Showing posts with label Contracts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Contracts. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 31, 2023

Jennifer Rubin’s Orwellian ‘Understanding’ of a Free Market

George Orwell’s 1984 features a tyrannical government’s tool called doublethink, which inverts the meaning of concepts to enhance the government’s power to stifle freedom. One infamous example of this “Newspeak,” the fictional language of Oceania, 1984’s totalitarian superstate, is the slogan “Freedom is Slavery.”


Washington Post columnist Jennifer Rubin apparently has her own version of doublethink. In a recent column, Distinguished pol of the week: A champion of free markets the GOP should embrace, Rubin defended a proposed Federal Trade Commission rule legally banning private non-compete clauses in private contracts as a win for free markets:


Lina M. Khan, head of the Federal Trade Commission, is demonstrating a commitment to competitiveness and free markets that even Republicans should embrace. The most recent example: the FTC’s proposal this past week to do away with noncompete agreements.


Such agreements prevent workers from going to work for a competing employer for months or even years. As the FTC explained in a statement, this is a "widespread and often exploitative practice that suppresses wages, hampers innovation, and blocks entrepreneurs from starting new businesses.” The release added: “By stopping this practice, the agency estimates that the new proposed rule could increase wages by nearly $300 billion per year and expand career opportunities for about 30 million Americans.”


The proposed rule is far-reaching. The FTC explains: “The proposed rule would apply to independent contractors and anyone who works for an employer, whether paid or unpaid. It would also require employers to rescind existing noncompetes and actively inform workers that they are no longer in effect.” [My emphasis]


It’s far-reaching, alright. These employment agreements are voluntary contracts between private employers and employees. A government ban is government coercion. It is tyranny. If the government can impose this rule, what feature of private contracts can’t it ban, or dictate, on vague justifications such as fighting “exploitation,” raising wages, advancing innovation, or supporting entrepreneurialism? Based on this “far-reaching” attack on freedom of contract and association, what limiting principle is left to reign in the government's control of private economic contracts?


As David McGarry writes for Reason in The FTC Wants To Outlaw Noncompete Clauses, but Does It Have the Authority?, “If it can survive legal challenges, the FTC's ban on noncompetes would have a massive impact on the rights of employers and workers.” [My emphasis]


Indeed—a negative impact, I would stress. Even worse, as McGarry points out, and as is announced in the FTC press release included in Rubin’s column, the rule would be retroactive, rescinding non-compete clauses in pre-existing contracts agreed to when noncompete clauses were legal. This is ex-post-facto law, a gift to any aspiring tyrant and a blatant violation of the U.S. Constitution. What can be more anti-free market than the ability of government regulators to declare all private contracts as subject to being made unlawful on the whim of any bureaucrat at any time in the future? Where is the rule of law that free markets depend upon for their very existence? The FTC rule does not, contrary to Rubin’s assertion, protect “a fundamental principle of free-market capitalism: the right to contract that both an employer and employee can agree to.” It is a trojan horse that destroys it.


True, non-compete clauses can be problematic. In one report, I read of a case where an employee was fired due to a recession. The non-compete agreement blocked him from some job opportunities offered by competitors, even though leaving his job was not his choice. But as McGarry pointed out, an employee could sue if he thinks the clause was abused. On the other hand, as McGarry and others have pointed out, without non-compete agreements, employees' opportunities to advance career-wise can be severely restricted, as without non-competes companies become more leery of sharing sensitive company information with employees they are not absolutely sure are strictly loyal, hampering advancements to higher-level job openings within the company. As McGarry points out,


Employers and employees weigh many kinds of benefits and drawbacks when considering whether to sign a contract—monetary and otherwise. Fully banning non compete clauses may help some, but will undoubtedly wreak unanticipated havoc on many others.


"With all due respect to the majority, I am dubious that three unelected technocrats have somehow hit upon the right way to think about non-competes, and that all the preceding legal minds to examine this issue have gotten it wrong," Wilson wrote [FTC Commissioner Christine Wilson is the lone dissenter on the new policy.]


But the bottom line is, these are private transactions. Private voluntary employment agreements that don’t involve fraud or criminal actions are none of the government’s business. 


Rubin might want to ask herself, “What does the ‘free’ in free market actually mean?” Contrary to Rubin’s doublethink, “free” does not mean an FTC ban on non-compete agreements. Put simply, it means the absence of government coercion in private economic transactions. It means to leave law-abiding, rights-respecting economic activity free of government coercion. The proposed FTC rule is the very essence of government coercion, and thus the very antithesis of a free market.  


Related Reading:


Gay Marriage, Freedom of Association, and Equal Protection of the Law


Gay Marriage: The Right to Voluntary Contract, Not to Coercive “Contract”


The Right to Discriminate is About Contract, Not Religion


Monday, January 23, 2023

Earned Pay vs. Need-Based Pay--or, Justice vs. Injustice

A couple of years ago, major bank CEOs appeared before a Congressional committee. One CEO, Jamie Dimon of JP Morgan, was asked a stupid question by an ignorant Congresswoman, Katie Porter. According to CNN,


Freshman Rep. Katie Porter stumped multimillionaire JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon during a hearing Wednesday with a simple question: How are workers supposed to make ends meet?


The back-and-forth occurred during a House Financial Services Committee hearing featuring the CEOs of several major banks on Wednesday. Porter, a California Democrat, shared the story of a JPMorgan Chase employee – making a fraction of what the company’s top executives are paid – who is running a $567 deficit each month because her salary is insufficient to cover basic expenses.


“How should she manage this budget shortfall while she’s working full-time at your bank?” Porter asked Dimon.


Dimon’s answer was basically that he’d have to think about, and would need to check the math. The hypothetical employee’s salary is $16.50 per hour, plus benefits. Porter used the exchange to demand that Dimon’s bank pay employees enough to make ends meet, regardless of any other considerations. 


With Dimon’s disappointing response leaving much to be desired, Michael Dahlen, writing for The Objective Standard, suggested How Jamie Dimon Should Have Answered Representative Katie Porter. 


As you’d expect from TOS, Dahlen suggested a good, hard-hitting moral and economic lesson to Congresswoman Porter. I give Dahlen a thumbs up. But I thought I’d take a crack at an answer myself. I composed my rough draft before reading Dahlen’s article, just to compare for myself. I must say, I think I did a very credible job. Here is my “How Jamie Dimon Should Have Answered Representative Katie Porter”:


First, let me say that a job is a two-way street. It’s based on mutual self-interest. We, as an employer with particular concerns, have as much right to do what’s best for our business as the employee has to do what’s best for herself in the context of her life and concerns. Ideally, both can find common ground and advance our respective interests together by the prospective employee accepting our job offer.


As to our policy, the employee is paid according to her productive contribution to our business, not her needs. As she gains knowledge, skills, and experience, she has the opportunity to advance in pay and position. In the meanwhile, she’ll have to figure out how to get by. Her life is her responsibility. 


We do “provide a way for families to make ends meet.” We offer jobs--good paying jobs with opportunity for advancement. But we don’t give handouts. If we pay people by need, rather than productiveness and competence, then soon enough there will be no business and the jobs, including mine, will be gone. Then how will she make ends meet? If a person doesn’t have to earn her pay, and instead get paid according to whatever she claims are her needs, then all incentive to excel at her job evaporates--along with the incentive of all of the other employees, whose competence suddenly doesn’t matter, only their needs.


Yes, I make vastly more money than her. That’s because my responsibilities and productiveness are vastly greater than hers. In fact, hers and the jobs of all 250,000+ JP Morgan employees depend on my ability to do my job competently. The only just and objective method of setting pay rates for all of these employees is merit, as judged by management and, ultimately, the judgment of the market; i.e., our customers, the ultimate end of our business. Anything other than a merit-based standard will ultimately result in inferior products, harm to our customers, and finally the loss of our customers. Need is neither just nor objective as a standard, and thus is not rational or sustainable. 


I started by emphasizing that a job is a two-way street. And as it turns out, such a relationship of mutual self-interest turns out to be win-win. Both sides advance their own well-being, based on mutual agreement. Our employees' jobs depend on a fair and rational pay policy just as much as our business does. 


I wish more businessmen would stand up for their right to exist, not just on economic grounds, but on moral grounds as well


Related Reading:


No Conflict Between People and Business


"Greed" is a Two-Way Street


If We’re to Have Labor Laws, Should They Work Both Ways?


Is ‘Common Good Capitalism’ a One-way Street?


On the Purpose of a Corporation by the Business Roundtable, PART 1


On the Purpose of a Corporation by the Business Roundtable, PART 2


Friday, July 10, 2015

Christie's Cowardly Second Veto of New Jersey’s Proposed Surrogate Motherhood Bill

For the second time in three years, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie vetoed the New Jersey Gestational Carrier Agreement Act. This act is intended to clarify the rights and contractual responsibilities of aspiring childless couples and the surrogates they hire as gestational carriers for their children, as well as protect the child in the event that either side reneges on the prior agreement. Current law does not “take into account this advance in reproductive technology.”


The latest version of the bill the NJ Legislature sent to Christie is identical to the first one the governor vetoed. For my analysis of NJ’s “Gestational Carrier” bill, read my Objective Standard blog post of June 2012, New Jersey's Surrogate Motherhood Bill and its Vicious Opposition.


As NJ.com’s Susan K. Livio reports, Christie’s reason for vetoing the latest bill is that “None of the ‘significant ethical and moral concerns raised by a government-enforced system of agreements to procreate’ have been addressed, according to the veto statement.” What “concerns” did the governor have? As Livio reported in August 2012:


According to the governor's statement explaining the veto obtained by The [New Jersey] Star-Ledger, "Permitting adults to contract with others regarding a child in such a manner unquestionably raises serious and significant issues."


"In contrast to traditional surrogacy, a gestational surrogate birth does not use the egg of the carrier," the governor wrote. "In this scenario, the gestational carrier lacks any genetic connection to the baby, and in some cases, it is feasible that neither parent is genetically related to the child. Instead, children born to gestational surrogates are linked to their parents by contract."


"While some all applaud the freedom to explore these new, and sometimes necessary, arranged births, others will note the profound change in the traditional beginnings of the family that this bill will enact. I am not satisfied that these questions have been sufficiently studied by the Legislature at this time," according to the statement.


What is there to study? That the gestational carrier method is new, different from the old? So what? That it involves a contract? So what? That some “others will note the profound change in the traditional beginnings of the family?” So what? Let them note what they like. No “other” has to engage in this new, “non-traditional” way of starting a family, if they disapprove. What busybody “others” have the right to stand in the way of couples seeking this new avenue to familyhood? And that’s the question Christie doesn’t answer—the why. Why keep antiquated legal roadblocks to gestational carrier contracts in place? Whose rights do the parties to gestational carrier agreements violate? No one’s. And that’s the point. Consenting adults have a right to voluntarily contract to mutual advantage, and as long as no intended or actual rights violations are evident, the government has a duty to uphold and enforce the contracts.


By Christie’s standards, this bill could never get enacted. How does the legislature “study”—i.e., reconcile—the irrational prejudices of the alleged defenders of “the traditional beginnings of the family” with those who “applaud the freedom to explore these new . . . arranged births?” Was any reconciliation possible between proponents of the tradition of slavery and those seeking freedom for the slaves, which is every human being’s rightful due? By Christie’s standards, slavery could never have been abolished.


The reason for Christie’s latest veto is no less vacuous that his rationalization for his first veto of the bill. As Livio reported in June, Christie, citing his prior concerns, said “I take seriously the need to guard against any societal deprecation of the miracle of life.” The NJ Star-Ledger correctly ridiculed Christie's ridiculous rationalization in an editorial titled Christie's empty talk about the "miracle of life". The Star-Ledger wrote:


Please. Surrogacy is perfectly legal in New Jersey, and hundreds of babies are being born this way already. What does this veto have to do with protecting the "miracle of life"?


Christie simply wants to ingratiate himself with conservatives who disapprove of the entire concept of surrogacy, because of their personal religious beliefs. That's not protecting babies. It's pandering.


I left these comments:


While I probably can’t support every regulation written into the New Jersey Gestational Carrier Agreement Act, I wholeheartedly support the concept behind the bill. The technology behind surrogate parenting is a truly man-made miracle, and the law should catch up with these scientific advances. The proper job of government is to make laws protecting individual rights. This bill would go a long way toward protecting the rights of aspiring parents, gestational carriers, and the child.


Opposition to this bill is rooted in a broader opposition by the so-called “pro-life” conservatives with their otherworldly “miracle of life” fantasies to the intervention of human intelligence to solve the problems of human procreation. This opposition is often camouflaged as a fight against the “exploitation” of women, as if women are too stupid to exercise their fundamental right to make good choices about what is in their own best interests. These mystical conservatives are the same people that tried or are still trying to outlaw “test tube babies” (in vitro fertilization, without which two of my six grandchildren would not exist) around the world.


But here in the real world, the ability of childless couples to have children they otherwise couldn’t have thanks to gestational surrogacy is the real miracle of life. I don’t know whether Christie is pandering or not. I certainly wouldn’t put it past the Democrats to play politics with this bill. Either way, it’s a real shame that this straightforward issue is not getting resolved.


-------------------


My last sentences are not really accurate. I'm convinced that the Star-Ledger is correct: Christie is pandering to the religious right. I just wanted to avoid the partisan aspect for the sake of not blurring the fundamental issues. And Christie’s pandering is of the most cowardly kind—refusing to take a stand while hiding behind vague demands for “more study.” An advocate of individual rights and free markets would have no trouble deciding on this issue.


Related Reading:

New Jersey's Surrogate Motherhood Bill and its Vicious Opposition.

Sunday, May 18, 2014

Cronyism, not "Conspiracy", is the Problem in New Jersey

The New Jersey Star-Ledger hinted at A Tesla conspiracy in NJ; a reference to efforts in the state to ban Tesla from selling its electric cars directly to consumers. 

New Jersey recently enacted a rule, through its Motor Vehicle Commission, stopping Tesla Motors from selling its electric cars directly to NJ consumers. Governor Chris Christie noted that he was obligated to enforce a long-standing state law that he interpreted as forbidding direct car sales to consumers by manufacturers.

In response, notes the Star-Ledger, two NJ politicians have proposed amending the existing mandatory franchise law to allow electric car makers to sell direct, while continuing to compel gas-powered car makers to sell only through independent dealerships.

The Star-Ledger was speaking "tongue-in-cheek" about a conspiracy, but the paper begged the question: What is really going on in New Jersey? I left these comments:



  • Franchise dealerships get government favoritism through a re-existing law forbidding car manufacturers from selling cars directly to consumers.
  • Greenwald and Eustace want to carve out a special exemption to that law for electric car makers, a government favor to Tesla.
  • Tesla buyers get a special federal tax credit of $7500 that gas-powered car buyers don't get, which is government favoritism for Tesla. 

The problem is not "conspiracy". The problem is plain, old-fashioned cronyism. The right solution is to eliminate the pre-existing franchise-mandate, extend equal tax credits (i.e., lower taxes) to all car consumers, and leave car manufacturers, consumers, and franchise dealerships free to contract voluntarily to mutual advantage on a level legal playing field, also known as a free market.

Related Reading:

Tesla the Beneficiary of Crony Laws

Friday, May 2, 2014

Force Means Denying Someone the Right to Refuse.

Correspondents often stray off-topic, and that was the case regarding to comment below. Under The Right to Choose Death, which has to do with assisted suicide, bayshore lady wrote:
I never said that.What I said is that so-called faith based employers should not be able to refuse it to their employees,thuis [sic] forcing their faith on them.

Even though off-topic, I thought this was an excellent concrete opportunity to clarify the relation of force with individual rights.

Bayshore, you are conceptually confused.

The right to refuse is precisely what liberty is all about. Under proper laws, the employer is simply choosing not to provide the contraceptive coverage. This is not  "forcing their faith on them," since he is acting only within the confines of his own business. His employees or prospective employees have no right to that which he does not willingly offer to provide. They are simply free to accept the terms, attempt to negotiate terms more to their liking, or seek employment elsewhere.

If the faith-based employer were to seek a law legally forbidding any employer from including contraceptive coverage, THAT would be forcing his faith on others. But the opposite is, in fact, the case. Since the contraceptive mandate legally forces all employers to cover contraception, it is the faith-based employer who is being forced to accept ideas he disagrees with. THEIR right to say no is infringed. Absent any law one way or the other, there is no force. The employer is free to refuse to offer the coverage, and the job-seeker is free to refuse the job.

Related Reading:

Gay Marriage: The Right to Voluntary Contract, Not to Coercive “Contract”


How the Catholic Church Paved the Way for the Birth Control Mandate


Private Sector Anti-Discrimination Laws are Rights-Violating and Destructive

Saturday, January 11, 2014

Gay Marriage Rights vs. Anti-Discrimination Laws

When Superior Court Judge Mary Jacobson legalized gay marriage in New Jersey last year, an opponent raised this objection:


But John Tomicki, president of the New Jersey Coalition to Preserve and Protect Marriage, said the institution should be kept to "one man and one woman" and that the ruling puts "freedom of religion and freedom of conscience at great risk."
"If a member of a religious denomination says that within their faith beliefs, they do not support same-gender marriage, will it be an act of discrimination if they refuse to officiate at such marriage?" Tomicki said. "Those are cases that are going on now across the country."

Tomicki is confused. If "a member of a religious denomination says that within their faith beliefs, they do not support same-gender marriage, [and thus] refuse to officiate at such marriage," it most certainly is "an act of discrimination." And it is that religious member's inalienable right to do so. But freedom of religion and freedom of conscience are not at great risk because two people of the same gender choose to marry. Freedom of conscience is put at risk because of anti-discrimination laws that facilitate such lawsuits.

Relating to this subject, the NJ Star-Ledger chimed in with Why should NJ sanctify religious discrimination against gays? Referring to legislative proposals to write religious exemptions to anti-discrimination laws, the editors objected to provisions that protect. . .


religious groups against lawsuits based on a broad range of discrimination against gay couples. A religious group that owns a banquet hall, for example, would be free to deny its space to gay couples, even when it makes that space available to the general public. Why should New Jersey sanctify that type of discrimination? If a religious group denied that same space to an African-American couple based on race, or a Jewish couple based on religion, that would violate laws against discrimination. 

I left these comments:

NJ law should not "sanctify religious discrimination against gays"—or sanctify any type of discrimination. But neither does the state have any right to forbid it. 

Private individuals have a fundamental, inalienable right to freely associate, or refrain from associating, with whom they please, for whatever reason, religious or non-religious, business or personal, rational or irrational, so long as they don't violate others' rights. From a legal perspective, marriage is strictly a matter of voluntary contract. Voluntary contract is based on the inalienable right to freedom of association. Thus, gay marriage is an inalienable right, based on freedom of contract and association. But if a banquet business refuses to host a gay wedding, they are not violating the gay couple's rights in any way. Same-sex individuals have an inalienable right to voluntarily contract, but not to coercive "contract."

Anti-discrimination statutes relating to governmental functions and hiring, such as the MVC,  are appropriate and necessary. Anti-discrimination laws levied against private citizens and their businesses are fundamentally unjust, because they violate the basic principles of liberty; the inalienable rights to life, liberty—including liberty of conscience—and pursuit of happiness. This editorial proves it.

Rather than twist themselves into pretzels trying to incorporate special exemptions from such laws for select special interests, such as religions or "religious leaders", legislators should be repealing such laws. Removing such laws don't "sanctify that type of discrimination"—or any type of discrimination. They protect liberty for everyone. Jim Crow laws, separate-but-equal laws, anti-sodomy laws, etc., are the kinds of laws that sanction discrimination. Laws that forbid private discrimination sanction economic aggression [in the form of predatory lawsuits, or the fear of such suits], rights-violations, and the principles of liberty. 

Those who support marriage contract rights for gays but then turn around and claim that gay couple may legally force business contracts on unwilling others against their convictions and choice are being blatantly hypocritical. In the name of anti-discrimination, they are discriminating against people that they disagree with by denying them their rights to freedom of contractual choice.

Related, another correspondent took issue, reminding me of what the law states:


WRONG. Businesses that allow the public access to their facilities are considered places of public accommodation, even if they are owned by religious organizations. As long as a church opens up a banquet hall to the public for rental, it cannot discriminate in who is allowed to rent the hall. If the church were to make the hall available only to members of its congregation, that would be a different story.

My reply:

Morally, it should not discriminate. But it should not be legally barred from doing so. "Public accommodation" and "public access" do not justify violating rights to liberty of contract. Proper laws do not protect "the public." They protect individual rights. I support liberty of contract fully and consistently, which is why I support gay marriage rights and the rights not to be forced into "contracts." Forced "contracts" are not contracts at all, but a form of tyranny of some men over others. Just as anti-gay bigots have no right to force their marital ideology on others, so pro-gay zealots have no right to force their views on others. We need peaceful coexistence, not force.
Related Reading:

Gay Marriage: The Right to Voluntary Contract, Not Coercive "Contract"







Monday, August 12, 2013

Will Contracts Be the Next Victim of Eminent Domain?

My latest post at The Object Standard blog sheds light on another emerging threat to our liberties. Here is the opening paragraph:

In 2005, in Kelo v. City of New London, the Supreme Court permitted cities to take land by force for the purpose of “economic development.” Now officials in Newark, New Jersey want to expand their use of eminent domain to seize mortgages in order to pressure lenders to the “negotiating table” and thus “help” homeowners with underwater mortgages receive a reduction in principal.

Read the rest of Newark Seeks to Use Eminent Domain to Extort Principal Reductions from Lenders.

A mortgage is a legally and morally binding contract voluntarily agreed to by lender and borrower, and each has a right to expect the government to enforce its terms.  Newark’s proposed actions constitute legally facilitated breach of contract.

To halt the ever-expanding eminent domain assault on our liberties, Americans must recognize that no public good can be served by violating the rights of any individual member of the public; that any implementation of eminent domain is an act of injustice. That's why, as I concluded in my TOS piece, we must call for total abolition of eminent domain.

Related Reading:

The Eminent Domain Assault by Readington Against Solberg Land is Democracy in Action—and Un-American

Honoring American Heroes . . . Forgetting American Ideals

Eminent Domain—Always an Abuse