Saturday, February 11, 2017

Is the Electoral College Un-Democratic? You Bet. Unfair? Nope.

The Electoral College was the subject of a "pro" and "con" debate between two New Jersey Star-Ledger guest columnists. I will focus on the argument against by Kean University assistant professor Frank Argote-Freyre, which he titled “Outdated Institution.” Argote-Freyre writes:


[The Electoral College] is fundamentally unfair and undemocratic.
It makes a mockery of the one person, one vote principle. Under it, every vote is not equal.


I left these comments, edited for clarity:


Undemocratic? If by democratic one means pure, or what I call fundamentalist, democracy, it certainly is. And that’s a good thing. Fundamentalist democracy is as un-American as communism, Nazism, and slavery—that is, it is a manifestation of totalitarianism. Fundamentalist democracy is absolute majority rule, whereby the majority can vote to execute dissenters, as in Ancient Greece, or persecute minorities, as some Muslim democracies do to non-Muslims, or enslave a minority, as in the pre-Civil War American South, or control the life of or seize the property of one’s neighbors, as in the modern regulatory welfare state.


If by democracy one means the process by which free people control their governance in a constitutional republic—a process consistent with a free nation based on fundamental individual rights—the Electoral College is in no way unfair. Every voter in every state counts toward choosing her respective state’s electors. Within the context of a constitutional republic's democratic process, there is nothing inherently unfair about the Electoral College.


There is nothing sacred about a national popular vote—not in a constitutional republic based on rule of law and limited, individual rights-protecting government; not in a United States of America. This does not mean the popular vote shouldn’t matter. But there are better ways to measure the popular vote—like, on the state level. That’s what the Electoral College system measures. Every elector is backed by popular vote at the state level.


The national popular vote is irrelevant—and logically so—given the wide diversity of interests and concerns among the people in the states. In fact, if you take out California, by far the biggest state, Trump won the national popular vote by 1.5 million (at last count). California went for Clinton by a 4.3 million vote margin. That’s a lopsided 62-32%, way out of touch with the national electoral mainstream but enough to swing the national popular vote totals to Clinton. If you take out New York, another big state with a similarly lopsided Clinton margin, Trump won the other 48 states by 3.2 million. There were no large states that went for Trump by anything close to the CA-NY margins. Even reliably Republican Texas, the second biggest state, only gave Trump a 9% point margin. I mention this only so one can easily see why the national totals are irrelevant.


In other words, Trump did win the popular vote—30 times; that is, in 30 states totalling 306 electoral votes. Clinton won 21 times (including the District of Columbia). The fact is, every voter has the same equal, albeit effectively meaningless, choice; each votes his choice as to which candidate to assign his respective state’s electoral votes. In fact, depending on state-level rather than national-level popular votes to choose a president, each individual voter has more influence because she is one part of a smaller voter pie.


Though important, the vote is secondary. The primary concern of the Founder Fathers was to protect the rights of the individual to live and work according to his own judgement and conscience without infringement by King, cleric, elected legislature, et al. The right to vote was not primary. It couldn't be, as the Founders rightly considered individual rights to precede government. Since “to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men,” the issue of voting only arises with the creation of a government.


Notice the hierarchy established in the U.S. Constitution's philosophic blueprint, the Declaration of Independence. First, it is established that man has certain unalienable individual rights—life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Then, “to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men.” Only after establishing the imperative to recognize rights and the need for rights-protecting government does the issue of voting arise—the “consent of the governed” clause pertaining to the government’s “just powers.” The right to vote is a logical extension of our fundamental rights as human beings. It is not one of them.


In other words, the Founders didn’t intend to create an absolute democracy, in which the vote is the be-all and end-all of liberty (The term “democracy” doesn’t even appear in the Declaration or the Constitution). This is important when considering the process by which our votes choose our political leaders. One of the areas in which the Founders most showed their brilliance is in the area of structuring government so as to distribute political power—the power of the gun—in a way that minimizes the chance of an unhealthy concentration of power and thus the emergence of tyranny. What kind of tyranny? Not just monarchy, but all kinds of tyranny, including the tyranny of the majority. It’s called the separation (or balance) of powers, also referred to as checks and balances.


Enter the Electoral College. The Electoral College must be understood within the context of the separation of powers, a device for protecting individual rights. By giving the states, through their elected legislatures, the constitutional responsibility to pick the president through the Electors they appoint, the states can act as a check on the power of the federal executive branch, as well as a check on each other.


The state legislatures can step in and override the popular vote for a variety of reasons. For example, in the case of an inconclusive vote—e.g. voting machine breakdowns, massive fraud, terrorist attack, etc.—the state legislature can assert its authority to choose the electors and facilitate the smooth completion of the electoral process. In addition, the electors, though morally duty bound to cast their votes for whom they are pledged, can constitutionally change their votes to nullify a popular vote in the unlikely event that an irrational, emotionally charged electorate chooses a demagogue with dictatorial ambitions, or other extreme circumstance. It is entirely within the realm of possibility that the Electoral College process may someday prevent the rise to power of an elected American Hitler or Chavez.*


But the Electoral College does not sidestep “the will of the people,” to use that ridiculous catchphrase (what “will” of which “people?” “The will of the people” is in fact a myth. It rests on the collectivist premise that “the people” is an entity with a will of its own apart from the individuals that comprise it. That’s mysticism, not reality. A better term is, “the will of the victorious electoral faction”). The popular vote does count. The state legislators—to whom Article II assigns the responsibility to choose, “in such Manner as the Legislature there of may direct,” the electors—are themselves elected by popular vote.


The important point is that the Electoral College is part of the checks and balances that prevents tyranny and thus protects our freedom, while also acting as a reliable and efficient means to choose our leaders. The primacy of liberty, not democracy, is the goal of the American republic and the starting point of American politics. America is about liberating each citizen to govern his own life, not give him the power to govern others. The right to vote is not primary. It logically follows from the individual’s inalienable rights to life, liberty, property, and the peaceful, non-predatory pursuit of happiness: That is, the right to have a say in the operation of the government created to protect his fundamental rights—a government constitutionally limited to protecting individual rights.


Judged from the perspective of the primacy of democracy, the Electoral College is, if not undemocratic, certainly less democratic than a direct national popular vote. But judged from the American perspective, the primacy of liberty, there is nothing undemocratic about it. The reactionaries against Americanism have largely succeeded in convincing us that liberty is about having a tiny part of a collective voice in governing other peoples lives. But liberty is not about the vote. It is about barring the majority from interfering in the individual’s right to govern his own life. Don’t let the democracy fundamentalists get their way. They are not champions of individual liberty. Keep the Electoral College. It is, in my view, a valuable and unifying—and quintessentially American—institution. It is a valuable tool for restricting majority rule and protecting our basic freedoms.


* In the leadup to the Electoral College vote on December 19th, 2016, there was a popular campaign to convince the electors not to cast their votes for Donald Trump on the grounds that Trump is unfit to be president, such as that his “impulsive nature would lead the country into another war.” The attempt failed, as expected. In the end, seven electors voted for people other than those they were pledged to, with Trump losing two votes and Clinton losing five, leaving a final tally 304-227 for Trump. The defections went to John Kasich [1], Ron Paul [1], Bernie Sanders [1], Colin Powell [3], and Faith Spotted Eagle [1]. I don’t believe Trump is incompetent or unfit, at least not enough to warrant an electoral college upset of the voters. And he certainly doesn’t rise to the level of a Hitler or Chavez. But it is the job of the Electoral College to consider such issues before voting. While it may seem like a rubber stamp, it is not. It is a real structural bulwark against tyranny.


Related Reading:







Avoid ‘Majority Rule’—Keep the Electoral College in Fact and in Spirit

Thursday, February 9, 2017

Rights-Violating Gender Pay Equity Laws are Insulting to Women

New Jersey Governor Chris Christie vetoed a so-called Gender Pay Equity bill, though for technical reasons, not principled opposition. But Gender Pay Equity laws should be defeated, on principle. This does not mean that women, on principle, should not be treated fairly. On principle, they should. But Gender pay equity laws are not about fairness.


The gender pay equity proponents claim that a man and a woman doing the same job should be equally compensated. “Equal pay for equal work,” they simple-mindedly call it. In theory, all things being equal, who would disagree with that? But gender pay equity proponents want to impose this principle by force across the board through laws like the Federal so-called Lilly Ledbetter Act of 2009, which “makes it unlawful for employers to pay people different rates for the same kind of work based on their gender,” according to John C. Ensslin for NorthJersey.com.


These laws are morally wrong, and fallacious in practical terms: In reality, all things are far from equal.


As anyone who has ever done an honest day’s work knows, equal work is a myth. Each person has their own strengths and weaknesses, produce at different rates, vary in ability to engage in teamwork, have their own unique goals, etc. Two people with the same job title doing the same job can and do produce at vastly different rates and can be vastly different in terms of things like reliability.  One person could be fast, but makes more mistakes than another who works slower but whose quality of work rarely results in mistakes. Also, different workers of equal productivity could have different values. A man who is a “breadwinner” may put a premium on maximizing his monetary compensation, while a single mom co-worker may forego a higher pay scale in favor of more work time flexibility, such as more time working from home, in order to better take care of her young children—which a woman close to me actually did.


The Left’s gender pay equity movement treats all women—and by extension men—as homogeneous grains of sand on a beach. In effect, like mindless robots. To paraphrase Peter Schwartz from his Capitalism Magazine article on racism:


The essence of gender pay equity is the idea that the individual is meaningless and that membership in the collective–the gender–is the source of her identity and value. To the genderist, the individual’s moral and intellectual character is the product, not of her own choices, but of the genes she shares with all others of her gender. To the genderist, the particular members of a given gender are interchangeable.


Every woman who believes that pay should be earned, rather than “achieved” at the point of a governmental gun pointed at the head of her employer—and who has any self-esteem worth noting—should be insulted and outraged to be treated in such meaningless fashion. She should be outraged to be stripped of her freedom to forge her own agreement with her employer, or in the case of businesswomen, the freedom to decide for herself what her employees are worth to her. And everyone who values liberty and justice should be outraged at such laws.


Even if the “pay gap" between women and men, such that it exists—and the gap has been “wildly exaggerated *,” according to the NJ Star-Ledger, not exactly part of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy—is due to women being less aggressive than men or even if some employers engage in gender discrimination, the government has no legitimate role in ramming one-size-fit-all pay dictates down the throats of all private employers. People not happy in their jobs are free to seek employment elsewhere. That such laws are called “pay equity” is a perversion of the term equity.


Gender pay equity laws violate the individual rights to private voluntary agreements between employer and employee, and are thus immoral. Employers and job seekers have a moral right, and should have the legal right, to negotiate their own terms of employment without coercive interference from government. Politicians passing laws dictating what private employers must pay their employees and what employees may agree to work for is essentially gangster economics. The New Jersey pay equity law, and all gender pay equity laws—including the federal one—are impractical, unfair, and immoral.


* [Obama's] claim that women earn 77 cents to a man's dollar is a wild exaggeration. . .His 77-cent number is based on a metric that doesn't take into account the fact that women tend to choose lower-paying professions and take time off when they have children. As a measure of unfair pay, it's worthless. When researchers consider these factors, the gap closes to 91 or even 95 cents to a man's dollar.—Obama-backed pay equity bill was a cynical ploy


Related Reading:





This ‘Women’s History Month,’ Distinguish Between Just and Unjust Equality

Tuesday, February 7, 2017

The Left’s Insatiable Lust to Soak American Business

An NJ.Com article GIVING GREED A HAND by Rutgers University’s Linda Stamato with the sub-heading “America’s tax policies lets corporations skirt their civic obligations, leaving us with a bigger bill to maintain society” gives you a pretty good idea of the political leanings of the author. The essence of Stamato’s article, which appeared in the 4/15/16 New Jersey Star-Ledger, is that business corporations exist only to pay taxes for the sake of “society,” have no right to exist for their own sake, and that no level of taxes is ever enough.

Even if there were no corporate income tax, corporations would still be responsible for virtually all taxes collected by the government; taxes paid by employees of the company and its suppliers, on sales of their products, on property owned by employees, on individuals working in public jobs supported by taxes, by the business’s owners (investors and shareholders) etc. Government gets its tax revenue from productive citizens, and business is the institution that organizes production. Corporate taxes are nothing more than government double-dipping on productive individual citizens. No business corporations, no production above a hand-to-mouth existence—and very little tax revenue. Even before paying a single dollar in tax revenue, successful businesses give by far more to society than any other segment of society, including public universities like Stamato’s Rutgers, which wouldn’t exist without taxes. Stamato owes her job to business corporations, and all they get for their taxes is smears.

An April 2016 NJ Star-Ledger letter put it nicely:

Does the writer not realize that corporations employ millions who pay taxes, provide dividends to stockholders who also pay taxes and have helped to create the greatest country the planet has ever seen? Do they not realize that the stock from corporations provide monetary value to millions of people’s retirement plans? Do they realize that the products from these corporations are actually wanted by customers? It that were not so, the corporations would not exist.

To Stamato and her ilk, “society” can never get enough value from corporations. Despite—or perhaps because of—business corporations’ immense value to Americans, Stamato demonizes them. This irrational anti-business hatred, whatever her motivations, is one of the great injustices in America today.

And what does Stamato contribute? She is co-director of the Center for Negotiation and Conflict Resolution at the Edward J. Bloustein School of Planning and Public Policy, which seeks ways to avoid war. This, from a statist. Given that statism, which is a state of war waged by government against the people, is the fundamental cause of war between nations, one has to wonder what she actually contributes to society—unless you consider bashing productive corporations a “contribution.”

Once you get past Stamato’s irrational bias against business, you get to something I can agree with her on. It took most of the article to get to the real issue—the desperate need for corporate tax reform. But here, too, Stamato demonstrates her bias—toward government’s insatiable appetite for and, apparently, “right” to take whatever it wants from its citizens. No matter how much government confiscates, it’s never enough for the Stamatos of the country.

Stamato’s version of tax reform is to grab more by closing “loopholes” that enable corporations to keep more of what they earn. She lauds New York for raising taxes through “loophole” closing, then rails against “tax-haven shopping”—companies seeking lower-tax states—by urging New Jersey, Massachusetts and Connecticut to raise their taxes in order to funnel $billions more into government coffers. Stamato is right that the current corporate tax code is a preference-ridden mess. But her solution is to close all loopholes, yet says nothing about lowering rates in return. It’s all about soaking business.

And her insatiable appetite for ever more looting of productive corporations doesn’t end at the U.S. border. She demands that lower tax countries like Ireland “do their part to devise tax policies that maintain a sane global economy”—i.e., raise their taxes to the same confiscatory levels as “sane” countries like the U.S.

America has the highest corporate tax rate in the world. Granted, many corporations pay a lower rate, if they meet certain conditions imposed by politicians. But the 35%, which does not include state corporate taxes, is the starting point. And that’s not the only egregious element of America’s corporate taxes. America is the only major industrial nation that taxes foreign profits of its domestic corporations.

Stamato dishonestly portrays tax inverting corporations as evaders of U.S. taxes. But nothing could be further from the truth. Tax inversion does not enable businesses to escape American corporate taxes on profits earned inside the United States. The purpose of inversion is to escape taxes collected on profits earned outside the United States, but which corporations want to invest back in the States. This money held abroad has already been taxed by the country in which it was earned, so U.S. corporations face double taxation from their own government if they want to reinvest it in the U.S. In other words, American companies are punished for reinvesting foreign-earned profits in America—tax inversion wouldn’t be an issue if they didn’t! There’s greed alright; the government and the supporters of its confiscatory corporate tax policy.

Sadly, the Obama Administration—in Trump-like fashion—got his Treasury Department to use its regulatory powers to block Pfizer from inverting. Such is the state of “the rule of law” under which American business must operate. Stamato concludes:

There is a fundamental issue here, too. Do corporations have no sense of responsibility, no sense of obligation as corporate citizens, for, let's put it plainly, the welfare of the nation? If corporations are people — the Supreme Court has told us they are — and people are citizens, we should expect corporations to act like citizens — good citizens, that is — those who pay their taxes to support the nation's needs, shouldn't we?

Yes, and they are no different from homeowners claiming the mortgage interest deduction.

Contrary to Stamato, corporations are not distinct people. They are associations of taxpaying individual citizens, which includes stock holding investors for whom corporate taxes are a form of unfair double taxation. And contrary to Stamato, American citizens are not subjects that have a duty to “the welfare of the nations” and “the nation’s needs”; i.e., the demands of the collective, which means, the state. America is a nation founded on the opposite principle; that each individual has the right to live for herself, and the government’s job is to protect that right. Individualism, not collectivism, is America.

Kudos to American corporations’ legal tax avoidance. Corporations are not subjects of society or of the state. Like everyone else, they, as associations of individuals, have the moral right to pay only what they are legally obligated to pay, and use every legal means available to minimize the government’s take—including robust tax-haven shopping.

Related Reading:




Toward Less-Unfair Corporate Taxes

Sunday, February 5, 2017

Are Parents Capable of Properly Educating Their Children in a Free Market?

An anonymous correspondent has left a comment on my post "DeVos Could Advance the ‘Civil Right’ of School Choice Across America that I think warrants a reply in a full blog post. Anonymous commented:


A free market in education:
As opposed to certified teachers with demonstrable knowledge of education practices, child development and psychology, etc, this would allow parents with no training, knowledge or even possible mental health, to decide what children learn and how. It's not unusual to hear of parents who abuse and even kill the children in their care. Assuming you feel this is undesirable, how would you prevent it?


Along the same lines, schools would be free to implement any curriculum they wish,. So, for example a Wahabi Madrassa might require only memorizing the Koran and inculcate violent jihad. Or closer to home Christian Dominionists, whose stated goal is to replace the US government with a theocracy, would be free to work towards that end. Again assuming these things are undesirable, what steps would you take to avoid them?


You deal with parents who abuse and/or kill their children, or who have mental health problems that preclude their capability to properly raise their children, or whose idea of “education” is to neglect their children’s education in favor of strict religious indoctrination or who actually incite their children to hatred and violence (religious or otherwise), by enacting laws that protect individual rights of children, such as child neglect/child abuse laws, and with laws that uphold individual rights generally, such as criminal laws against force and fraud—and, more broadly, by upholding the principle of separation of religion and state. Protecting individual rights, not running education, is the proper function of government. Our country operates on the principle innocent until proven guilty, not the other way around. Absent evidence of actual harm-doing, the government has no right to interfere. Just as you are protected from unreasonable search and seizure—government agents cannot enter your home to search for stolen property without a warrant based on actual evidence that you are the thief—so should parents be protected regarding how they educate their children.


Anonymous's premise is that every parent should be denied their freedom because some may act badly or make poor choices because they didn’t make the effort to become properly informed. This premise is the essence of injustice. No freedom—intellectual, political, or economic—is possible under these premises. If you hold these premises in opposing freedom of education, you must logically hold them in regard to freedom in any field of human endeavor.


And if parents are incapable of assessing the qualifications of educators or educational philosophies and rationally choosing accordingly, then is any adult capable of assessing doctors, plumbers, auto mechanics, investment advisers, lawyers, and the services they provide etc., etc., etc., or of assessing the products that fill the shelves of America’s stores? Are they even capable of judging the politicians and public school board members who will administer public education, or should we do away with elections? Do you have to be an “expert” in any of these fields to make rational decisions? No, you just have to become informed enough to make a reasoned choice. Anonymous’s argument—that parents are incapable of exercising the freedom to direct the course of their children’s education—is in principle the same argument used by the Southern states to protect slavery; that blacks are not capable of exercising freedom. Anonymous has—unwittingly, I presume—repudiated the whole concept of a free society and upheld the validity of the totalitarian state ruled by an allegedly omniscient “philosopher king” elite.


Anonymous’s argument is self-refuting in another way. If individuals in their private lives are capable of the kinds of atrocious behavior that you describe—and some are—then what’s to stop the same people who gain control of the machinery of state from imposing irrational educational beliefs on everyone? Because they’re “experts?” We already see it now, with regard to Christians imposing “creationism” and Leftists imposing “climate change catastrophe” in public school curriculums—in each case without any proof. Government schools don’t automatically protect us from bad education. Neither will a free market. But at least in a free market, or even a semi-free system of universal parental choice, parents can remove their children from bad schools and get them into better schools.


Finally, Anonymous’s argument that there is some kind of either/or dichotomy between a free market in education and qualified educators—”A free market in education: As opposed to certified teachers with demonstrable knowledge of education practices, child development and psychology”—is just arbitrary and wrong. The government doesn’t run the plumbing industry, yet there are plenty of qualified plumbers (I am one). If private schools are incapable of finding and/or training “certified teachers with demonstrable knowledge of education practices, child development and psychology,” then on what basis are we to be assured that government schools are any more capable? How do you explain the many good private pre-schools, k-12 schools, and universities that now operate? Qualified teachers won’t just disappear into thin air if we moved to a free market. Neither will good people suddenly stop going into the education field. We will, however, have much more diversity and competition in education.


Anonymous worries that Christian Dominionists might indoctrinate their children into working to replace the US government with a theocracy. It’s a legitimate fear, which is the reason for the religious Establishment Clause of the First Amendment, which prohibits the government from making any  “law respecting an establishment of religion.” But we should also fear, with much more fervor, government control of education precisely because we don’t have the protection of an Establishment Clause relating to education. What’s to stop government from indoctrinating children in its schools with an ideology directed to the purpose of establishing some other form of tyranny, such as collectivism for the purpose of establishing socialism—a process that is already well underway? Private education won’t prevent all bad education or guarantee all schools are good, but it will prevent bad education from being imposed by force of law. C. Bradley Thompson, writing for The Objective Standard, begins making his case for “The Need for Separation of School and State” by citing principles espoused by James Madison:


In 1784, in response to Patrick Henry’s call for a compulsory tax to support Christian (particularly Episcopalian) ministers, Madison penned his famous “Memorial and Remonstrance,” a stirring defense of religious freedom and the separation of church and state. The heart of his argument can be reduced to three principles: first, individuals have an inalienable right to practice their religion as they see fit; second, religion must not be directed by the state; and third, religion is corrupted by government interference or control. Few Americans today would disagree with Madison’s reasoning.


One virtue of Madison’s response to Henry’s bill is that its principles and logic extend beyond church-and-state relations. In fact, the principles and logic of his argument apply seamlessly to the relationship of education and state. If we substitute the word “education” for “religion” throughout Madison’s text, we find a perfect parallel: first, parents have an inalienable right to educate their children according to their values; second, education must not be directed by the state; and third, education is corrupted by government interference or control. The parallel is stark, and the logic applies equally in both cases.


Just as Americans have a right to engage in whatever non-rights-violating religious practices they choose, so Americans have a right to engage in whatever educational practices they choose. And just as Americans would not grant government the authority to run their Sunday schools, so they should not grant government the authority to run their schools Monday through Friday.
Parents (and guardians) have a right to direct the education of their children.1


Parents’ children are their children—not their neighbors’ children or the community’s children or the state’s children.


Reflecting on the issues and questions raised by Anonymous advances the case for the separation of education and state.


Related Reading:





Education in a Free Society—C. Bradley Thompson for The Objective Standard

Friday, February 3, 2017

NJ Mom Should Demand More Educational Freedom for Herself, Not Cut Down Others’ Freedom

Charter schools have been expanding rapidly in New Jersey in recent years due to strong parental demand. When a student attends a charter school, the education tax dollars follow the student. So good have charter schools performed that even the normally Left-leaning New Jersey Star-Ledger saw fit to chastise the leading Democrat 2017 gubernatorial candidate for his ties to the teachers union and “threat to successful charter schools.” This charter expansion has created a political backlash from the entrenched establishment, led by the teachers union.

As part of that backlash, a group of parents in Red Bank, NJ are demanding that a charter school in their town be closed “because, they argue, it has created the most segregated school district in New Jersey.” According to MaryAnn Spoto, reporting for NJ Advance Media for NJ.com,

The complaint said Red Bank residents spend $2 million annually to fund two public schools – one that is predominantly poor and Hispanic with about 1,400 students and another that is smaller, whiter and wealthier with 200 students.

The Red Bank Charter School opened 28 years ago, approved for 80 students. It then expanded to 162 students and now has applied to double its enrollment. But these parents want it closed.

One Red Bank, NJ woman laid out the case against the charter in her town—not being racially and economically balanced enough. In a NJ Star-Ledger guest column, N.J. mom: Why my town’s charter school doesn’t work if you’re poor and brown, Maria De Los Angeles Santamaria Zacarias observes:

The student body of the Red Bank public schools is 81 percent Latino, while at the charter school only 38 percent are Latino. If you look at the composition of the schools from a socio-economic perspective there is a similar disparity. About 89 percent of the children in the Red Bank public schools qualify for free and reduced lunches, an indicator of poverty, while at the charter school only 41 percent do.

I thought charter schools were supposed to reflect the racial, ethnic and socio-economic composition of the town. In Red Bank, this is clearly not the case. The Red Bank Charter School has become a bastion of segregation and privilege.

Only late in the article did Ms. Zacarias get around to addressing educational quality, saying the charter is no better than the traditional public schools, based on the Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) test. But that’s a Red Herring. The parents chose the charter, and their judgement trumps Zacarias’ opinions or standardized tests.

The Red Bank Charter School has applied to the state Department Of Education for permission to expand. It was denied, meaning that students already in the highest grade in the school must be forced back into the traditional public school, because expansion means adding the next grade to accommodate advancing students. The charter now has an application to renew its existing charter. Ms. Zacarias urges the permission be denied. Why? Because the charter “damages” our community:

Some people no longer talk to their neighbors. There is tension when parents from the schools come together at the kids’ sports games. But most hurtful of all are some of the comments I’ve heard from charter parents. They refer to me and people like me as “those people.”

We are just people. People like everyone else, who want what’s best for our children.

There are other issues. Ms. Zacarias also observes that the charter gets more funding than the traditionals—$18,726 per student versus $16,607. But, she says, “Red Bank is a small community. It should have one school system.”

No, it shouldn’t. I left these comments:

This shows the dark side of the collectivist “diversity” campaign, which ignores the individual humanity of actual children and instead seeks to categorize children by racial groupings.

Charter schools are not a magic bullet (I favor a fully free market in education, which would involve the separation of education and state). But charters do provide a modicum of freedom within the monopolistic government school establishment, giving parents some choice over their children's education and educators the chance to innovate. Yet, the Red Bank and other charters are being attacked—and by extension the educational choices charter parents made for their children—because it doesn’t fit some neat little racial statistic. What about actual education for actual children—not merely as determined by standardized tests or other bureaucratic criteria, but as judged by the child’s parents?

The Red Bank Charter “damages our community?” What is a community, but a number of individuals? How will some parents attacking the education choices of other parents foster a harmonious community? Peaceful coexistence is built on respect for the rights of others—including the right of parents to direct the course of their own children’s education. Respect for individual rights is the only basis for a decent community. No wonder the charter parents are angry. Other people want to shut down their children’s school, forcing their children back into the traditional government school that they believe isn’t good for their child. It sounds to me like the phrase “those people” refers not to race but to the anti-charter crowd.

But this is how collectivism works. It forbids anyone from excelling, pulling anyone who does try back down into the tribal brew—all in the name of the equality myth. The result? Dissention between those who try to rise up, and those who resent them.

No community “should have one school system”—especially a government-run system. Human beings are not a homogenous herd. The herd, or tribal, premise goes against our humanity. Collectivism breeds an us-versus-them mentality. This may suit people who want to run our lives or control what and how children are taught. But it doesn’t suit a free, enlightened, and civil society.

This mother shouldn’t be concerned with racial stats. Every parent should focus on getting her own child the best education possible, not “what’s best for our children”—i.e., other people’s children. If Ms. Zacarias is not happy with her child's school, she should demand more charter choices or, better yet, the ability to use her son’s education dollars—the $16,607—to fund tuition payments for Bryan [her son] to attend a school of her choice; choices that should include all available education options, including private schools and homeschooling; choices that should be open to all parents. The per-pupil cost of public schools is, at root, private money, and should be directed by private citizens, not politically advantaged interests.

When I think of segregation, I think of government-enforced separation of groups. The Red Bank charter is 38% Latino and 41% classified as poor, as opposed to 81% and 89% in the traditional public schools. This is hardly segregation. Charters, being tax-funded schools, should be forbidden from discriminating based on race or parents’ income in its admittance standards. Assuming that’s the case—and I have seen no indication of racial or economic discrimination—the statistical disparities are a result of parental school choice, not enforced segregation. Apparently, their is unsatisfied demand for more entries into the charter, as there are throughout New Jersey, and the charter seeks to expand to accommodate some of that demand.

Yet, rather than expand the opportunities for more parents to get their children into the school, many parents want the school shut down for racial and economic class, i.e., collectivist, reasons. Not a word about child education, educational innovation, or parental choice, either of those already in the charter or of others who want in because they are seeking better education than, in their judgement, the traditional schools can provide.

Granted, the original rationale for opening the charter feeds into this racial collectivism—the school was allegedly needed to stop “white flight” from Red Bank. So in part the charter is a victim of its own premises. But it’s a shame that in a nation based on individualism, schools are being judged by collectivist standards rather than educational standards and results. These kinds of conflicts would never happen in a free market for education.

Unfortunately, government-financed schools are not going away anytime soon. That doesn’t mean all schools should be government administered and run. And it doesn’t mean that parents with an apparent racial inferiority complex should be able to close schools and deny educational opportunities freely chosen. America is a nation built for the individual’s freedom to escape the tribal muck.

Related Reading:




Dividing Parents Over Charters and Traditional Government Schools

Wednesday, February 1, 2017

Trump Could Give Us a Welcome Respite from Environmentalist Political Domination

Recently, the New Jersey Star-Ledger, reflecting the Environmentalist Left’s panic over Donald Trump’s election, railed that Trump's war on the environment must be fought locally., and urged people to gear up for the “People's Climate Mobilization in Washington on April 29.”


I left these comments:


The battle over climate change is a broader battle between environmentalism and human flourishing.


Humans survive and thrive by using reason and productive work to transform the raw environment to benefit human living. Environmentalists’ moral standard of value is unaltered nature. Therefore, Environmentalism is ideologically inimical to human well-being. Climate change is the main front in the Environmentalists’ war on human flourishing, and reliable energy led by fossil fuels and free market capitalism are the main targets of the Environmentalists because reliable energy is vital to industrial progress and freedom is the social condition vital to the production of industrial-scale energy.


For too long, the anti-humanists, with climate catastrophism as a cover, have had the political upper hand in America. They have convinced many that reliable energy, mainly fossil fuels but also non-carbon reliable sources like nuclear power and hydroelectric power, must be curtailed and eliminated regardless of the immense value they provide to human well-being and regardless of the catastrophic harm energy poverty will bring to people. Mind you, the Environmentalists are not just calling for minimizing the negative side-effects of energy production, but eliminating reliable energy as such—kind of like eliminating antibiotics because they entail some negative side-effects.


It’s about time we got the other side of the debate brought to the forefront. I will not judge Trump’s specific policies here. I do not know if Trump is the president to bring it about, being as unpredictable as he is. What I do know is that we need an honest debate that considers not just the negative side effects of reliable fossil fuel energy specifically and industrialization generally, but also their immense value based on a humanist standard of value—human well-being as the moral standard.


The climate catastrophists, aka climate alarmists, know that their case is garbage. That’s why they need to demonize “skeptics” as science deniers or climate deniers. That’s why they resort to neo-fascist tactics like the “AGs for Clean Power” coalition’s prosecutorial assault on dissenters under the guise of “fraud.” True, climate change is real, humans are one contributing factor, and everyone knows it. So what? The immense value of reliable energy including fossil fuels is far greater than whatever negatives carbon dioxide causes (which, by the way, must be balanced against the positive impacts of increased CO2, such as enhanced plant growth). But climate catastrophism is pure speculation peddled by primitives who are unconcerned with the human catastrophe their policies, if fully enacted, will cause. It’s about time we got a full, undemonized airing of the pro-humanist and progressive pro-energy side in the Climate debate in Washington.


The Star-Ledger observes, “The week actually began with a Pew poll that said that 55 percent of Americans believe the environment should be among Trump's top priorities. We hope the same people are making plans for April 29.”


This presupposes the question, “What do we mean by ‘the environment’?” Nobody wants dirty industrialization. No one wants wanton destruction of natural beauty, or polluted rivers, or dirty air—all of which can and should be subject to rational anti-pollution laws based on available technology and cost-benefit analysis. But pollution is not the issue. The question is, by “the environment” do we mean a transformed environment safe and conducive for human flourishing or an unaltered “natural” environment that leaves humanity subject to natural dangers that industrialism now protects us from?


There is no imagined “war on the environment.” The real battle is Environmentalism vs. Human Flourishing—i.e., an unaltered “natural” environment vs. a human environment. A loud and vocal minority will come out on April 29th, some well-intentioned but grossly misguided, but led by nihilistic energy-enemies like Environmentalist Bill McKibben and his ilk. Those of us who actually value our lives, the lives of our families, and those of future generations should reject it. I side with Human Flourishing.


Related Reading:










Related Viewing:

Hans Rosling's 'Magic Washing Machine’