Thursday, February 12, 2015

The Free Market Doesn’t ‘Do’: It Liberates You to Do

[Below is my reply to a comment posted on Paul Mulshine’s column My generation is kidding itself about Medicare]


In a post that was eventually deleted for inappropriate comment, nyquill012 made two points; one concerning free markets and one concerning where healthcare companies’ profits come from. I left this reply:


“it's [a] delusion that the ‘free market’ can solve anything.”


This is true. A free market doesn’t solve problems. It’s not an entity. A free market leaves individuals free to plan and advance their lives according to their own judgement, including solving their own problems, without aggressors and predators getting in their way. That’s what the “free” in free market means; freedom from aggressive force. This feature of a free market—the absence of aggression and predation, including by government officials—is what makes free market capitalism the only moral social system. If the free market is a “fairy tale,” then so is any chance of peaceful coexistence among people.


The real delusion is that government bureaucrats can solve the problems of millions upon millions of people simply by seizing their money and imposing “solutions” at gunpoint, without creating bigger problems than it “solves”. The extraordinary cost of healthcare is a prime example. Government pays nearly 90% of our healthcare bill—either directly through government programs like Medicare and Medicaid, or indirectly through government-controlled “insurance” companies. As any decent economics textbook will tell you, when you disconnect the consumer from the responsibility to pay his own way, price discipline disappears. Then you have a government dictating prices through monopsony power and healthcare decisions properly left to healthcare consumers and providers.


As to private healthcare companies “profiting on death and suffering”: In fact, they profit on valuable products and services that reduce suffering, cure people, and extend life. The only people who profit on death and suffering are power-hungry politicians, people who seek escape from the responsibility of paying their bills, and spiritual parasites who push socialized medicine under the guise of caring for people.


Related Reading:



Free Market—the Ayn Rand Lexicon

Wednesday, February 11, 2015

In the Healthcare Debate, Remember the Doctors

[Below is my reply to a comment posted on Paul Mulshine’s column My generation is kidding itself about Medicare]




Since Medicare is far more efficient and cost effective than private health insurance, the answer to the problem of controlling health care costs is absurdly simple. Universal health care for all. Expand Medicare to cover everybody and pay for it through payroll taxes. By including 300+ million Americans into the same insurance pool, the cost of providing health care would be dramatically reduced. Such a huge pool of insured backed by the power of the federal government could negotiate the best terms for medicines and fees for service. Since everyone would be paying into the system there would be no free ride for anyone while the basic social contract to provide care to citizens would be upheld. And the government would not be getting between the patient and their doctor. Rather, Medicare would simply be involved in paying for services while the patient chooses which doctors to see. No more of the in-network restrictions, arbitrary wait times for medications or reams of forms to fill out to give private companies the opportunity to take your premium and then deny coverage. All that would be ended. Doctors would even have to compete with each other to be more efficient to win the finite supply of Medicare dollars. The doctors and hospitals would come crawling to the consumer for a change.


Obviously, I couldn’t answer every point spewed out by VoiceofDemocracy. That would have taken a chapter. Instead, I chose to focus on VoiceofDemocracy’s callous final sentence regarding doctors in my reply:


“The doctors and hospitals would come crawling to the consumer for a change.”


Funny: I never thought of doctors and hospitals as someone I “crawled” to when I’m sick. A few years ago, I had major hernia surgery. Thanks to my talented surgeon, it was done laparoscopically, enabling me to return to work in a few days, rather than spend weeks of a painful recovery. I was always grateful that there were people who went through the grueling process of becoming doctors and other healthcare professionals. When my grandson was diagnosed with Crohns disease—a once-upon-a-time life-threatening ailment—I was grateful that treatments and doctors were available to put him into remission, enabling him to live an essentially normal life.


It’s bad enough that you would corral everyone into a one-size-fits-all healthcare straightjacket, placing everyone into a position of being forced to pay for everyone else’s healthcare, but not being responsible for his own. This is utterly character-destroying. Much worse is your utter contempt for the very people your whole scheme depends on—the doctors, whose careers would be placed under state control. Leaving aside your “slavery is freedom” diatribe, your hateful disdain for doctors reminds me of an observation by Doctor Hendricks, a character in Atlas Shrugged:


[I]n all the discussions that preceded the enslavement of medicine, men discussed everything — except the desires of the doctors. Men considered only the ‘welfare’ of the patients, with no thought for those who were to provide it. That a doctor should have any right, desire or choice in the matter, was regarded as irrelevant selfishness; his is not to choose, they said, but ‘to serve.’ That a man’s willing to work under compulsion is too dangerous a brute to entrust with a job in the stockyards — never occurred to those who proposed to help the sick by making life impossible for the healthy. I have often wondered at the smugness at which people assert their right to enslave me, to control my work, to force my will, to violate my conscience, to stifle my mind — yet what is it they expect to depend on, when they lie on an operating table under my hands?


Of course, getting customers is not a problem for most doctors under any socialized, single-payer scheme. Only in a free market do doctors actually have to compete. The problem under single payer is being overwhelmed. Once healthcare becomes “free,” people flock to doctors on any whim. Why not? Cost is no object—to the consumer. But it is to the government, which will have to control costs. And it will, using its monopsony power. As the only legal buyer as a “single payer,” government officials won’t have to “negotiate” with anyone. It can simply dictate. Doctors wouldn’t have to “crawl to the consumer”: They’d have to grovel before the government.


Related Reading:


The Forgotten Man of Socialized Medicine: The Doctor, Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4—Leonard Peikoff


Atlas Shrugged—Ayn Rand

How Not To Fight Against Socialized Medicine—Ayn Rand

Tuesday, February 10, 2015

The Tyranny of Medicare is Built on Altruism

[Below is my reply to a comment posted on Paul Mulshine’s column My generation is kidding itself about Medicare]


TotalStuff posted


Shove it up your opinion! I have a right to the medical care required to keep me alive and the government is going to pay for it.


We are not a dictatorship or a communist country... Compassion outweighs money every-day of the week!


My reply:


“the government is going to pay for it.”


No, taxpayers pay for it.


I’m not sure if TotalStuff’s comment is serious or satirical, but it captures the essence of any socialized program; catering to entitlement and greed. Self-responsible people don’t need or want Medicare or Social Security: They take the initiative to plan for their own senior years. Socialized programs are designed for the sake of the irresponsible, to whom the self-responsible are to be sacrificed.


The “right” to medical care is really the “right” to pick other people’s pockets. When you do it privately, you are a criminal. When the government does it for you, you most certainly do have “a dictatorship or a communist country.” Money—the right to earn it and keep what you earn—is the hallmark of a free society. It’s easy to say “Compassion outweighs money” when the money was created by other people’s sweat and labor. But compassion doesn’t grow out of the barrel of a gun. It grows out of good will.


If you want a demonstration of the ultimate end of altruism, the ethical doctrine that holds self-sacrificial service to the needs of others as the essence of morality, TotalStuff is it—the flip side of the altruist coin—the greedy collector of others’ sacrifices, with government as the distributor.


Related Reading:


Health Care is Not a Right—Leonard Peikoff

The Creed of Sacrifice vs. The Land of Liberty—Craig Biddle

Monday, February 9, 2015

When Government Pays for End-Life Medicine, Government Makes End-Life Decisions

Paul Mulshine had a pretty good article in the New Jersey Star-Ledger titled My generation is kidding itself about Medicare, which was critical of Medicare. Mulshine cited Ezekiel Emanuel’s recent Atlantic article “Why I Hope to Die at 75.” Emanuel, notes Mulshine, intends “to forego any extraordinary measures that would artificially extend his life. He doesn’t want to become a burden on those younger than him.”

The first question that comes to mind is: Then why doesn’t Emanuel oppose Medicare, which in and of itself is precisely “a burden on those younger than him?”

That aside, Mulshine approvingly makes a crucial point:

As for all of those people who objected to Emanuel’s piece on the grounds that there should be no limits on end-of-life spending under Medicare, I don’t know what you’d call them. They’re certainly not conservatives.

They were all over the internet last week repeating some variant on this mantra: “End-of-life decisions should be between the patient and the doctor.”

But, Mulshine observes: “If the government’s picking up 83 percent of your medical bills, it’s silly to say the government should have no say in what services you receive.”

Exactly. When the government pays, the government can and will set the terms. Mulshine cites a “Dying in America” study, which deals with end-of-life considerations and possible solutions. His implicit point is that, if you want control over your end-of-life healthcare decisions, you must oppose Medicare. Personally, I’d much rather Medicare was never created, which means I would have been in charge of planning for, and paying for, my own old age health expenses—and in turn been in charge of my own end-of-life decisions. Of course, at 65 years, it’s too late for me. There is no insurance alternative to the Medicare monopoly, even if I could afford it. And planning for old age can’t start in old age. It must start in your younger years. So, I’m stuck.

Mulshine also points out that most people currently on Medicare will receive more in benefits than their Medicare payroll taxes will cover.

Here it gets interesting.

Sure, Medicare is in much deeper financial trouble than Social Security. The payroll tax of 2.9% (combined employer/employee share) doesn’t come close to covering Medicare outlays. But, the federal government can “print” money to cover the shortfall. As Mulshine points out, citing an internet comment from another article:

“The best medical care gets better (and more expensive) every year,” the guy wrote. “Ten thousand people a day turn 65. Good thing printing presses and paper are no longer needed to mint money, we would run out of ink.”

What “the guy” is referring to is inflation; the artificial expansion of the money supply to finance government spending. That payroll tax may not cover Medicare, but direct taxes aren’t the only way to fund government spending. The government can simply seize our purchasing power, leaving us with dollars of diminishing value. That’s what inflation is—a tax on purchasing power. You simply can’t “print” goods and services. So current beneficiaries may cash in. But younger people are going to get screwed coming and going. But so will retirees. In fact, inflation ordinarily hits retirees harder because they can’t recoup purchasing power losses through inflationary wage gains. Retirees are generally on a fixed income. So, mathematically, there may well be a large gap between taxes paid in and Medicare dollars cashed out. But the gap will not be as large as it otherwise would be, thanks to inflation.

Nonetheless, as Mulshine eloquently concludes: “The politicians will keep pandering to my generation. As for future generations, they better hope they die before they get old.”

[NOTE] This generated a lot of commentary, much of it hostile and even nasty. I engaged several correspondents’ comments, which I’ll post over the next several days.

Related Reading:


Unlike Ezekiel Emanuel, I Hope Not to Die at 75—Ari Armstrong, The Objective Standard

Saturday, February 7, 2015

How about ObamaCare’s Victims?

ObamaCare subsidies are currently being challenged before the Supreme Court.


That was the object of David Tedrow’s column in the Washington Post, Without ObamaCare, I Would Have Died. Tedrow opened with “The Obamacare subsidies saved my life. Now, I’m scared the Supreme Court is going to gut them.”


Tedrow explains how his life was turned upside down from a life-threatening illness that eventually would require a liver transplant. He explains that his existing private insurance policy, though expensive, was covering his treatment.


But then, his insurer ended his policy (Tedrow gives no reason). He then signed up for insurance under ObamaCare, at a small fraction of the cost of his prior policy. “I now pay just $126 a month for insurance,” Tedrow writes, “a federal government subsidy covers the rest.” Tedrow wound up getting his transplant, plus all related medication, and he is on the mend. Tedrow concludes:


Because of my insurance, I’m able to contemplate my future. And I’m really frightened that the Supreme Court might cut the subsidy for me and so many others. For me, the subsidy is the difference between life and death.


I left these comments:


Sorry for your illness, and glad for your recovery. But that doesn’t justify ObamaCare. It highlights its flaws. Your prior policy was canceled most likely because ObamaCare made it illegal, as has happened to millions of other Americans.


Health insurance is inordinately expensive because of government policies like benefit mandates, which ObamaCare doubled down on. Health insurance would be a lot more affordable if consumers and insurers were free to negotiate policies that fit consumers’ needs and budgets rather than government dictates.


The ObamaCare subsidies you so glibly brag about are paid for by forcing privations on other ratepayers, and on taxpayers. My daughter, a divorced single mom raising two daughters, has just seen her premiums rise by hundreds of dollars. The personal costs your subsidies enable you to avoid are paid for with blood money.


Being on the dole at the price of forced privations on others is not an honorable position. In the end, our healthcare is our individual, not collective, moral responsibility. Rather than brag about being on the dole, you should demand an end to the myriad government policies—both post- and pre-ObamaCare—that made our health insurance such a mess,and the subsidies “necessary,” in the first place.


Welfare Statists always trumpet the beneficiaries of their programs, as if the ends justify the means. ObamaCare is no exception. But the ends don’t automatically justify the means. The first step in justifying any end to be achieved is to morally justify the means. If the means are immoral, the ends can not be justified, no matter how desirable. Opponents of the regulatory welfare state must always be willing to point this out, no matter how much some beneficiary tugs at the heartstrings.


Granted, it’s not easy to challenge someone like Tedrow. His encounter with a life-threatening illness should draw the empathy of any compassionate person. And Tedrow is not your typical parasite. He was productive and self-reliant before his illness, which left him unable to work.


Of course, as with other welfare state programs, ObamaCare subsidies would probably have to be phased out, now that they have become entrenched and many people have become dependent on them. But ended they must be—along with all other government interference in the health insurance market—giving people like Tedrow an appropriate amount of “breathing room” time wise while a free market is established and rates have come down to affordable levels.


Of course, voluntary charitable help is perfectly moral—though not morally obligatory—should people choose to offer it. But, if we who advocate liberty can’t expose the immoral truth about welfare statism even in the face of sympathetic cases like Tedrow’s, then we have no business calling ourselves advocates of liberty.


Related Reading:



The Only Obamacare Fix Is For Obama To Legalize Real Health Insurance—Paul Hsieh

Thursday, February 5, 2015

The Convoluted Logic of the “Climate Lobby”

A letter titled Fine energy companies for spewing carbon pollution appeared in the 10/18/14 NJ Star-Ledger. David Korfhage, identified as the “group leader of the Montclair Citizens Climate Lobby,” writes, in part:


As it stands, fossil fuel companies can sell their dirty energy and dump all the pollution that comes with them into the atmosphere without charge. They get the profit, we pay the cost. It's time for a change.


Just as I have to pay a fine if I dump my garbage on the street, fossil fuel providers should be required to pay a fee for all the carbon pollution their fuels produce.


I left these comments:


“They get the profit, we pay the cost.”


Wrong. We benefit from the products our money pays for. They profit from the benefits we receive from their products. When I pay $50 for a tank of gasoline, I get the gas that powers my car. If I’m not better off with the gas than with the $50, I’d leave the $50 in my wallet and forgo the gas. The same goes for the #2 fuel oil in my oil tank, which heats my house and provides hot water, and the electricity I buy from fossil-fueled generating plants, which provides my illumination, powers my clean water well, and runs my computer so I can leave this comment. Every dollar I send to fossil fuel companies provides me with a benefit greater than the value of the money I send them. Otherwise, I’d hold onto the money, rather than buy gasoline, heating oil, and electricity.


Fossil fuel companies profit by making our lives better. They get the profit, and we get the benefit. Win-win.


“A revenue-neutral fee-and-dividend is the policy we need to end global warming.”


Leaving aside the utter absurdity of that conclusion—which doesn't even deserve a rebuttal—notice the Orwellian language distortion; a common tactic of statists who want to put something over on people.


A dividend is a payout from a company’s earnings, or profits; i.e. wealth production. The yield on ExxonMobil’s stock is a dividend—a reward for investing one’s capital in ExxonMobil. A monthly check funded by a tax on fossil fuels is not a dividend. It is a handout funded by seizing other people’s earnings at gunpoint, otherwise known as a tax. A dividend is the result of a voluntary transaction. A tax-funded handout is based on force. They are opposites.


So all of the hysterical hyperbole about impending global climate catastrophe comes down to---handouts!


There are two additional points I want to make about Korfhage’s comments.


First, the “carbon pollution” so often cited is CO2, the stuff of life. CO2 is not harmful to humans. It is vital, because is feeds the plant growth that produces the oxygen that keeps us alive. CO2 is not a pollutant, unless you’re willing to define human life itself as a pollutant—which, in fact, is precisely how the intellectual leaders of the environmentalist movement view us.


Second, consider Korfhage’s statement, “Just as I have to pay a fine if I dump my garbage on the street, fossil fuel providers should be required to pay a fee for all the carbon pollution their fuels produce.” Notice the bait and switch. If you dump your plastic grocery bags into the street, you are polluting and you get fined, because you, the consumer, did the dumping. Korfhage doesn’t advocate pinning the blame for his polluting on the plastic bag makers. He expects to pay the fine.


Well, why doesn’t the same principle apply to fossil fuel producers? After all, it is consumers, not producers, who dump “carbon pollution” into the air. This is where Korflage’s word trickery comes in. All of a sudden, he—the consumer—is not to blame. But why not? Just as Korfhage doesn’t have to dump his plastic grocery bags into the street, so he doesn’t have to dump “carbon pollution” into the air. Now, one can say, “But Korfhage can still use plastic grocery bags and dispose of them properly, instead of just dumping them (and his other garbage) into the street. He has no choice when it comes to fossil fuels: to use them is to release “carbon pollution” into the air. But this is a distinction without a real difference. The point is, it is the user of fossil fuels who does the dumping. Fossil fuel companies wouldn’t exist if not for consumers who voluntarily buy their products. No consumer, no producer.


Of course, a carbon tax would fall not only on the companies in the form of reduced sales, but mainly on the consumer, who would face higher prices. Doesn’t exactly jibe with Korfhage’s “dividend” (free lunch for consumers) scenario. But then climate change dogmatists rarely think things through.


Related Reading:



Trader Principle—Ayn Rand Lexicon

Tuesday, February 3, 2015

Pope Francis’s Embrace of Anti-Fossil Fuel Agenda Follows From Church’s Anti-Capitalism

Pope Francis has come out strongly against fossil fuels. As The New Republic reported:


In 2015, Pope Francis plans to make climate change a personal issue for the world’s 1.2 billion Catholics. The Guardian’s John Vidal reports that Francis will publish an encyclical (a letter to the world's bishops), speak directly to United Nations leaders in the fall, and organize a summit of world religions—all aimed at pressuring countries to commit to a strong climate agreement at a Paris meeting next December.


The “climate agreement” the pope wants countries to commit to is a worldwide reduction in carbon emissions (fossil fuel use) by 80%. Given that fossil fuels comprise 86% of the world’s energy, what motivates a Catholic pope to threaten the primary energy source that the world’s people choose to power their industrial needs? An admiring New Jersey Star-Ledger may have inadvertently hit the nail on the head. In Can Pope Francis break the deadlock on climate change, the Star-Ledger wrote:


[I]t makes perfect sense that Pope Francis has entered the fray. The world’s poor represent the vast majority of his flock, so he has every reason to make this a personal cause in 2015, taking on an unprecedented role for the Vatican.


I left these comments:


It sure does make “perfect sense.”


To the extent capitalism is allowed to operate, billions have been liberated to work themselves up from poverty. Capitalism leads to industrialization, which raises peoples’ standards of living, which includes an ever-increasing ability to counter and adapt to climate dangers. Industrialization requires plentiful, cheap, reliable energy, which for now and the foreseeable future overwhelmingly means fossil fuels. That’s why fossils are the fuel of choice for economically rising third world nations, which have surpassed the West in carbon emissions. Fossil fuels now make up 87% of the world’s energy mix.


It’s no accident that poor countries “have a harder time coping with severe storms and changing weather patterns.” They have less (or no) capitalism, industrialization, and fossil fuel use. If the Catholic Church really cared about lifting the poor, it would demand freer markets, individual rights—including property rights—the rule of law, and much more of what is by far the best and only energy technology available today capable of sustaining the industrial, technological advancement still-poor nations of the world desperately need—fossil fuels.


Yet, the Church doesn’t and won’t. For decades, Catholic Popes—from Paul VI  to Benedict XVI to Francis VI—have railed against capitalism and free markets, the social engines of upward economic mobility. [I’m not speaking here of rank and file Catholics. I’m speaking of the Catholic Church as an institution.]


Why? In my view, precisely because “The world’s poor represent the vast majority of his flock.” Poverty and misery are the foundation of modern Catholicism. “Ministering to the poor” is central to the Catholic Church’s purpose for being—and its power. Where would the Church be if poverty continues to give way to capitalistic, fossil-fueled prosperity worldwide? The Church has a vested interest in poverty. It will fight tooth and nail to “protect” the poor—from prosperity.


So yes, Pope Francis’s jumping “into the fray” on the side of political statists’ conspiring to strangle fossil fuel energy production under the guise of some alleged, impending “climate catastrophe” that exists only in computer models makes perfect sense, from the Catholic Church’s perspective. Francis’s  position is a logical extension of the Church’s historic anti-capitalist, anti-prosperity mission.


Related Reading:





The Illegitimacy of Pope Francis's “Legitimate Redistribution” of Wealth—Natalie Ogle for The Objective Standard