Sunday, December 14, 2014

Catholic Schools Are Struggling to Stay Open: (Partial) Solution, Tax Credits

NJ Catholic schools fight to keep doors open as future dims, screams a headline in the New Jersey Star-Ledger.


I left these comments:


While there may be many reasons for Catholic Schools’ struggles, the biggest is likely the dominance of the quasi-monopolistic, coercive “public”—i.e., government—school system.


The basic injustice that parents who choose private education options for their children face is that they are forced to continue having their money seized to fund the government schools. This is morally grotesque, and probably keeps a lot of parents who would otherwise choose private education stuck in public schools.


This injustice should be corrected. A properly structured tax credit program for parental school choice would move us in that direction. My tax credit proposal, Toward a Free Market in Education published in The Objective Standard, would open the door to private alternatives to the public schools for all parents in all income brackets. Tax credits would be available to all taxpayers to fund the education of any child, limited to the per-pupil cost in the child’s local school district. This feature would open vast opportunities not just for parents but for older taxpayers to fund their grandchildren, for example, and for philanthropic funding of poor children’s education, should the poor parents choose private education. And, since tax credits leave individuals free to spend only their own money as they choose—as is their fundamental right—the separation of church and state would not be violated as it is with government vouchers.


This may or may not help the Catholic schools. But it would go a long way to correct the moral injustice of coercive government schools. It would enable private education alternatives of all kinds to compete for education dollars on a more even playing field, while leaving the public schools adequately funded for those who remain with them.


Related Reading:




     My replies to TOS letters regarding Toward a Free Market in Education:



Friday, December 12, 2014

Debunking Myths of American History—4

This is Part 4 of a 4-part series, in which I replied to comments made under the op-ed by Frayda Levin, an Americans for Prosperity board member, titled I'm A Proud Koch Brothers Insider. For a deep, integrated history of capitalism, I recommend The Capitalist Manifesto by Andrew Bernstein.


“Fact is, while individual humans are decent, as a group they're aggressive, exploitative, oppressive, violent, selfish, and dangerous.  The evidence is in our history.”—Get Real


My Reply:


This makes no sense. A group is made up of individuals. Some individuals are “aggressive, exploitative, oppressive, violent, selfish [in the conventional sense], and dangerous.” But most are industrious, respectful, benevolent, cooperative, and no threat to others; i.e., rationally selfish [at least to some extent]. Man is not predisposed either way. The evidence is that the freer a country is, the more people achieve and coexist peacefully. Only with the arrival of “big government” did America begin its descent into predatory balkinization, as “progressives” transformed our government from one limited to protecting individual rights to a rights-violating tool of pressure group factions. When government (the power of the gun) is given the power of aggressive force, the bad type of people organize to use that aggressive power. Then others follow, either in self-preservation or for their own predatory purposes. Special interest politics proliferates. When people are forced into tribal conflict, what does one expect? Blame belongs to the collectivist/statist system the progressives built, not human nature, which is only suited to individualism and limited government.


Related Reading:

For the New Intellectual—Ayn Rand

Thursday, December 11, 2014

Debunking Myths of American History—3

This is Part 3 of a 4-part series, in which I replied to comments made under the op-ed by Frayda Levin, an Americans for Prosperity board member, titled I'm A Proud Koch Brothers Insider. For a deep, integrated history of capitalism, I recommend The Capitalist Manifesto by Andrew Bernstein.


“[A] complex global economy cannot function in a 18th century Jeffersonian utopia.”Get Real

My Reply:


So a free society in which every individual can think and act on his own judgement, pursue his own values, keep his earned rewards and must take responsibility for his own failings, under a government limited to protecting his right and an economy based on voluntary trade to mutual advantage, is utopian? What is the anti-utopia—a handful of central planning, all-powerful government masterminds imbued with superior wisdom, omniscience, and infallibility running hundreds of millions of lives in perfect harmony? You have it exactly backward: Freedom is the realistic ideal. Statism is utopian.

Related Reading:


Atlas Shrugged—Ayn Rand



Ameritopia: The Unmaking of America—Mark R. Levin

Wednesday, December 10, 2014

Debunking Myths of American History—2

This is Part 2 of a 4-part series, in which I replied to comments made under the op-ed by Frayda Levin, an Americans for Prosperity board member, titled I'm A Proud Koch Brothers Insider. For a deep, integrated history of capitalism, I recommend The Capitalist Manifesto by Andrew Bernstein.


“The Post Civil War order, which lasted in many places until WWII,  was dominated by robber barons, children working in factories and mines. segregation and lynching, and horrific conditions.”—Get Real


My Reply:

Wrong. This period was the freest era in human history, and the result was astounding progress across society. Jobs, rising real wages, and new occupations abounded. Mostly poor but ambitious immigrants flooded in. Why? To come to the hellhole you describe? Hardly. To live free, and prosper. The middle class was born. It was not a time of robber barons. It was a time of industrial genius and inventiveness. The period started with the horse and buggy and whale oil lighting and ended with electrification, indoor plumbing, automobiles, aviation, skyscrapers, and on and on. Your hellhole is a fiction manufactured by capitalist-hating, socialist-embracing intellectuals, who had to bury the truth about capitalism to pave the way for the “Progressives.”


The whole of the evidence of the past 250 years is that prosperity and societal harmony exist only to the extent that individuals can live and associate freely and government exists to protect their rights to do so.


As to “children working in factories and mines [and] segregation and lynching”:


Child labor existed throughout history, as a necessity of survival. Capitalism inherited child labor, as it did all of the “horrific conditions” it gets blamed for but didn’t create. Capitalist prosperity eliminated the need for child labor, over time, as economies and prosperity grew because of capitalistic freedom.


Segregation is not a product of capitalism (freedom). It is statist. Segregation is legally imposed “separate but equal” doctrine entrenched by the reactionary 1896 Supreme Court Plessy ruling. Separate but Equal is a work-around against the 14th Amendment’s “equal protection” clause. Lynchings are crimes, for which the government is created to protect against. The widespread use of segregation and lynchings was a failure of government, not freedom.


Related Reading:


The Inventive Period—Andrew Bernstein



Notes, and Myths, on American History - 2

Tuesday, December 9, 2014

Was America 'made possible by stealing Indian land and the labor of slaves?'

Yesterday, I highlighted an op-ed by Frayda Levin, an Americans for Prosperity board member, titled I'm A Proud Koch Brothers Insider. In the comments section, a critical correspondent with the screen name “Get Real” posted a hodgepodge of charges against capitalism and Americanism.


Starting today, I’ll post my rebuttals to several myths advanced in the comments. If we pro-liberty activists are to successfully defend liberty, we must be able to defend the history of capitalism and the American Founding. This entails getting history right. For a deep, integrated history of capitalism, I recommend The Capitalist Manifesto by Andrew Bernstein. In the meantime . . .


“America's early history was made possible by stealing Indian land and the labor of slaves.”—Get Real

My Reply:


Think about what you’re saying, here. “Predation and slavery are good, because they lead to prosperity.”


Of course, that’s nonsense.


Slaves produce far below their potential because they are forbidden to get an education, maximize their talents, act on their own judgement, pursue their own goals and values, and keep what they earn. If slavery—which America inherited from past history—was the source of prosperity, human history would have been one long economic boom prior to the liberty of capitalism and the industrial revolution, which eventually eliminated the practice. That was not the case. Slavery held this country back. The innovative chemist and agricultural giant George Washington Carver—a former slave—achieved more as a single free man than any number of plantation slaves ever could. How many Carvers—and ambitious black men and women generally—failed to flourish because they were locked up in the slave system? How much better off would America be today had this country’s Founding ideals been spread to everyone at its beginning? The loss to this country in terms of today’s prosperity because of the existence of slavery is incalculable.


To say that this country was "built on the backs of slaves" is a grave insult to the memory of the slaves. This country was built on liberty, property rights, and individualism. Granted, not everyone was free. It was only to the extent that people were free, not enslaved, that this country prospered.


As to “stealing Indian land,” North America was a mostly open, uninhabited continent—punctuated by pockets of primitive tribes. The idea that the indians owned the continent to the exclusion of the rest of the world is a purely racist concept. European settlers had as much right to settle in North America as the American Indians had before them and as new immigrants have today. Injustices were committed against the Indians, including stealing land they actually settled, and we shouldn’t minimize that. But the reverse was also true. There were also injustices by Indians against the settlers.

Related Reading:

The Enemies of Christopher Columbus: Answers to Critical Questions About the Spread of Western Civilization—Thomas A. Bowden

Monday, December 8, 2014

The Koch Brothers and the Nature of Government Regulation

The Koch Brothers are out front in actively supporting Right-wing—meaning pro-liberty, limited government—causes. Among the causes they support is the pro-free market Americans for Prosperity.


Needless to say, the Koch Brothers are among the Left’s favorite whipping boys. So, it was nice to see them defended in a New Jersey Star-Ledger op-ed recently. Frayda Levin, an Americans for Prosperity board member, wrote I'm A Proud Koch Brothers Insider on 10/2/14.


Government regulation of business is a major theme in this piece. This segment really caught my attention:  


As a small business owner, I regularly dealt with the IRS, the New Jersey Department of Treasury, the New Jersey Department of Labor, the federal Department of Labor, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, the Consumer Product Safety Commission, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and environmental agencies at the local, state, and federal levels, to name but a few.


The list of laws that applied to me and forms that I filled out on a daily, weekly, and annual basis is even longer. Each agency requires reams of paperwork; each law they implement or regulation they pass contains hundreds of pages of complex legal language.


No small business owner could ever hope to understand this convoluted and overlapping system. Yet if I was not in compliance with any of the thousands of pages of laws, reporting, and filing requirements, I could be sued, fined, or even jailed.


I left these comments:


“No small business owner could ever hope to understand this convoluted and overlapping system. Yet if I was not in compliance with any of the thousands of pages of laws, reporting, and filing requirements, I could be sued, fined, or even jailed.”


One of the primary fundamental motives behind the regulatory state is power-lust. Fear generated by non-objective, confusing regulatory law, in which no businessman can ever really know when they are breaking the law, is an effective lever of government control over businessmen. As a government official admitted in Atlas Shrugged, “There’s no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren’t enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible for men to live without breaking laws.”


The other basic premise driving ever-expanding regulation is: Punish the innocent many for the wrongdoing of the few. Let a handful of scoundrels come to light, and the politicians cry for “more regulations”; followed by the entire industry or business community being burdened with another layer of regulation. After the handful of Enron accounting scandals, thousands of innocent businesses who didn't cook their books got hit with Sarbanes-Oxley. As I’ve noted, if someone seriously proposed putting all Italian-Americans under government probation [treating them like paroled convicts] because a few became Mafia gangsters, everyone would see the absurdity and injustice of the idea. Yet, that is precisely the widely accepted premise—instead directed at businessmen—that underpins government regulation. The presumption of guilt that American businessmen labor under—and the resultant labyrinth of regulations—is just another virulent form of bigotry.


This, in a nutshell, is the regulatory state.


It is said that government regulation is needed to protect consumers. Yet, no matter how many regulations are imposed, charlatans continue to operate. Regulations didn’t stop Enron or Bernie Madoff. If government stopped wasting resources making life miserable for the innocent—protecting rather than violating their rights—and concentrated instead on pursuing the guilty, consumers, our economy in general, and our lives would be much better off.


The Koch Brothers are fighting the good fight—for themselves, sure, but also for the rest of us who love liberty.


Related Reading:





Where Does Valid Law End and Regulation Begin?

Saturday, December 6, 2014

The Wall Street Journal Reviews Epstein's 'The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels'

The Wall Street Journal has published a review of Alex Epstein’s The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels, a much-needed defense of the vital resources coal, oil, and natural gas. Philip Delves Broughton writes:


If you drive a car, or use modern medicine, or believe in man’s right to economic progress, then according to Alex Epstein you should be grateful—more than grateful. In “The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels” the author, an energy advocate and founder of a for-profit think tank called the Center for Industrial Progress, suggests that if all you had to rely on were the good intentions of environmentalists, you would be soon plunged back into a pre-industrial hell. Life expectancy would plummet, climate-related deaths would soar, and the only way that Timberland and Whole Foods could ship their environmentally friendly clothing and food would be by mule. “Being forced to rely on solar, wind, and biofuels would be a horror beyond anything we can imagine,” writes Mr. Epstein, “as a civilization that runs on cheap, plentiful, reliable energy would see its machines dead, its productivity destroyed, its resources disappearing.”


When you consider that most of us live what we would consider decent, moral lives, it seems extraordinary that anyone feels it necessary to write a book called “The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels.” We use fossil fuels and their by-products in everything we do and rarely consider it a vice. A pang of conscience may strike us when we read of oil spills or melting icebergs. But not when we are sitting on a plastic chair, visiting a power-guzzling hospital or turning on our computers. To call fossil fuels “immoral” is to tarnish our entire civilization and should plunge us all into a permanent state of guilt, which seems a bit strong.


Yet, as Mr. Epstein notes, this is precisely what so many vocal environmentalists do.

This is a really important review. In an e-mail to subscribers, Epstein, who heads The Center for Industrial Progress, wrote that “the WSJ review is uniquely important as it marks the most significant mainstream mention of a moral case for fossil fuels.” He notes that after the WSJ review, “Amazon’s ranking of The Moral Case shot up over 5000 spots in one day.” You can read the whole review here. The first chapter of the book is available for free here.