Friday, October 27, 2023

The Morals of the Israel/Hamas War—and the Vindication of Leonard Piekoff

The moral standing of the latest Israel/Hamas war is as bright a line as you’ll ever see. The aggressor is Hamas. The defender is Israel. From the moment Hamas launched its barbaric attack on Israel, every casualty on either side became the moral responsibility of Hamas, the aggressor. Every brick in the Gazan rubble resulting from the Israeli military retaliation; every drop of blood and every tear shed by Gazans, civilians, foreign nationals, or others, is the moral responsibility of Hamas. 


To be clear, let’s consider the alleged destruction of that hospital that was first reported to have resulted in hundreds of deaths. Hamas immediately blamed an Israeli air strike. It has since become clear that it was an errant missile fired by a Hamas ally. And the death total and damage to the hospital turned out to have been greatly exaggerated. But all of that is morally beside the point. Even if the original reports were accurate, and a strategically targeted Israeli air strike destroyed the hospital and killed many hundreds, the responsibility would be on Hamas. Hamas is the aggressor. Israel is the defender. That strike would not have happened but for Hamas’s attack on Israel.


From here on out, whatever death and destruction results from Israel’s avowed strategy to eradicate Hamas once and for all—including the use of nuclear weapons, if God forbid it comes to that, will be laid at the feet of Hamas and its master, the Islamic theocracy of Iran.


Which brings us to the next point. In 2001, right after the 9/11 attacks, Ayn Rand Institute founder Leonard Piekoff went on the Bill O’Reilly show to advocate for the response to the Islamic attack on America that he considered proper. In a contentious interview in which O’Reilly treated Piekoff at times less than respectful, Piekoff argued that the Taliban in Afghanistan was the wrong target. The right target, said Piekoff, was Iran, the spiritual and political head of the entire anti-civilization Islamic Totalitarian movement. Have a listen, think about where we are now, and then dare to tell me that Piekoff was wrong. 


Imagine where we’d be today had America followed Leonard Peikoff’s advice.


Related Reading:


The Jihad Against America and How to End It, by Craig Biddle for The Objective Standard blog


Winning the Unwinnable War: America's Self-Crippled Response to Islamic Totalitarianism, by Elan Journo


The War Between Enlightenment and Fundamentalist Political Islam—and the Choice All Muslims Must Make


Bush's Collapsing "War on Terror"


The "Forward Strategy" for Failure by Yaron Brook and Elan Journo


Related: Democracy in Action in Egypt


Ralph Peters: "Mesmerized by Elections, We Forgot Freedom"


Iraqi Democracy vs. Freedom


Mesmerized by Elections, the NJ Star-Ledger Forgot that Tyranny is Tyranny


No comments: