Showing posts with label U.S. Constitution. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. Constitution. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

Misrepresenting the 1965 Voting Rights Act

The New York Times claims that the “Supreme Court . . . has weakened the Voting Rights Act.” This is unequivocally false, as I have said.


Here are excerpts from two more recent articles, and my comments.


NYT — End Gerrymandering


For a century after Emancipation, millions of Black Southerners could not vote because of a racial caste system based on laws and violence. That violence was often horrific by design, including lynchings, beatings and strategic terror campaigns to crush any attempt at Black political participation. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 attempted to stop this exclusion, and it ensured that voters who had lived in areas with a history of voter suppression could elect representatives who would speak for them in Washington. 


The Voting Rights Act of 1965 attempted to stop this exclusion, and it ensured that voters who had lived in areas with a history of voter suppression could elect representatives who would speak for them in Washington. 


The current gerrymandering campaign undermines that principle. It disproportionately robs Black Americans of the ability to vote for their preferred candidates. Those candidates are not always Black, but they often are, much as white, Asian and Latino voters often support candidates who share their own background. Race, after all, still matters in American life, as is clear from the large Black-white gaps in income, wealth, educational attainment and life expectancy. 


I left these comments:


Ending racial gerrymandering doesn’t “rob Black Americans of the ability to vote for their preferred candidates.” It removes racial discrimination from redistricting. The 1965 Voting Rights Act does not sanction or authorize racial gerrymandering. It was radically reinterpreted to that effect. The VRA was enacted to enforce the 15th Amendment, secure the individual right to vote, ban voter discrimination based on race, and dismantle barriers to voting such as literacy tests and poll taxes. It’s still one-man-one-vote, and everyone has the same ability to vote for their preferred candidate.


NYT says “Race, after all, still matters in American life, as is clear from the large Black-white gaps in income, wealth, educational attainment and life expectancy.” 


But race shouldn’t matter, collective statistical “gaps” notwithstanding. Statistical disparities will always exist. Strict equality of outcome or circumstance will never exist where freedom reigns because it goes against the laws of nature, which is why our system guarantees equality of RIGHTS before the law.  What matters is that every individual’s rights are secured, equally and at all times. The Left wants race to continue to matter, because their whole collectivist worldview depends on it. It sees all issues through a lens of race and tribes. It may have been understandable, though not justifiable, to racially rig districts 60 years ago. But is it still? When will race not matter in America? How about now? 




From The Supreme Court Has Grown Too Powerful. This Is How to Rein It In, Kate Shaw writes


[T]his is a precarious moment for American democracy and for the mechanisms of democratic participation — and because it’s impossible to ignore the Supreme Court’s role in creating this instability. In this election cycle, state legislatures have aggressively redrawn congressional districts to maximize their partisan advantage and, in Southern states, to extinguish Black political power; the ultrarich are spending tens of millions of dollars helping to elect their preferred candidates; and the president has sought to radically change the rules for voting by mail, while openly promising voters payouts for helping his party retain control of Congress. 


True, the court has rebuffed some of the most egregious efforts at election subversion this year. But it has laid the foundation for the electoral upheaval we are experiencing.

That’s one of the reasons fixing the Supreme Court must be a top priority — and why Democrats, if they take control of one or both houses of Congress in November, must place Supreme Court reform at or near the top of their list.


Beginning with John Marshall’s 1803 pronouncement in Marbury v. Madison that “it is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is,” we have gradually come to view the Supreme Court as the final arbiter of the meaning of laws and the Constitution. When the court is functioning properly — when it plays a meaningful but limited role in our system — that’s a reasonable state of affairs, whatever the merits of any particular Supreme Court decision. 


[L]ast term’s Louisiana v. Callais, functionally rendered the Voting Rights Act a dead letter  


“Too powerful” means the Court is doing its job upholding the U.S. Constitution. Louisiana v. Callais is the decision that found racial gerrymandering unconstitutional.


My comment


Some criticisms are valid. But on balance I think the Supreme Court has done a pretty decent job of upholding the Constitution and protecting individual rights from bad law.


But I want to correct one glaringly wrong criticism.


The claim that Louisiana v. Callais “extinguish[ed] Black political power” and “functionally rendered the Voting Rights Act a dead letter” is flat out wrong. The Voting Rights Act secured the individual right to vote equally for everyone. The idea that it established some racial collective “right” to vote was an interpretation of the Act that diminished equality in voting rights. That interpretation made a mockery of the Voting Rights Act, because it switched the right to vote from the individual (where it morally, legally, and logically belongs) to the racial collective, effectively privileging voting majorities within the race-gerrymandered district. It amounts to “All voters are equal, but some voters are more equal than others”—more equal than all other voters, including voting minorities within the racially rigged district.


The Supreme Court didn’t extinguish black voting power, or anyone’s voting power. It reaffirmed equality in voting rights—one man, one vote—and overturned the horrendous miss-interpretation of the Voting Rights Act. Racial discrimination has no place in our electoral process, or anywhere else.


As to reforms, I agree with Marshall . We must be careful not to neuter that vital function of the judicial branch.


Related Reading:


New Jersey’s Racist John R. Lewis Voter Empowerment Act


Woke Redistricting Madness in NJ


Did SCOTUS Promote or Reject Racism in Alabama Redistricting Case?


Re: Supreme Court Updates: Justices Further Weaken Voting Rights Act, Igniting Political Scramble by The New York Times


Wednesday, September 16, 2026

On This Constitution Day, Remember the Declaration of Independence

239 years ago, on September 17, 1787, the Constitutional Convention ended and the Constitution of the United States of America was signed. This day is officially known as Constitution Day.


It was also an occasion for one columnist to declare that the US Constitution is "broken." The New Jersey Star-Ledger's Tom Moran wrote five years ago:


Kids in America are taught to venerate the Constitution, almost as if it were the word of God.


And that’s exactly what Thomas Jefferson feared. He believed it was flawed, that experience would teach each generation new lessons and that it should be redone every 19 years.


But Jefferson lost the argument. And so the Founders signed a Constitution  225 [235] years ago tomorrow that is an impregnable fortress, firmly set against the forces of change that Jefferson welcomed and almost impossible to amend.


Does that make sense? Haven’t we learned valuable lessons over the past few centuries about how democracies thrive, and how they stagnate? In a day when our federal government is so dysfunctional, shouldn't we at least consider fundamental changes?


University of Texas Professor Sanford Levinson is advocating a series of such fundamental changes to the US Constitution, which Moran discusses in his column. Levinson's proposals include instituting a direct popular vote for president and measures to greatly weaken the checks and balances that limit the power of any one branch of government. In essence, Levinson's purpose, according to Moran, is to expand the power of majority rule and break Washington's political "gridlock," which has made our federal government "dysfunctional."


Moran approvingly cites Thomas Jefferson who, as Moran strongly implies, would welcome these constitutional changes, or any changes suited to any generation.


Before we discuss ways to expand the power of electoral majority rule so as to enable the government to get more "done", we need to have a conversation to reiterate what the government's proper job is to do.


The American constitution's basic function is to limit the government's power to the protection of individual rights. This is spelled out in the Declaration of Independence, the philosophical blueprint for the constitution. Any discussion about the constitution has to begin with the Declaration--which, incidentally, was written by Thomas Jefferson:


We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.--That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed. . .


In its essentials, this 55 word statement of proper government says:


  • All men are born equal in moral agency to self-govern their own lives without interference from other men.

  • Each individual has rights to secure his freedom to exercise moral agency.

  • Rights belong inextricably to the individual by virtue of his nature as a human being.

  • Rights are held equally and at all times by all people.

  • Rights are guarantees to freedom of action; to the pursuit of happiness, not to happiness guaranteed by the labor or wealth of others.

  • "Among these rights" includes the right to acquire, use, and dispose of property, as was widely understood by the Founding Generation and which makes logical sense, since property is inextricably linked to life and the pursuit of happiness, without which no other rights are practicable.

  • Rights precede government.

  • Government is created exclusively to “secure”—i.e., protect—rights, not to grant them by legislative decree.

  • Government’s “just powers” being authorized by the people, through a popular vote.

  • “Just powers” being those powers, and only those powers, required for the government to fulfill the purpose for which it was created to begin with—to legally protect the people’s unalienable individual rights to life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness.


Of course, this is not the "Word of God," to be accepted uncritically. Each of these points requires extensive philosophical backup. None of these "truths" are automatically "self-evident." They must be learned and validated scientifically; i.e., morally and philosophically, as determined by the observable facts of reality concerning man and his requirements for survival and flourishing. But these are the essentials, as I see it.


The Founders did not intend to create a democracy, despite Moran's devious attempt to smuggle in that premise. They created a constitutionally limited republic protective of the liberty and rights of the individual, under which the constitution "carefully limits the power of the majority by drawing a legal boundary around it" (P. 113)—a boundary that stops the majority and elected officials' power where individual rights begin. The Founders understood that the government presupposes individual rights. So the constitutional discussion must begin with the questions: What are rights, and what is the proper function of government?


As the Declaration states, every individual is "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness." Since productive work is the only means of sustaining one's life and achieving happiness, it's obvious that the Founders understood--including in Jefferson's own words--that property rights are among those rights. The Declaration then states "That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men." Rights—which in fact are not endowments by either nature or God but moral principles derived from observations and facts about human nature—are sanctions to freedom of action in a social context, not a claim on the lives and property of others or a government guarantee of material well-being and happiness. Notice that the constitution does not authorize the government to redistribute private wealth. Forced redistribution of wealth or income would relegate some people to privilege and others to involuntary servitude, which would violate the principle of equality.


Moran is wrong. America hasn't stagnated. It has "progressed" from what was a largely free country a century ago to a burgeoning regulatory welfare state—a dangerous regressionary trend unsupported by constitutional authority. Why? Because the fundamental principles upon which the constitution rests have been largely abandoned, opening the door to the piecemeal progression toward unlimited majoritarian rule, a manifestation of totalitarianism. Consequently, our best short-term protection against further encroachments on individual rights--and it's a weak protection--is political gridlock. I can't think of anything more dangerous to America's future than to begin tampering with the basics of the constitution in today's cultural environment. Before we consider unshackling majority rule, we must rediscover our Founding principles, roll back the regulatory welfare state, and provide ironclad guarantees that no one's rights be alienated by majority vote; i.e., respect the original intent of the constitution.


The Founders did not intend to replace absolute monarchy with absolute majority rule unconstrained by the principle of individual rights. As Benjamin Martin (Mel Gibson) asked during a debate over the propriety of the Revolutionary War in the movie "The Patriot", "Why should I trade one tyrant 3000 miles away for 3000 tyrants one mile away? An elected legislature can trample a man's rights as easily as a king can."


The answer: We shouldn't. As Jefferson said, "the majority, oppressing an individual, is guilty of a crime, abuses its strength, and by acting on the law of the strongest breaks up the foundations of society." The Founders were not primarily concerned with giving the people the right to vote. They intended to liberate the people from predatory government, whether monarchistic, theocratic, socialist, or democratic.


There are those who would invert the original concept of Americanism—that the individual is sovereign and his life belongs to him—and replace it with the idea that the collective—i.e., the state—is sovereign over the individual. It is an attempted transition from republican constitutionalism to democracy; from individualism to collectivism. We cannot let the counter-revolutionary reactionaries succeed. The fight to defeat the reactionaries and restore and renew Americanism can start with this: As we celebrate Constitution Day, remember what I call the Constitution’s philosophic blueprint, or what has also been called the Conscience of the Constitution—the Declaration of Independence.


Related Reading:


The Philosophy that Framed the Constitution: The US Constitution: political football, romantic relic, or something more? By Dan Sanchez for FEE


The Federalist Papers by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay 


America the Undemocratic


On a Revisionist's Proposal to Upend the Declaration of Independence


Atlas Shrugged: America’s Second Declaration of Independence—Onkar Ghate


The Declaration of Independence


The Conscience of the Constitution: The Declaration of Independence and the Right to Liberty—Timothy Sandefur


Constitutional Ignorance Led to a Tyranny of the Majority—Gary M. Galles


July 4, 1776: 'Words that Will Never Be Erased'


Sunday, December 8, 2024

The Constitution, Property Rights, and Climate Change

QUORA: According to the U.S. Constitution, one of the government’s essential roles is to protect property. Climate change and rising sea levels put some property at risk of flooding. What do conservatives want to do about this?


My answer:


Let me start by stating unequivocally that I am not a conservative. I speak only for myself. 


As to the question, it’s true that one of the government’s essential roles is to protect property. That is made crystal clear in the 5th and 14th Amendments, as well as throughout the Federalist Papers. But that protection extends only to human predators, be they the government, domestic criminals, or foreign enemies. Natural processes, like sea level rise, are outside the scope of government. And, yes, climate change and sea level rise, even if partially linked to human activities, is a natural process. Man is part of nature, and like all life forms, man has a particular mode of survival, which is to apply his mind and labor to altering, re-shaping, and improving the natural conditions of nature to his own benefit. But natural processes are not human predators, and thus don’t fall under the essential government role to protect anyone’s property.


Of course, the U.S. government can and does tax its citizens to build seawalls, dikes, sand dunes, and the like to protect coastal properties from the seas. We can argue whether or not the government should be doing it. But, to my understanding, that is not authorized anywhere in the Constitution. 


Elsewhere, Dennis Manning Answered, in part:


The Preamble to the Constitution lays out the basics of essential roles…to establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for common defense, promote general welfare, and to secure the blessings of liberty for us and future generations. Defense of the nation is not the same as protecting property. That is not the government’s role.


My reply:


I generally agree with everything beyond the first paragraph, which is completely erroneous in its conclusion—”protecting property . . . is not the government’s role.”


What is Justice, if not to secure rights to persons and property? What, exactly, does “the blessings of liberty” mean, if not the right of property, without which no other rights, including the right to life, are possible? If you’ve ever read the Federalist Papers, the Constitution’s definitive resource, you would know that the protection of property rights is a primary goal of the government. E.G. Federalist 54: “Government is instituted no less for protection of the property, than of the persons of individuals. The one as well as the other, therefore may be considered as represented by those who are charged with the government.” John Locke, the Founders’ most cited Enlightenment philosopher and the originator of the concept of unalienable individual rights, understood property rights to be inextricably linked to man’s rights. Man, Locke argued, has a fundamental natural right to his own person, and by logical extension to the product of his own labor, and that the government’s job is to secure those Natural Rights to Property, along with Life and Liberty, through its laws.


As to the Constitution:


The 5th Amendment states “. . . No person shall . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation.


The 14th Amendment states “. . . nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law.”


And what exactly does “the common defense” (“defense of the nation”) mean, if not protecting the rights of its citizens, including their private property? 


Related Reading:


The Federalist Papers by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay


The Primacy of Property Rights and the American Founding -- David Upham for FEE


Property Rights and the Constitution -- Cato Handbook for Policymakers