Tuesday, February 18, 2020

Who Determines ‘Educational Needs’?—and the Need to Answer Opposing Views

In a comment to my post "Letter: ‘Vouchers Will Hurt Public Schools.’ So?", correspondent Burr Deming offered:

As always, you present a coherent argument for the libertarian view, in this case against the exclusive funding of public education over private alternatives.

We published a link to your article. As might be expected from a left of center site, there was articulate disagreement.

The thrust of that opposing argument is that public education came to be precisely because of educational needs not addressed by private education.

I like your habit of publishing views with which you disagree, alongside your reasons for disagreeing. We try to follow your good example.

I answered Burr as follows:

Thanks for the encouraging comments. 

As to those arguing that "public education came to be precisely because of educational needs not addressed by private education," my answer is: Go ahead, address it. In a free market, or even a semi-free market of universal school choice, who could stop you? One of the best features of a fully free and private education market is precisely to allow education entrepreneurs to identify unmet needs and offer new and innovative solutions. Everyone should be free to implement their ideas — by voluntary consent and agreement. The minute someone decides to use government force to impose and pay for her “solution” to what she has decided are “unmet” educational needs, she is denying to others with different ideas the same freedom: She is defeating the very purpose by which she defends public education. 

Mike Kevitt also offered food for thought:
The "educational needs" not addressed by private education are the collectivist indoctrination of students. Those are the "needs" of advocates of government schools. It's government schools which don't address educational needs, such as civics.
I replied to Mike: Good point. What about the educational needs not addressed by public education?

I would also argue that complete abolition of public schools is not necessary even if you buy the argument about “educational needs not addressed by private education.” My Objective Standard article Toward a Free Market in Education: School Vouchers or Tax Credits presented a tax credit proposal would leave traditional public schools operational. So would a form of Education Savings Accounts that would simply allow the allotted per-pupil cost of each district to follow the student to the parents’ schooling of choice, choices that would include the traditional public school. 

Granting government monopoly decision-making power, thus excluding the vast private sector from the decision-making process, we would be much less likely to meet students’ educational needs. The bottom line is, it is simply immoral and unfair to assign government planners the exclusive power to determine the educational needs of students, shutting out the parents and all others from the process.

Back to Burr, I was particularly pleased with his observation “I like your habit of publishing views with which you disagree, alongside your reasons for disagreeing.” Most of my posts do just that. I believe people’s opposing views should be properly presented, which is why I rely on direct quotes as much as possible, along with links. I don’t think “straw man” arguments are fair to the person one is critiquing. But also, the person offering the critique loses all credibility. On a personal note, advocating my own views in the context of focussing on opposing views helps me sharpen my own arguments by causing my to consider objections I may not have otherwise considered.

Thanks, Burr.

Related Reading:






Saturday, February 15, 2020

QUORA: Why can't libertarians name a single successful libertarian experiment in running a country?--2



Here is my original answer to this question. A related Question was posed in the answer column by Ted Lesher: 

Many responses to this question cite countries with “economic freedom” as being successful. Could someone explain what is mean (sic) by “economic freedom,” particularly in those countries? Could someone explain the relationship between such “economic freedom” and libertarian ideals?

I left this answer:

The best way to understand economic freedom is to consider the nature of religious freedom. Religious freedom is made possible by the doctrine of separation of church and state. This means that people are free to choose and practice their conscientious beliefs (religious or nonreligious) so long as they don’t violate the same rights of others.

Likewise, economic freedom is the doctrine of separation of church and state applied to economics—the separation of economics and state in the same way and for the same reasons as the separation of church and state. People are free to work, contract, and trade so long as they do not violate the same rights of others.

Under separation of church (or mosque or synagogue, etc.) and state, the government is neutral, neither imposing nor forbidding nor dictating any religious doctrines, interests, or activities, such as imposing a tax to support a favored religion or mandating Sunday worship or school prayer sessions. Under church/state separation, the government steps in only when someone initiates force or fraud against others, say by sexually mutilating women and girls or by denying a minor child essential medical attention on the pretext that “God will provide.” 

Likewise, under separation of economics and state, the government is neutral, neither imposing nor forbidding nor dictating any economic activity, such as regulating prices and wages, labor organizing, contracting, or imposing taxes and granting subsidies to favor one economic interest over or at the expense of others, etcetera. Under economics/state separation, the government steps in only when someone initiates force or fraud against others, such as cheating a consumer by misrepresenting one’s work product, breach of contract, or whose work interferes with the use or enjoyment of the property of another. 

Absent rights violations of others, each individual is free to follow his conscience (religious freedom) or work and trade with others on mutually agreed terms (economic freedom), without government interference. ( I am indebted to philosopher Ayn Rand for identifying this parallel.)

Like religious freedom, economic freedom relates to the “libertarian ideal” insofar as that ideal means each individual has the inalienable right to freely live and act by the judgement of his own reasoning mind in pursuit of his own goals, values, and happiness. Since economics is the field of work, trade, and voluntary cooperation in which humans must engage to materially support their own individual lives, economic freedom is integral to the “libertarian ideal” of individual freedom.

I should add that full economic freedom has never been achieved. All economies, even the freest, have been burdened by some level of government interference, distortion, cronyism, and hampering. Also, there’s more to economic freedom than just economics. A substantial level of political and intellectual freedom are required for economic freedom to fully flourish over the long term. But generally, the prosperity enjoyed by a country’s citizens directly correlates to the degree of economic freedom they enjoy.

Related Reading:


 The Capitalist Manifesto—Andrew Bernstein

Wednesday, February 12, 2020

Is ‘Common Good Capitalism’ a One-way Street?

In “Common Good Capitalism” Is No Substitute for Free Enterprise, Brooke Medina and Doug McCullough take Senator Marco Rubio to task for his Common-Good Capitalism, Rubio’s call for paternal statism to—quoting Pope Leo XIII—be sure that “the working classes be carefully watched over by the administration.” 

Rubio has been peddling his statist cause at National Review and The New York Post, where he argued, incredibly, that “It’s not ‘Socialism’.” 

In one passage that I’ve selected, Rubio writes:

What makes this society possible is the rights of both workers and businesses, but also their obligations to each other. Put another way, businesses have a right to make a profit, but they also have an obligation to reinvest those profits productively for the benefit of the workers and the greater society. Similarly, workers have a right to share in the benefits of the profits they helped create. 

I wonder if he believes the “obligation” should be a two-way street? Gallup says that Millennials are “Unattached to organizations and institutions,” and so are job-hopping like mad. The Financial Times says it’s nothing new. If businesses are obligated to subordinate their interests for workers, shouldn’t workers subordinate their interests and forgo job-hopping—and the better job-opportunities they desire—for the sake of the businesses that “reinvest for the benefit of the workers?” Does it work both ways? Or are business owners the only slaves of a government-determined “the common good?” If the last, what’s left of the rights of businesses to their profits?

In fact, capitalism does work both ways, with business and workers each pursuing their own best interests, and each going their separate ways unmolested when their interests don’t harmonize. Rubio is trying to defend capitalism on collectivist grounds. But he is merely kowtowing to the socialists.

Tellingly, Rubio’s National Review article is “adapted from a speech [he] delivered November 5 at the Catholic University of America.” I say “tellingly” because the last place you would look for a defense of capitalism (a free society) is to the Catholic Church. I propose that Rubio switch to the Democratic Party, where he would make a good running mate for Elizabeth Warren. “Common-Good Capitalism” is just another distressing example of the alleged defenders of free markets turning against capitalism.

With “friends” like Marco Rubio and his Catholic Church, capitalism doesn’t need enemies like Bernie Sanders or Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

Related Reading:





Sunday, February 9, 2020

Another Reactionary’s Flawed Framing of American Ideals


In Did we ever believe in the American Revolution’s ideals?, Michael Leroy Oberg, Professor of History at the State University of New York, College at Geneseo, argues,

I no longer look to the Revolution for the ideals I want to see realized. The Founders left me little to celebrate, other than a flawed framework for government that has, despite its defects, endured for more than two centuries. For millions of people around the globe — Native Americans, Africans and African-Americans, those on the receiving end of American empire — the American Revolution unleashed a force that has done far more evil than good. Perhaps someday we will live in a society where all people are truly equal. Perhaps, and on the other hand, alongside our proclamations of liberty and justice for all, our racism and our violence, and our exploitation, erasure, and injustice, we are closer to the Founders, warts and all, than we care to admit.

But can the “racism and our violence, and our exploitation, erasure, and injustice” really be laid at the feet of “liberty and justice for all?” Here is an expanded version of some comments I posted to the article:

The trick to repudiating American ideals is to point to all of the ways that they were not lived up to, and then repudiate the ideals rather than the scoundrels who betrayed them. Why not point to the way we did? Like women's suffrage, ending Jim Crow and legalized segregation, marriage equality, free speech and, above all, the abolition of slavery—the Declaration’s finest hour? Like that the Founders gave us the intellectual ammunition against slavery even though many entered the Revolutionary period themselves owning slaves, thus opting for the “greater good” over their own personal curcumstances? That’s heroic. *

Posting ideals is a start. The hard work is convincing people, one mind at a time, of their rightness. That’s a long hard slog. Despite many owning slaves, the Founders signed on to the most anti-slave ideals ever formulated. 

The rejection of American Ideals has a much more sinister purpose than merely smearing Americanism. A counter-revolution against America goes back to the Founding. It involves first radically reinterpreting America from liberty to democratic—putting democracy before liberty, freedom, equality, effectively nullifying the last three. Second, reframing equality, replacing the freedom and justice of political equality with the tyranny of economic equality.

Why? The Founding ideals are the bane of tyranny of all stripes. Theocracy, absolute monarchy, and all forms of socialisms right up to today’s democratic variety cannot get a foothold against the ideals of inalienable individual rights to life, liberty, earned property, and the pursuit of happiness. Those ideals must be repudiated for tyranny to take hold. 

American ideals are Enlightenment ideals. The fight for those ideals started before the American Revolution and continued afterward, from the fight against slavery to the fight against the “new” Democratic Socialists. All Oberg’s analysis shows is that the fight is not over. America’s ideals are the antidote to tribalism, racism, conquest and plunder, slavery, and other injustices. If there are people who still don’t share fully in the promise of liberty, freedom, equality, and republican democracy, the Declaration’s ideals are the solution, not the problem. The people who most need what the Founding Fathers created are precisely the groups that got screwed the most, including African-Americans and Native Americans, because groups are made of individuals and you can’t protect groups without securing individual rights. I embrace the ideals of American Revolution. I’m a radical champion of them. I will fight to my last breath against the reactionaries. Don’t let the counter-revolutionaries take away inalienable individual rights and limited rights-protecting government, whoever they may be—socialists, theocrats, democrats. The alternative is tyranny.

As Harvey Milk, one of the early leaders in the “Gay Pride” fight for equal rights for gays, said at a 1978 speech,

In the Declaration of Independence it is written 'All men are created equal and they are endowed with certain inalienable rights . . . .' That’s what America is. No matter how hard you try, you cannot erase those words from the Declaration of Independence.

And neither can Professor Oberg.

There is a lot to challenge here. But I want to specifically address these comments by Oberg:

I live now on land taken through fraudulent transactions by the state of New York from the Haudenosaunee, the People of the Iroquois Longhouse. . . . And [President Trump] wastes no opportunity to rub the noses of native peoples in the fact that what was once theirs belongs to them no longer. 

I submit that describing North America as “once theirs” is a blatantly racist premise--and hypocritical. A race can’t own a continent, to the exclusion of other peoples. The hypocrisy comes in when in the same paragraph Oberg damns Trump for his anti-immigrant stance. You can’t have it both ways. Either America is a nation where people of all backgrounds can come and live in peaceful coexistence, their inalienable rights protected, or it isn’t. If it is, then white people of European descent should be just as welcome without being labeled “white supremacists.”


* [I put greater good in scare quotes because there is no greater good than an individual human life. By putting their ideals above their actions even though they are contradictory, the Founders acted incredibly selfishly and in accordance with their sacred honor.]

Related Reading:






What to the Slave is the Fourth of July?--Frederick Douglass, July 5, 1852



Thursday, February 6, 2020

Another One-Way Labor Law

N.J. becomes first state to mandate severance for workers if they are part of a mass layoff. So read an article headline in the New Jersey Star-Ledger by Samantha Marcus. She wrote:

The law (S3170) requires that New Jersey employers with at least 100 employees provide their workers 90 days notice — up from 60 — before a large layoff or a plant closing or transfer that will put at least 50 people out of work. It would also force these businesses to pay their workers one week’s severance for every year of service. The payout increases by an additional four weeks if the employer doesn’t comply with the 90-day notification rules.

“When these corporate takeover artists plunge the companies into bankruptcy they walk away with windfall profits and pay top executives huge bonuses, but the little guys get screwed,” state Sen. Joe Cryan, D-Union, who sponsored the bill, said in a statement. “The law will now be upgraded to better protect the rights of the employees. Workers’ performance and workers’ dedication to the company were secondary. Now, hopefully, they’ll be moved more to the forefront.”

I posted these comments:

Gallup reports that Millennials are “the Job-Hopping Generation” who feel “unattached to organizations and institutions” that employ them. The Financial Times reports it’s nothing new—“Job-hopping millennials’ are no worse than their elders.”


With that much quitting, why shouldn’t labor law be a two-way street? If businesses are legally required to give 90 days notice before letting employees go, followed by hefty severance pay, shouldn’t simple fairness put the same requirements on the “little guys?” What about the rights of business owners? What about business performance? What happens when business dedication to its workers becomes secondary to the worker who quits for better job opportunities?

Many more workers quit than are fired. Gallup shows that 45-60% of workers “are open to a different job opportunity” and 21-36% “will look for a job with a different organization in the next 12 months.” In other words, many more businesses “get screwed” by “little guys” than “little guys get screwed” by businesses. So why does the new law only apply to business? Shouldn’t the basic American principle of Equal Protection of the Law impose the same obligation on the worker?

For the record, I oppose these types of labor laws, unless they involve fraud, breach-of-contract, and like criminal activity. Never mind that the law applies only to “mass layoffs.” To any individual worker, a layoff is a layoff. If we’re going to have these laws, it should be applied fairly.

Related Reading:



Monday, February 3, 2020

Forbes Turns to an Anti-Capitalist


I often have more of a problem with fellow pro-capitalists than anti-capitalists because the pro-caps tend to accept the anti-caps’ basic premises, thus letting the anti-caps frame the issue and capture what they can’t on their own, the moral high ground.

But sometimes I get outraged, as I did when I read the Forbes Inside Scoop column titled Capitalism, Built To Last, written by Randall Lane, the chief content officer and editor of Forbes, and published under the tag “Billionaires”.

Randall Lane writes,

Forbes publishes the Just 100 in partnership with Just Capital, a non-profit company started by hedge fund billionaire and Robin Hood Foundation founder Paul Tudor Jones, one of the keenest capitalists. For him, the Just 100 was born of patriotic duty. "There is no bigger threat to our democracy than wealth disparity. It is a story normally reserved for monarchies, dictatorships and plutocracies," Jones tells me. "And yet we got in this pickle because over the past 40 years the corporate focus on profits took on manic proportions relative to other stakeholders such as employees, communities and the planet.” [my emphasis]

The Just 100 statement reads  

Shareholder returns mean nothing if a company's workers, customers, communities and environments aren't considered, too. That's the reasoning underlying the third annual Just 100, our ranking of America's best corporate citizens with our research partner Just Capital.

As it is every year, the Just 100 is a reflection of the issues that matter most to Americans and a ranking of how the nation’s largest publicly traded companies perform in these areas.

The relationship between shareholder returns and workers, customers, communities and environments is important but not relevant here. I covered this issue in depth here and here. My concern here is the Lane quote above.

Jone’s (and Lane’s) implication is that there is no difference between capitalist fortunes built on enriching willing consumers through voluntary trade, and the fortunes acquired by thieving monarchs, dictators, and plutocrats throughout pre-capitalist history! Is there anything the anti-capitalist Left can propagandize that approaches the destructiveness of lumping fortunes by productive work and fortunes by looting into the same package?

NO! This equivocation of capitalist fortunes with the looters’ fortunes of old into a package deal is a central feature of the free enterprise-hating egalitarian socialist Left. With “defenders” of capitalism like Paul Tudor Jones, who needs the socialist Left? And who needs Forbes? Shame on Forbes for bringing the anti-capitalist fox Jones into the capitalist henhouse. This, published in an allegedly pro-capitalist magazine! It is straight out of Elizabeth Warren’s playbook. I’m glad I canceled my Forbes subscription.

My answer to Jones’s disgusting equivocation is, thank you capitalism, including those who thrived over the last 40 years! Let’s consider just one. Ben Silbermann became a billionaire “on paper” when in April 2019 he brought public the company he’d spent the last decade building. That company is Pinterest, which, at the time it made Silbermann a billionaire, boasted 250 million active subscribers, a group that includes my wife. It has now surpassed 300 million! How does that put Silbermann (and his co-founders Paul Sciarra and Evan Sharp) in the same category as monarchs, dictators, plutocrats, and other like thieves? How many of those grew their fortunes by creating a product that 300 million people find beneficial enough to voluntarily subscribe to?

My answer to Lane’s lauding of Paul Tuder Jones and his misnamed Robin Hood Foundation is, thank you to Michael Dell and Bill Gates for the computer upon which I am typing this post and to Sergey Brin and Larry Page for the Google Docs and Blogger I’m using—and, on behalf of my wife, to the newest billionaires like the Ben Silbermanns. You guys are part of a class that is only possible under the glorious, “pursuit of happiness” freedom of capitalism--a class that represents the greatest humanitarians that ever existed.

Related Reading:












Sunday, February 2, 2020

HAPPY GROUNDHOG DAY

It's 02/02/2020!

On this special Groundhog Day 2020—and on behalf of all of us snow-lovers—may Punxsutawney Phil see his shadow!

Related Reading:
Sunday's date is a rare palindrome that hasn't happened in over 900 years
Sunday is shaping up to be a unique day for reasons other than the Super Bowl and Groundhog Day: It's also a rare palindrome. 
While various forms of palindrome dates are fairly common, 02/02/2020 has the unique distinction of reading the same backward and forward when written out in eight digits in multiple date systems, according to University of Portland professor Aziz Inan.