive, sidestepping any judgment on what the accused is actually being selfish about. It implies that looking out for one's own interests is ipso-facto a bad thing. That is altruism just as Rand understands it. 


Far from being too “extreme” to have practical consequences in real life, altruism’s widespread corruption is evident everywhere across everyday life.


* [A sacrifice is the giving up of a value for a lesser value, or no value at all, as opposed to giving up a lesser value and receiving in return a value that is more important to you than that which you gave up.]


Related Reading:


QUORA: Is Ayn Rand's 'Selfishness' 'the middle between altruism and selfism?'


Books to Aid in Understanding Ayn Rand's Rational Selfishness


QUORA: Is Ayn Rand's 'Selfishness' 'the middle between altruism and selfism?'


QUORA: ‘Did Ayn Rand support the idea of giving to charity or donating your own money to help other people?’


QUORA: What does Ayn Rand think about vitrues [sic] such as charity, selflessness, and friendship?


QUORA: What do people misunderstand about Ayn Rand's ideas?


Understanding Ayn Rand’s Original Ethics Requires Original Thinking


Sunday, July 17, 2022

Reply Responses to QUORA: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’ — 2

I received several comments to my QUORA answer to Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?


From Eddie Pilchard 


She applied pure philosophy to human beings, and her experience of human beings was… unusual. Moreover, she had a circle of followers who, through an almost religious belief in her put her needs before their own in extremis, including a woman who willingly let her husband have a relationship with her. Sounds almost… altruistic..?


The definition she gives for altruism is a textbook one; but in reality few people live their lives entirely without regard for their own needs. Most altruism is in the form of altruistic acts not an entirely altruistic life. You may do something supremely kind at your expense without it being to such an extent you could be said to entirely put others first.


And that's my major issue with Rand: she didn't know real humans. Her experiences were of unusual and extreme circumstances, not of the average. And so she describes scenarios and personalities that are based on academic and false assumptions. As for the visions she paints, rather than a utopian idea of how the world might be they all share one thing: that in reality to live in her future world - if applied to people as they really are - would be just awful. [sic]


My reply:


Actually, Ed, I have found Rand’s thinking on this subject very relevant to real life (though not always her particular application to her life). It is up to each individual to apply philosophic principles to her/his own life, and one does not have to agree with every aspect of Rand’s (or other Objectivists’) individual choices to find value in Objectivist principles. 


Rand sharply distinguished between altruism and rational benevolence/generosity. This has been very helpful in how judging and shaping relationships with others fits into my hierarchy of values.


It is true that “in reality few people live their lives entirely without regard for their own needs.” Altruism has its greatest, and most destructive, application in politics. Note that few people in their personal relationships would demand the sacrifice of others’ wealth or interests for their own needs or interests. But, when turning to politics, where the reality is more abstract, these same people often have no problem expecting the state to forcibly redistribute others’ wealth—hence, the spreading entitlement mentality and our runaway welfare state. Note the politicians’ incessant calls for sacrifice. Altruism, even when only part of an “average”, is a malignancy.


And yes, altruism does get and has been applied in its extreme. The utopian visions of communism and fascism are based on the complete subordination of the individual to “others”, with the state as the embodiment of the others, in the cause of some collectivist good, with real life devastating results. These atrocities cannot and have not been justified or implemented except by reference to the strict textbook definition of altruism, coupled with the explicit rejection of the individual’s rationally self-interested right to his own life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.

I have found Rand’s observations on altruism, and Objectivism more broadly, to be well-grounded in reality and a good guide to practical living.


Related Reading:


Reply Responses to QUORA *: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’


Is Science Catching Up to the Objectivist Ethics?


"Give Back" is a Sinister Ploy to Guilt Achievers Into Giving Up What They Have Earned


Is It Now ‘Respectable’ to be a Moocher?


The Worship of Need: The Path to Communism


Our Pick-Pocket Nation


Bezos Should Focus On Running His Company


Friday, June 24, 2022

Need-Based Morality Penalizes NJ’s Self-Supporting

Back when New Jersey Governor Phil Murphy was pushing for a so-called “millionaires tax” to help fund his Progressivist state budget, a NJ Guest Columnist, Rob Duffey, argued in defense of Murphy on 3/27/19, Don’t worry about the rich; N.J. needs millionaires tax. Need I elaborate? The title says it all.


In response, another guest columnist, Philip Perinelli, explained This is why I’m leaving New Jersey:


I have contemplated writing a letter to the state government of New Jersey, including the Governor, Senate President, Assembly Speaker, and all members of the legislature. The article by Rob Duffey that appeared in the March 27 Star Ledger, titled “Don’t worry about the rich; N.J. needs the millionaires tax” prompted me to write.


Much has been said about a millionaire’s tax. Some say tax them and they will leave. And they well may. Of course, as Mr. Duffey points out, they may not. The fact is that the truly rich can decide to stay or leave. They can afford to do either. Mr. Duffey also points out that the state needs the money. I am not a millionaire. And that is why, while there is much to love about living in this town and this state, my wife and I plan to leave New Jersey in the next several years.


Perinelli is heading for Pennsylvania, where taxes are lower, including on retirees. But he demonstrates something else: It’s not just “the rich” who can be victimized by Progressivism. 


I posted these comments:


“New Jersey needs the revenue,” so we’ll just seize it from those who earned it, at gunpoint. If you don’t like it, you can uproot your life, and leave. 


What can “justify” such an unjust “political argument” as “credible policy?” The morality of altruism, which holds that one person’s need is an automatic claim on others’ wealth. When need is the moral standard, need becomes a political license to steal.


Need is the natural state of life, including human life. Wild animals satisfy their needs by seizing whatever they need. Primitive humans did basically the same, hunting and gathering as needed. The rise of civilization gave rise to wealth production, changing the equation to require justice. 


Altruism is a carryover from primitive man, manifested in “progressivist” politics. It’s not just about millionaires, unfair as a “millionaires tax” is. Gary Sudol asked in a recent letter* why he cannot opt out of the Family Leave Act, which recently quadrupled the payroll tax on workers (4/13/19). Answer; because other people need it, even if Sudol doesn’t.


There are basically two ways for people to satisfy their needs--earn it yourself or prey on others. Progressivism sides with the predator. Do not confuse altruism with generosity, charity, or compassion. There is nothing generous, charitable, or compassionate about Progressivists’ policies, which forcibly redistribute from people who earned it to people who didn’t. They are barbaric and unjust. 


I sympathize with Mr. Perinelli. We can’t escape Progressivism. But we can escape the most unjust states, like NJ. We won’t have completely achieved a fully just and civil society until we make our government protect each individual’s right to what he has earned, rather than some “right” to other people’s earnings.


* [Since I cannot link to the letter because the Star-Ledger no longer publishes its letters-to-the-editor online, I post it here:


Family-leave payroll deductions are unfair--letter 4/13/19


Once again the workers of New Jersey will take another hit. This time we face a big increase in contributions to expand the family-leave program. Some people will see their payments increase fourfold. I have worked over 40 years, have never used this program and will never want to. I would like to know why I don’t have the option to opt out of this program. There are many companies that do offer family-leave programs. If someone wants this benefit, they are free to secure a job with one of these companies. This expanded program is one more step in making New Jersey a bad place for business and taxpayers. I’m looking forward to the day when I will vacate this tax-happy state and relocate to a more taxpayer-friendly state.


Gary Sudol West Orange


The new law greatly increases the payroll tax, while making it more “progressive”--hitting middle and high income workers. It also makes it illegal for a company to replace a worker who takes advantage of the 12-week leave. And proving once again that socialist programs, once enacted, and no matter how small, will inevitably grow like a cancer. This new law expands on a previous law, because the original law was “woefully underutilized.,” with only “The overall participation rate among eligible workers in 2015 [being] less than 1 percent.”


If a program is “underutilized”—meaning, few people  want it—why not eliminate it? Instead, the injustice is expanded, and taxpayers like Gary Sudol are left picking up the tab against their will. Once we accepted the malignancy of forced redistribution of wealth, the cancer aggressively grows. Why? Because someone “needs” the loot. This has been termed The Tyranny of Need. 


Related Reading:


QUORA *: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’


Reply Responses to QUORA *: ‘Is Ayn Rand wrong about altruism?’


People Don’t Want ‘Paid Family Leave’ in NJ, So Let’s Expand It [?]


End, Don’t Expand, NJ’s Paid Family Leave Coercion


Family Leave Insurance No “Success” for Those Who Don’t Want It


“The Decline of American Liberalism”—Six Decades Later By Lance Lamberton


Excerpts from this review:


The most disappointing aspect of The Decline is that it offered no reason for why it took place other than to agree with Jefferson’s observation that “[t]he natural progress of things is for liberty to yield and government to gain ground.”


I would argue that the Founders’ acceptance of the morality of altruism, where self-interest is regarded as immoral and self-sacrifice is the highest moral ideal, was the root cause for the decline of American liberalism. Until classical liberalism embraces rational self-interest as the highest moral ideal and can build a society upon that foundation, then further decline will become the order of the day until, indeed, the well of freedom becomes almost completely dry.


QUORA: ‘Did Ayn Rand support the idea of giving to charity or donating your own money to help other people?’


QUORA: What does Ayn Rand think about vitrues [sic] such as charity, selflessness, and friendship?


Tuesday, January 4, 2022

Another Counter-Productive Attempt to Define Capitalism as Something it’s Obviously Not--Unselfish

Defenders of Capitalism never stop trying to deny that Capitalism is the system of self-interest, and that self-interest is its prime driving force—and the source of its great moral strength. In The Driving Force of Free Markets Is Empathy, Not Greed, Dr Rainer Zitelmann claims, “Only the entrepreneur who prioritizes other people’s needs can be successful. Empathy, the ability to recognize the desires and needs of others, is the true basis of capitalism—not unbridled greed and selfishness.”


Both capitalists and anti-capitalists frequently accuse capitalism of being a system driven by selfishness and greed. Capitalism’s defenders sometimes say: “By nature, man is selfish, which is why socialism will never work. Capitalism better reflects the fundamental characteristics of human nature.” Anti-capitalists claim that capitalism promotes the worst characteristics in man, especially greed.


But are greed and unbridled selfishness really the driving forces of capitalism? Human self-interest is one—not the only—driving force of all human action. But this has nothing to do with a particular economic system. Rather, it is an anthropological constant. In capitalism, however, this self-interest is curbed by the fact that only the entrepreneur who prioritizes other people’s needs can be successful.


Unfortunately, selfishness is never properly defined, just seems to be assumed to equate with treating others badly, rather than the end result of being rational. That’s what’s behind the idea that self-interest needs to be “curbed,” rather than to acknowledge that man needs a moral code to teach him to figure out what is in his self-interest and how to achieve it.


It’s true that to succeed under Capitalism, the entrepreneur must consider or project the needs and wants of consumers. But that focus is a means to the end, not the end. The end--the driving force--is personal fulfillment—selfishness, properly understood as rational self-interest. But every coin has two sides. If the entrepreneur unselfishly “prioritizes other people’s needs,” then what does that make his consumers? According to Zitelmann’s standard, these consumers are geedy takers exploiting the good empathetic nature of the entrepreneur. 


This is nonsense. The consumer is primarily motivated by the same moral force as the entrepreneur, rational selfishness. By protecting every individual from force and fraud through individual rights, Capitalism prioritizes every person’s freedom to pursue his own happiness through trade. Trade is mutually beneficial self-interest in action. By protecting individual rights, Capitalism denies the ability to achieve one’s ends through coercion, predation, violence, fraud, or other criminal means. In this sense, Capitalism actually curbs, rather than promotes, “the worst characteristics in man.” But this is not meant to curb genuine self-interest, the pursuit of personal happiness. The great virtue of a system built on rational selfishness is that it protects everyone’s pursuit of happiness equally by denying to everyone the achievement of one’s goals by engaging in rights-violating actions. *


The happy consequence of this universal benevolent display of “greed” (which is never defined, either) is a system of general betterment without the sacrifice of anyone’s self-interests.


So we get another attempt to define capitalism as something that everybody knows it is not--unselfish. This is and always has been destructive. The underlying assumption that Zitelmann’s line of defense fosters is that Capitalism is at best a necessary evil. To save Capitalism, Capitalism’s defenders must proudly embrace its obvious moral root as a necessary good, making Capitalism itself a necessary good.


* [In fact, it is altruism that promotes the worst characteristics in man. Rational selfishness promotes mutual respect, universal benevolence, and peaceful coexistence. Altruism promotes universal predation as a moral ideal.]


Related Reading:


Why Capitalism is Selfish--and Why That’s Good


Books to Aid in Understanding Rational Selfishness


Capitalism and the Moral High Ground by Craig Biddle


Why Capitalism Needs a Moral Sanction