Friday, March 13, 2015

Natural Resources Defense Council Hails NY's Ban on CO2-Reducing NatGas Fracking

Late last year, New York Governor Andrew Cuomo banned hydraulic fracturing (aka “fracking”) in his state. The New Jersey Star-Ledger’s Tom Moran ran a column challenging that decision, saying Cuomo’s ban on fracking handicaps the fight against climate change (See my 12/28/14 post). In his column, Moran criticized environmentalists’ celebration of Cuomo’s ban, saying:

I hate to be a Green Grinch, but this is one of the environmental movement’s blind spots. Cuomo’s decision is a disaster for the environment where it counts most – on climate change.

Fracking has created a boom in natural gas production, driving its price below that of coal. And when a power plant switches from coal to gas, its carbon emissions are cut in half. That is the key reason America’s carbon emissions have been dropping since 2006, despite the political stalemate.

Shortly after, director of Programs for the Natural Resources Defense Council Daly Bryk—who was quoted in Moran’s column—took Moran to task in a New Jersey Star-Ledger letter.

I left these comments, drawing on quotes from Bryk’s letter:

“For too long, the fossil fuel industry has sold us the idea that we must choose between one dirty fuel or another. That is no longer reality.”

Sure it is. Every fuel source is “dirty” in some respect. Wind energy, for instance, requires massive mining, transportation, manufacturing, infrastructure, construction, and maintenance operations, and has horrific pollution consequences. Regardless of the energy technology, pollution should be minimized as much as technologically possible, consistent with the energy needs of human life. The question is: What energy source meets our needs fully and reliably? Which energy source is worth the risk of some pollution or climate change? Fossil fuels come in first. Nuclear and hydro a distant second and third. So-called “clean energy” doesn’t even make the reliability scale.

“Natural gas may burner cleaner than coal, but from the ground to the smoke stack, it still contributes to climate change.”

So what? Human beings survive and thrive by altering and improving the environment. So what if a bit more greenhouse gases reach the atmosphere. Greenhouse gases make life possible by keeping the Earth warm. If a slightly warmer Earth is the “price” of a better human life across the board, it is the moral and practical choice. And far more than any other energy source, fossil fuels have massively improved the environment from the standpoint of human life as the standard of value.

“Now is the time to break our reliance on all fossil fuels, and go all-in on the clean energy sources at our fingertips.”

Now is not the time to force people into life-destroying energy privation. There should never come such a time. Fossil fuels provide reliable, economical, scalable, abundant energy on demand. “Clean energy” cannot. At least Moran seems to understand, at least implicitly, that we shouldn’t destroy the economy, and millions of lives along with it, unless and until “clean energy” alternatives prove that they can.

Let “clean energy” demonstrate its ability to replace fossil fuels in the free market—i.e., by convincing people to voluntarily embrace solar or wind without government “incentives,” subsidies, or legal restrictions on fossil fuel alternatives. Go ahead, Daly Bryk: You’re free to “go all-in on the clean energy sources” and prove that they really are “at our fingertips”—at your own expense, in voluntary contract with others, without government “help.” It is not fossil fuel interests who are trying to thwart “clean” alternatives. It is “clean energy” special interests who are trying to stop fossil fuels. If and when energy consumers voluntarily choose solar, wind, et al because it is demonstrably better in all respects, you and your “green” energy win. Until then, leave fossil fuel companies free to continue to develop and sell their products in free competition. It’s the only humane course of action. Our lives depend on it. To stop fossil fuel development before a demonstrably viable replacement is available, and consumers are rationally persuaded by new energy producers to switch, would be cruel beyond words. We shouldn’t gamble the lives of billions of human beings on a “clean energy” pipe dream.

Despite its name, the Natural Resources Defense Council does not defend natural resources. It defends natural raw materials.

A “resource” is a material that can be used to create something useful. A “natural resource” is a naturally occurring raw material transformed into a useful material. Natural gas was not a resource until human ingenuity turned it into one. The same goes for oil, coal, aluminum, iron ore, uranium, sand (for computer chips), etc., etc., etc. Human beings survive and thrive by turning natural raw materials into man-made resources and resources into human life-enhancing products and services. The NRDC doesn’t defend natural resources. If it did, it would defend man’s freedom and ability to create resources out of raw materials. Instead, it seeks to stop the creative process that human life depends on. It “defends” raw materials from transformation into the resources of human life. The NRDC is anti-human life.

Daly Bryk is an uncompromising environmentalist and full-fledged statist. As Moran noted in his column, Bryk advocates using government force

to redouble efforts to conserve energy, by far the cheapest way to reduce emissions. She wants a crash program to build wind and solar power. She wants a national program to cut emissions in all sectors.

Related Reading:



Environmentalists, Luddites, and Collectivism

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

Congress Should Abolish Obama’s Discriminatory “Gainful Employment” Regulations Against For-Profit Colleges

The Obama Administration will implement new so-called “gainful employment” regulations on colleges on July 1. The Objective Standard published my article on the subject in December. I wrote:

In 2010, the Obama administration began a concerted assault on private-sector, for-profit colleges (often called “career colleges”) by, among other means, seeking to establish so-called gainful employment regulations that would restrict students’ access to federally backed loans if students sought to attend career colleges rather than government-run or nonprofit colleges.

Read the rest of The Government’s Renewed Assault on Private-Sector Colleges. And be sure to check out Craig Biddle’s print article The Government’s Assault on Private-Sector Colleges and Universities as well as the other links in the article.

Also, consider Obama’s “Free” Community College Scheme in the context of these regulations.

Related Reading:



Where Does Valid Law End and Regulation Begin?

Monday, March 9, 2015

America Was Not Founded as a Christian Nation

I just came across this article by Bill Flax; Was America Founded as a Christian Nation? I think it’s fairly accurate, but only up to a point. Flax observes that:

The most vocal proponents of Christian America and their counterparts advocating a completely secular state necessarily cherry-pick data to prove exaggerations while discarding inconvenient details.

Flax criticizes the Religious Right for “transforming our Forefathers [ the Founding Fathers] into faithful servants of Christ.” On the other hand, observes Flax, “[T]hose most ardently challenging America ’s Christian origins wrongly portray the Founders as rank secularists.”

While there is no question that there were many Christians among the Founders, I think the second idea is closest to the truth.

American culture is predominantly Christian. But America is not, never has been, and never was a Christian nation. The fact that many Christians were instrumental in creating America does not change that fact. America is an Enlightenment nation. Many Enlightened Christians helped create it. But it is not a Christian nation. Pre-Enlightenment, Christianity had centuries to create an American nation, but did not and could not. No Enlightenment, no America.

The Founders believed in reason; that reason is a valid guide to human action and man’s primary means of supporting his life; that reason belongs to the individual; that therefore individuals must be free to live by reason; and thus government must be erected to protect man’s inalienable rights to liberty. These are Enlightenment ideals. This liberty includes the freedom to live by one’s beliefs, whether religious or not. Hence, the First Amendment, and church-state separation. This view is compatible with enlightened Christianity: God created man and nature, but then leaves us to shape our own existence with our human faculties without His interference. But this view is not dependent on Christianity. The Enlightenment transformed Christianity. The Enlightenment led, Christianity followed. Man’s nature and the social requirements for his survival and flourishing are what they are, regardless of whether one thinks man has supernatural origins or not.

The Founders did inherit Christian morals. But the Founders were political, not moral, revolutionaries. Enlightened Christianity served as a ready-made philosophy for the Founders, even though much of it—particularly the altruist ethics—contradicted the Declaration’s principles, which sanctioned man’s right to pursue his own happiness. Like most enlightened Christians—and as Flax notes—the Founders cherry-picked what they thought to be the rational elements.

While Flax decries Big Government operating in Christ’s name, he seems to approve of “big government” when it suits Christianity: He condemns those who believe the First Amendment justifies evicting crosses from parks, purging prayer from schools and ousting “under God” from the Pledge of Allegiance.

The Founders wouldn’t have supported officially-sponsored prayer in government schools. If they did, they would be completely contradicting their own Founding principles. It’s clearly a violation of the Establishment Clause for a government institution to impose religious practices. It’s simply wrong to impose prayer sessions on a captive audience of kids compelled by truancy laws to be in schools that their parents are compelled to finance. I doubt the Founders would even approve of our government-run schools. It clearly contradicts the principle of inalienable individual rights, and makes inevitable conflicts like the controversy over school prayer.

The same goes for the Pledge of Allegiance. People should be privately free to insert “under God”—or not. The legislature should stay out of it, giving no official stamp of approval for or against “under God.”

As to “evicting crosses from parks,” the issue is public parks vs. private ones. As long as “public”—tax supported—parks exist, any display carries the implicit sanction of government. Of course, Christians, being taxpayers, can rightly claim that as partial owners of the parks, they have a right to display religious symbols. But then the same can be said of secular groups. These kinds of conflicts are inevitable with any kind of “public” ownership.

But Flax is wrong that “Modern denizens of political correctness [secularists] reckon the Founders so irreligious that they had sought to diminish spiritual influence.” Did they really? Or did they seek to separate government influence from private influence—a crucial difference. Look around. Churches are as numerous as gas stations and Dunkin Doughnuts. No one ever proposed eliminating religious displays in front of private homes; or banning private religious practice in public, so long as there is no implied government sanction. The Founders sought to protect private “spiritual”—religious—influence on the basis of “To each, his—not government’s—own.”

America as a Christian nation would be a nation ruled by biblical edicts rather than objective laws. Under such a regime, non-Christians—and even minority Christian sects outside the Christian mainstream—would be, at best, second-class citizens and, at worst, subject to persecution and even imprisonment or death. America would be, in essence, a Christian Iran.

It should be remembered that secular government does not mean atheistic government. It means a government that is neutral in the field of ideas, neither promoting nor forbidding any belief system, but protecting freedom of conscience so long as one’s actions don’t violate the rights of others. This distinction is important. A secular state is neither anti-Christian nor pro-Atheist. It is what America was intended to be; a government of laws and not of men.

Related Reading:


My Commentary on Church-State Separation

Saturday, March 7, 2015

Protecting Oil Companies’ Rights is Not a Government Subsidy

In commenting on an article "Oil divestment is investing in climate change solutions" (which I addressed in The “Divest-Invest Philanthropy” Movement and its Statist Roots), the correspondent “gyre” had this to say:


I don't believe there has ever been nor will be an energy source as heavily subsidized by public money as oil was and is still subsidized.


The charge that the oil industry is subsidized is nothing new. What’s different about gyre’s charge is the nature of the “subsidy” he asserts:


Think of energy and national security for one moment. How many trillions of dollars have been spent on oil acquisition (cheap federal land grants and transportation routes) and protection. Is there any doubt that the deployment of our troops throughout the world and all those "boots on the ground" in the Middle East are not related to the acquisition of oil and the control of oil refineries? Even the Navy has been involved with the protection of shipping lanes for oil tankers and the deployment of ships to the Arctic region in order to protect our interest in the oil locked in the seabeds under the Arctic ocean. Both Russia and China are very interested in the oil above the Arctic Circle. This may lead to future conflicts with them. It's a no win situation for all parties and it's becoming more costly to maintain our oil dependence.


I left these comments:


Where does the “public money” come from? Taxes; a large amount of which is paid out of profits, wages, dividends, and salaries earned by the fossil fuel industry. If the oil industry is “heavily subsidized,” then so is every other self-supporting, tax-paying industry. In fact, given that most of our prosperity— and thus “public money”—comes from prosperity powered by fossil fuels (which you yourself readily acknowledge), the notion that oil is the most subsidized energy source is patently absurd.


A subsidy is a direct payout from taxpayers to recipients, not an indirect benefit producers’ own taxes fund, such as a military that protects the rights of American energy producers and America’s national security interests. Some companies do get actual subsidies; e.g., solar, wind, and ethanol companies. I say let’s end all corporate welfare, lower and flatten corporate income taxes in exchange for elimination of all special tax provisions, and create a level market [tax] playing field for all energy technologies and producers. Then we’ll see who really needs subsidies to survive.


It’s not just the oil industry that’s protected by our military. It takes consumers to sustain an industry. By protecting oil company’s rights, the government protects every consumer of their products; the products that power your car, heat and cool your home, provide illumination at night, produce and cook your food, etc., etc., etc.


Notice also the selectivity. Those shipping lanes carry all manner of commerce. Why single out only oil companies and their consumers as recipients of this alleged “subsidy”. Trillions of dollars of merchandise produced by myriad industries and passing through those shipping lanes are also protected by our Navy.


Gyre’s premise is circular: The government doing its job is a subsidy. To whom? To the very people whose taxes fund the subsidy, without which there is no subsidy. Gyre’s selectivity is nothing more than irrational bias against oil companies that falls apart on examination.


Related Reading:


Thursday, March 5, 2015

How Government Regulation is Corrupt by its Very Nature

The New Jersey Star-Ledger—an unwavering pro-regulation champion—ran an op-ed titled Wall Street banks and federal regulators are still too chummy. This interesting piece actually exposes the essentially corrupt nature of government regulation of business:

Another cortex-shattering example of Wall Street’s unfettered existence arose last week, with reports about the chummy relationship between banking leviathan Goldman Sachs and the agency that is in charge of its regulation, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.

Goldman . . . has Fed regulators literally working inside its office, ostensibly acting as a watchdog who keeps the bank on good behavior.

That can lead to what is known as regulatory capture. If that sounds like a body-snatching thing, it's in that vein: They become pals, banks co-opt the regulators, and the rules become fungible.

Given that all-encompassing nature of banking regulation, how do the editors expect regulators to do their jobs without having offices inside the largest banks? No answer. Since banks’s very survival depends on satisfying regulators, what’s so surprising about bankers cultivating relationships with the people who have a stranglehold on their careers? Does anyone seriously believe bankers would be better off antagonizing the regulators? And as for the regulators, the editors write:

After that crash, The Fed commissioned a report to investigate how it screwed up so egregiously. This report, from a Columbia finance professor named David Beim, found that the Fed was too risk-averse and admiring of banks that it was meant to regulate, and that a culture of leniency prevailed.

Were regulators afraid to challenges their bosses? Absolutely, the report said. Were examiners afraid to alienate banks that could be their next employer? The Beim report didn’t speculate, but NPR reports that seven former Fed examiners now work at Goldman.

Regulators are just as human as bankers. That’s something statists regularly ignore, because that reality clashes with their implicit mystical view of government officials as omniscient, infallible, and superior in wisdom. But remember that the “culture of leniency” prevailed in the context of a housing bubble-led economic boom. Why would regulators challenge their bosses, who were beholden to politicians who run on the booming economy? And by what fantasy do the editors think that regulators are not motivated by the same career incentives as anyone else? Why on Earth would they want to “alienate banks that could be their next employer?” And for that matter, why wouldn’t Goldman want former regulators and their connections inside the government regulatory agencies on it’s payroll? They’d be foolish not to.

What the editors expose is not bad regulation, but the very bad nature of regulation, which leads to corruption because regulation itself is inherently corrupt.

To top it off, there was this predictable nugget:

For two decades, the Ayn Rand disciple [Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan] shunned most forms of regulation and let Wall Street operate like it was the Wild West, literally ignoring fraud because he thought the market could overcome anything.

The result was a global catastrophe, and an old man admitting that his ideology was tragically flawed, as Greenspan was pummeled into historical infamy by an angry Congress.

I left these comments:

There’s some truth here. Banks are so heavily regulated that regulators actually have offices inside the banks. Cozy relationships between banks and regulators? That’s the nature of government regulations. With their business so straight-jacketed, what else can anyone expect of bankers, but [to] get “chummy” with the regulators? This unholy alliance of business and government wouldn’t exist in a free market banking system, where the government prosecuted fraudsters and other wrongdoers but left innocent people free to operate.

That said, there are fallacies here.

First, Greenspan’s butt-covering pronouncements to the contrary, banking regulations increased dramatically in the decade prior to the crash.

Second, Greenspan was not an “Ayn Rand disciple.” He was the Chairman of the Federal Reserve Board, the biggest bank regulatory agency and owner of the monetary system. They are diametric opposites.

If you want to see a real Ayn Rand disciple in action, consider John A. Allison, who successfully guided one of the big ten financial institutions, BB&T, through the housing boom, bust, and financial crisis by avidly avoiding (as much as regulators allowed) sub-prime lending. BB&T consequently emerged as one of the strongest banks.

At the time of the crash, Allison was the longest-serving bank CEO in the United States. He is on Harvard Business Review’s top 100 most successful CEOs of the decade. His experience through good times and bad—38 years at BB&T—warrants respect. Anyone with a modicum of objectivity and honesty should read Allison’s insider's’ view of the 2008 crash; his book “The Financial Crisis and the Free Market Cure.” As Allison notes, the problem wasn’t under-regulation. It was mis-regulation. One example of mis-regulation was mark-to-market accounting rules—imposed under Bush’s big regulatory bill, Sarbanes-Oxley—which needlessly accelerated the financial death spiral and wasn’t corrected until well into 2009, too late to save the economy.

Whereas Greenspan was a financial crisis culprit because he abandoned Ayn Rand principles, Allison saved his bank because he adhered to Ayn Rand’s Aristotelian principles.

The primary culprit for the 2008 crash was government intervention into the housing and mortgage markets—specifically, the Federal Reserve Bank and the politicians’ “affordable housing” policies and crusades. Bad banks were only a secondary cause. The politicians pushed sub-prime lending on the banks through the regulatory apparatus and the GSEs Fannie and Freddie, fueled by the Greenspan Fed’s bubble-inflating easy money policies.

Contra statist apologists, government officials are not omniscient, infallible, or superior in wisdom. They are subject to the same incentives as everyone else, including protecting their turf. Just as statists perpetrated the Big Lie that unregulated markets caused and exacerbated the Great Depression, so they are perpetrating another Big Lie; that deregulated markets caused and exacerbated the Great Recession. Statists and their apologists are perpetrating this new Big Lie to protect and expand their power over the economy.

Related Reading:




Tuesday, March 3, 2015

From Employer-Based Health Insurance to Individual Ownership Without a ‘Pay Cut for Millions of Workers’

My 1/30/15 post, The Not-So-Suttle ObamaCare Extortion, highlighted comments I posted regarding the New Jersey Star-Ledger’s editorial, Republican Govs rethink stiff-arm of ObamaCare, in which I advocated transition from employer-based health insurance to individual-owner insurance. In response to my post, a correspondent wrote:


“you're asking for a pay cut for millions of workers, insurance is part of the total compensation package . . .”


I replied:


Half right. No government program can be abruptly ended. It must be phased out equitably. Insurance is a part of the employee’s compensation. No worker should get a single dollar in pay cuts. Previously, I addressed this issue on my blog:


“[B]usinesses and other third parties like unions . . . should be allowed to simply deposit whatever they are currently spending to insure their employees’ into [the employees’] own self-directed, personal tax-free health savings accounts. Individuals and families can then go forth and purchase insurance directly from insurers competing for their business. This would also alleviate a host of other problems by making health insurance portable like auto, life, and homeowners insurance, which people don’t lose when leaving a job. [Emphasis added. Rick Ungar does a nice job of explaining why health benefits are earned as part of the employees compensation, not funded by the employer.]”


No employer should be allowed a windfall at employee expense. As part of the transition, I recommend that every employer that offers health insurance should be required to give independent accounting to its employees exactly how much it is spending on employee health coverage. This would protect employees from employer fraud, and employers from frivolous lawsuits claiming fraud. Then, employees can choose rationally without fear of any back-door pay cut. Once an employer moves to employee-owned accounts, the health insurance accounts can become part of the normal compensation agreements, and altered according to voluntary agreements between employer and employee.


Ending third-party-payer health insurance needn't be a big deal.


Related Reading:





How About ObamaCare’s Victims?

Sunday, March 1, 2015

The Strong vs. the 'Weak' in the Assisted Suicide Debate

The article I wrote about in my last post, Assisted suicide laws are more dangerous than people acknowledge by John B. Kelly, drew some strong commentary in support of Kelly. One such comment came from correspondent Leslie Wolfgang, who wrote: “Brittany Maynard is a strong woman, but assisted suicide laws are to protect the weak.”


The first question to ask is; “strong” in what way? The second question; what is the purpose of law?


“Strong” comes in two manifestations; the strength of a strongman, or the strength of good moral character. The first is the power of the club or the gun or muscles—physical coercion. The second is the power of virtues like courage, independence of mind, self-motivation, perseverance in pursuit of goals,and self-discipline. The first leads to destruction and death, the second leads to a successful, self-sufficient, flourishing life.


It is the second type of strong that carries the world, including the so-called “weak,” on its shoulders—the strength exhibited by people like Brittany Maynard. Moral strength is the foundation of life; weakness the weight of death. Yet, it is the strong who are exploited and need protecting. As evidence, consider the statement above. Wolfgang would callously uphold coercive anti-assisted suicide laws that violate the rights of the strong of character to act on their own judgement regarding their own lives, in the name of protecting the “weak.” To sacrifice the strong for the alleged benefit of the weak is the ultimate moral inversion; the sacrifice of life to death. Such is the nature of the weakest of the weak; the wielder of the club against the strong of character; the Wolfgangs of the world—the strongman.


Considering the growth of the regulatory welfare state—which is justified as a necessity to “protect the weak”—it is the strong in character who need protecting, since they are the victims of the welfare statist protectors of the weak. But, in truth, proper law doesn’t protect the weak at the expense of the strong; or the strong at the expense of the weak. It protects everyone—the weak, the strong, and the mediocre—equally and at all times. Protect the rights of consenting adults of sound mind to live and leave this world with dignity, while building in legal safeguards against exploitation of the “weak” of unsound mind by the unscrupulous. Laws legalizing doctor-assisted suicide, which really means eliminating rights-violating government interference in private decision-making until and unless evidence of rights-violating actions is uncovered, is the moral thing to do. Anything else is cruel, mean-spirited, morally corrupt—and truly weak. A Brittany Maynard’s rights should not be violated simply because she is a “strong woman.”