Showing posts with label Communism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Communism. Show all posts

Friday, October 2, 2026

Socialism vs. Welfare Statism: Why These Terms Matter

I originally posted a version of this essay about 8 years ago. But after reposting my updated version of Criminal Socialism vs. a Free Society, and given the recent surge in interest and support for Democratic Socialism in the United States of America, I see it necessary to repost an updated version of Socialism vs. Welfare Statism: Why These Terms Matter. Why? Because Socialists are pointing to America’s welfare programs as Socialism, and arguing for more of the same. But the welfare state, more accurately called Welfare Capitalism, is not Socialism. Socialism and welfare statism of fundamentally different social systems. The Democratic Socialists are trying to pull off a dangerous bait-and-switch, and if America falls for it, we will end up an enslaved country.


Venezuela is a prime example, among many prime examples, of Socialism fully and properly instituted. But Socialists point to welfare states as examples of Socialism in action. But Germany, England, the Scandinavian countries, Canada, et al are NOT socialist. Socialism is the political implementation of the principle that the interests of “society” as represented by the government take precedence over individual interests. Therefore, socialism denies individual rights, including rights to property and free trade: The “people,” as a number of individuals, exist to serve the interests of society as determined by the state. Socialism, to be socialism, has to deny individual choice (individual rights), because Capitalistic rights directly conflict with it’s principles. As the Socialist Robert Heilbroner observed:


The rights of individuals to their Millian liberties [are] directly opposed to the basic social commitment to a deliberately embraced collective moral goal…


Dissents, disagreements, and departures from norms then assume a far more threatening aspect than under bourgeois [i.e., Capitalist] society, for they hold out the possibility of destroying the very commitment to a moral consensus by which socialist society differs from capitalist.


Nor can we wriggle off this hook by asserting that, among its moral commitments, socialism will choose to include the rights of individuals to their Millian liberties. For that celebration of individualism is directly opposed to the basic socialist commitment to a deliberately embraced collective moral goal. [my emphasis]


These European countries are not socialist (although Germany WAS once socialist, under National Socialist [NAZI] rule). They, like America, are mixed economy welfare states. Unlike totalitarian socialism, Western welfare states still have a healthy degree of private enterprise and free market Capitalism, and thus a still-healthy recognition and protection for individual rights, including rights to property and free trade. Because of this, welfare states’ Capitalist-oriented, hampered market economies can still generate continued prosperity and rising living standards even while carrying the burden of financing the welfare state, differing only in the balance between the two. 


It’s important to get this understanding right, because most Democrats now view socialism more positively than capitalism, according to Gallup.* Welfare statism is different in crucial respects from democratic socialism. It is true that the limited socialistic aspects—mainly redistribution of wealth—of the welfare state requires the limited use of the same statist powers as does full socialism. But its goal, in theory, is a “safety net” for capitalism, not a replacement--i.e., a mixed economy; that is, a mixture, albeit a tense one, between statist income redistribution and Capitalism. Under the Western style welfare state, individual rights and free enterprise are still fundamental, and socialism is limited in scope so much freedom remains. Democratic Socialism implies no limits. The distinction is important. No longer content with the limits of the welfare state, and driven by hatred of freedom, capitalism, and achievement, the Democrats are now in the process of “graduating” to full blown totalitarian socialism, including massive central control and strict economic regimentation. It won’t be easy to bring about in America. But once we start down this road, the result will be the same as it always is--loss of economic, political, and intellectual freedom, growing economic paralysis and eventual collapse, massive human suffering, and the total state. What else can one expect when the individual is subordinated to the collective? Of what importance are hordes of suffering individuals next to whatever grand utopian collectivist ideal the state happens to want to impose “for the good of society?” 


No doubt, Trump has an authoritarian streak--his antitrust threats against Amazon for Bezos’s WAPO editorial criticisms; his regulatory threats against Google for alleged search engine “bias”; his tax bullying of U.S. multinational corporations; his threat of stronger libel laws against reporters; his communistic taking of equity stakes in dozens of private companies; his nation-over-individual rights of Americans’ justification for unConstitutional tariffs. But this is penny-ante statism next to democratic socialism. Totalitarian? Based on

what ideology? Trump doesn’t even have one! Next to democratic socialism, Trump is a schoolyard bully. Democratic socialism is the Al Capone crime organization, rising out of the underworld to rule a nation. Democratic socialism is across the board a criminal enterprise, but with law as protector rather than adversary. It makes the real Al Capones of history look like pickpockets.


If you like Germany, then stick with what Germany actually is, a Western-style mixed economy welfare state. We can at least debate the relative balance between capitalism and socialism. Freedom and prosperity, at least, has a chance. But be aware of what you’re advocating if you declare your allegiance to socialism, democratic or otherwise--the total subordination of the individual to the state.


As theory and history has unequivocally demonstrated, there is no essential difference between Socialism and totalitarianism. A government that owns and regulates the means of production, exchange, and distribution; that can distribute all of a country’s money equally; in which government rather than individual people owns or controls all industry, is a government with total control over the economy. Since economics is the field of human activity by which people support their lives, a government that totally controls the economy has total control over people’s means of survival. A government with total control over people's means of survival is a government that has every individual by the throat. Such a government can enforce its will in every area of life  and liberty through economic sanctions. What freedom, what opposition, is possible under such conditions? Does it matter whether the political leaders are elected or not? A government, of whatever kind, that has every individual by the throat IS a totalitarian state. Logic confirms this truth. History has proven this time and again.


To summarize, the welfare state—more accurately labeled Welfare Capitalism—is a Capitalist-oriented, individualistic, free market system with a government-imposed “social safety net” but with strong though not fully consistent protections for individual rights to life, liberty, and property. Capitalistic freedom is the foundation and the financial support for the welfare state. Socialism is a collectivist other-oriented system that prioritizes the group over the individual, in which the state tolerates individual existence only to the extent that it furthers the goals of the state as the determinant of the collective will. Of necessity, Socialism is totalitarian, because it owns or controls all economic activity—“the means of production”—and thus exerts control over all aspects of people’s lives because the economy is the area of activity in which people work and trade to support their lives. Poverty is the unavoidable result because the market freedom that supports the welfare state is erased under Socialism.


The welfare state is to Socialism what CATO’s Paul Meany and Marian Tupy describe as “the crucial difference between government assistance and government control,” or what more crudely (but I think more succinctly) describe as the difference between the pick-pocket is to the murderer. In the Declaration of Independence it is written,
That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends [to secure individual rights], it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.
But,
Prudence, indeed, will dictate that Governments long established should not be changed for light and transient causes; and accordingly all experience hath shewn, that mankind are more disposed to suffer, while evils are sufferable, than to right themselves by abolishing the forms to which they are accustomed.
Clearly, the evils of our current welfare statism are “sufferable”—i.e. tolerable. Capitalism, hampered, diluted, and violated as it is in today’s America—still functions strongly enough to carry the welfare burden and still drive prosperity and growth forward. No remnants of  Capitalism in America, as in Venezuela, could ever survive Socialism. That is why the terms Socialism and Welfare Statism matter. Americans must think twice and think deeply about even considering, let alone choosing, Socialism over Capitalism. It’s literally a matter of life and death.

Related Viewing:


Is the US Already Quasi-Socialist? By CATO


Related Reading:


Socialism's Totalitarian Nature Cannot Be Obscured by 'Democratic Socialism'


Criminal Socialism vs. a Free Society


We Need a Deeper Understanding of Socialism


Why Nazism Was Socialism and Why Socialism Is Totalitarian--George Reisman


The Myth of Scandinavian Socialism


Elizabeth Warren’s Plan — We’ve Seen This Before--Stephen Hicks


Fascism: Back Door to Socialism that Obama and the Left Well Understand


A is A, and Socialism by any Other Name...


QUORA: ‘Is it possible to be both a Communist and a Fascist?’


Why do fascism and communism often go hand in hand when they are philosophically polar opposites?


Is fascism a form of capitalism?’


Bill Maher’s Category Error on Socialism: There’s a big difference between government assistance and government control. By Marian L. Tupy


Thursday, August 28, 2025

Trump's policies are fascism

 QUORA: "What term do you think best describes Trump's attempts to control the U.S. economy — state capitalism, fascist capitalism, or is there another term?"

My answer:

Neither “state capitalism” nor “fascist capitalism.” Both are logically invalid terms because Capitalism by definition means the absence of government interference into—or control of—the economy (i.e. the separation of economics and state). Trump’s policies are, in fact, straight-up socialism of the fascist, as opposed to the Communist, variety.

Related Reading:

QUORA: ‘Is fascism a form of capitalism?’

The Capitalist Manifesto by Andrew Bernstein

Tuesday, December 26, 2023

QUORA: ‘What three points do communists and fascists disagree on?’

 QUORA: ‘What three points do communists and fascists disagree on?’


I posted this answer:


  1. Communism is international socialism: It seeks a worldwide homogenous system. Fascism is national socialism: It seeks to tailor its system to the customs and traditions of individual nations.

  2. Communism allows no private property or private enterprise. Fascism allows a superficial veneer of both. But it is only a veneer of privatization, as all economic forces, as Mussolini put it, must be “coordinated and harmonized in the unity of the State.”

  3. Communism is by definition strictly egalitarian—”from each according to his ability, to each according to his need.” Fascism is less so, or not at all so. 


These differences are superficial, though. What’s more important, because more fundamental, is what they have in common. There are 4 fundamental commonalities:


  1. Statism (central control of all aspects of society)

  2. Collectivism (the supremacy of some group, be it the race, the proletariat, society as a whole, et al, in whose name the state operates) 

  3. Mysticism (the quasi-religious belief in a higher group or national consciousness in whose will the state is the embodiment.)

  4. A common enemy — Enlightenment liberalism and its consequences; individualism, constitutionally limited individual rights-protecting government, and Capitalism.


So, in practice, communism and fascism have meaningful differences.


But fundamentally, on the philosophical level—which is the level that counts most—communism and fascism can be thought of as fraternal twins. Never mind that, in today’s scrambled jargon, communism is considered “far Left” and fascism “far Right.” In truth, the only social system that is the antipode of both is Capitalism.


Related answers:


Why do people find communism so terrifying as an idea?


Why do fascism and communism often go hand in hand when they are philosophically polar opposites?


Is it possible to be both a Communist and a Fascist?


Related Reading:


QUORA *: ‘Why do people find communism so terrifying as an idea?’


Individualism vs. Collectivism: Our Future, Our Choice—Craig Biddle


What is Capitalism?—Ayn Rand


Nazism, Communism, Atheism, and the Enlightenment


QUORA: ‘Is fascism a form of capitalism?’


We Need a Deeper Understanding of Socialism


A is A, and Socialism by any Other Name...


Thursday, October 19, 2023

QUORA: ‘Is it possible to be both a Communist and a Fascist?’

 QUORA: ‘Is it possible to be both a Communist and a Fascist?’


I posted this answer:


Superficially, no. Essentially, yes. The difference between Communism and Fascism are as follows. Communism is international, focussing on a united socialist world. Fascism, or national socialism, rejects that approach, instead focussing on socialism tailored to specific national attributes. Communism seeks state ownership of business and private enterprise (the means of production). Fascism seeks effective ownership through widespread centralized control of the economy, leaving a veneer of private ownership. Communism is strictly Egalitarian economically, demanding strict equality. Fascism redistributes plenty of wealth, but allows some measure of differentiation in wealth and income. 


While Communism and Fascism differ in means, and feign to be mortal enemies, they share a common goal, along with every variation of socialism--wholesale, totalitarian socialization of society, and a hatred of their common enemy, individualism, the heart of Capitalism. Communism’s disdain for individualism, or individual autonomy, is undisputed. But just read Hitler’s Mein Kampf or Mussolini’s Doctrine of Fascism, and you will easily notice the same disdain for individualism and Capitalism. All share a collective moral vision, whereby all individuals, and their associations, whether corporations, unions, professional or trade societies, etc., exist for and within the orbit of the state. Don’t forget Molotov-Ribbentrop, the Nazi-Soviet pact that launched World War II.


Socialists love to redefine socialism, each faction claiming that their brand will work where all the others failed—somehow. Which brings us to today’s Democratic Socialists.  I view these socialists as sympathetic to communism, but without wholesale nationalization of industry. Essentially, Democratic Socialism seeks Communism’s goal of “worker” control of industry through “legal”--i.e., state coercive--means. They are, in effect, practical Communists. They want to reach communistic goals through fascist means. It would not be inaccurate to describe Democratic Socialism as Red Fascism.


Is it possible to be both a Communist and a Fascist? Given that communism and fascism are, fundamentally, ideological fraternal twins, the answer is absolutely. As proof, I give you the Democratic Socialists.


Related answers from me:


Can a fascist be a capitalist?


Why do fascism and communism often go hand in hand when they are philosophically polar opposites?


Is fascism a form of capitalism?’


Can a communist society include capitalists?


Related Reading:


Criminal Socialism vs. a Free Society


Socialism's Totalitarian Nature Cannot Be Obscured by 'Democratic Socialism'


Sanders' Brand of Socialism is Old Fashioned Fascism


A is A, and Socialism by any Other Name...


We Need a Deeper Understanding of Socialism


Friday, July 14, 2023

QUORA: ‘Were the Confederate States fascist?’

 QUORA: ‘Were the Confederate States fascist?’


I posted this answer:


Well, they were socialist, but more akin to communism than fascism (if by fascism you mean the system defined by Benito Mussolini and the philosopher Giovanni Gentile in 1932). 


As the Abolitionist movement gained strength in the decades leading up to the Civil War, Southern intellectuals mounted a spirited moral and economic defense of slavery. They defended plantation slavery on grounds that anticipated Karl Marx. Leading Antebellum intellectual George Fitzhugh, for example, published a widely read book titled Sociology For The South: Or The Failure Of A Free Society (1854). In this book, Fitzhugh defended plantation slavery as “the beau ideal of communism,” while condemning the free labor of the North as victims of greedy capitalists. The slaves, he argued, were well taken care of from cradle to grave, and always had employment when they could work. When they couldn’t work, Fitzhugh explained, they were well supported by their masters. “The children and the aged and infirm, work not at all, and yet have all the comforts and necessaries of life provided for them. They enjoy liberty, because they are opposed neither by care nor labor.” 


The free labor of the North, Fitzhugh held, were not really free because they were at the mercy of exploitative capitalists, to whom they had to sell their labor for money, and could be fired at will, leaving they and their families on their own with no support. James Henry Hammond, South Carolina governor, argued that black slaves were better off than Northern free laborers, whom he argued were essentially wage slaves. This is essentially the argument that Marx would advance in support of his brand of Communism. 


As historian C. Bradley Thompson has observed, Southern intellectuals, drawing on German philosophy, were the first in America to reject the Declaration of Independence and free market capitalism. They were essentially Marxists before Marx.* 


Of course, most whites and some blacks were relatively free, so the Confederate states defy broad labels like socialist, Communist, or Fascist. If one were to label the South, Slavocracy would best “fit the bill.” 


* [Thompson is the author of America's Revolutionary Mind: A Moral History of the American Revolution and the Declaration That Defined It]

 

Related Reading:


Brad Thompson on “the unidentified, unacknowledged union of proslavery and progressive thought.”


Sociology for the South: Or the Failure of Free Society by George Fitzhugh


QUORA: ‘Why do fascism and communism often go hand in hand when they are philosophically polar opposites?’


Friday, October 16, 2020

An Economic Egalitarian Acknowledges: Ending Income Inequality’ Begins With Legalized Theft.

A letter published in the New Jersey Star-Ledger on 9/21/20 under the heading Millionaires Tax, Rebate have Kennedy-like Vibe makes explicit the horrid consequences of the war on economic inequality. In support of NJ Governor Phil Murphy’s proposed “millionaires tax”, which increases by 2% the income tax rate on incomes over $1 million, to fund $500 handouts to lower/middle class families defined as “households in the state with income below $150,000 and at least one child,” Robert R. Salman wrote:


In keeping with . . . [what] John F. Kennedy said in his 1961 inaugural address] . . .,  "If a free society cannot help the many who are poor, it cannot save the few who are rich," Gov. Phil Murphy and Democrat legislative leaders have agreed to provide New Jersey with a true millionaires tax.


This new tax will also attack the scourge of income inequality by providing relief to certain middle- and lower- income families. 


Taking one person’s money at gunpoint, even if giving the loot to another, is theft. Income inequality is a natural and just consequence of an economically and politically free society. In a civil society, theft, not personal achievement, is the scourge. Salman inverts this principle of civil society, claiming that personal achievement is the scourge, and theft is virtuous. Salman’s moral perversity is stunning.


But this is economic egalitarianism. Cut through all of the posturing against income inequality, and you find that no argument has ever been advanced to explain why it is wrong or unjust or unfair or harmful for people to achieve at different levels. 


Salman clearly demonstrates that “fixing” the non-problem of income inequality begins with redistributive theft, and in the end no one’s income is safe from it. Today it’s an assault on incomes over $1 million. No amount of rationalization, like “it only affects a tiny minority who can easily afford the extra tax,” can change the fact that there is nothing to prevent the $1 million threshold from being ratcheted down. The principle involved, like all principles, is open-ended. Under the principle that income inequality is a “scourge,” everyone has an automatic claim on anyone with higher income, and can legitimately use the government’s legal, i.e., gun-backed, apparatus to seize the more affluents’ wealth in the name of income equality. The flip side is that no one is safe as long as there are others who make less, and who in turn can claim a portion of his wealth via armed government agents as “hired guns.” 


It starts with the “top 0.1%.” But there is nothing to prevent the 0.1% from morphing into the 1%, then the 10%, then the 25%, and so on and so on. There is no logical limit to the downward pull, a downward pull that ultimately must, by definition, end in universal poverty, as every communist state has demonstrated. And as communist states like Soviet Russia, Red China, Pol Pot’s Cambodia, and Castro’s Cuba amply demonstrate, what begins with theft often ends with murder.


How this redistributive tax will “save the few who are rich,” or any of us who achieve more than the next guy, defies logic. There is no moral or economic justification for any government program to coercively “remedy” income inequality, because there is nothing inherently wrong with income inequality--not when free markets and free trade are the source of the inequality. Greed and/or envy—cutting down the more successful because they are successful—is the real motive of anyone who ever preached against “the scourge of income inequality.” 


Related Reading:


Free Market Champions Must Defend Economic Inequality


Billionaires' Likening of Today's Campaign Against the Rich to Nazi Germany is Frightenly Close to the Mark


The Justice of Income Inequality Under Capitalism by Ari Armstrong  for The Objective Standard


The Left’s Egalitarian Trap (and Why Republicans Must Not Step In)


The Justice of Income Inequality Under Capitalism Ari Armstrong  for The Objective Standard


Laughing Joe’s Egalitarian Aim Ari Armstrong  for The Objective Standard


Equal Is Unfair: America's Misguided Fight Against Income Inequality—by Don Watkins and Yaron Brook


Contra Obama’s Pandering to Cuba’s Dictator, Economic Inequality is America’s Strength and Equality is Cuba’s Tragedy